6 ms·
There's a big difference between supply problems leading to inflation (which has an equilibrium,) and government problems leading to inflation (which has no fun
by whatshisface 9y ago
There's a big difference between supply problems leading to inflation (which has an equilibrium,) and government problems leading to inflation (which has no fundamental limit.) In one case it's best to imagine it as the price of scarce goods rising, in the other it's best to picture it as the value of notes falling. Then, it's clear that one has a bound that the other doesn't.
- wz1000 9y agoAs long as the government has the power to tax, it can shrink the supply of currency as much as it wants. There is no such "easy fix" for supply problems.
- dnautics 9y agoBut why would it ever shrink the supply of money? Much easier to take from the working class and give to cronies, then blame it on greed and capitalism.
- RobertoG 9y agoNormally, the cronies are rich people. Even if inflation could be advantageous, sometimes, for some people, hyperinflation don't benefit anyone, but it benefit rich people the less. If you have liquid or even financial assets, you don't want inflation. If somebody owns you money you don't want inflation. If you want to hire cheap you don't want government spending in the economy and making workers more expensive. So, you have an interest in scare people about become the next Zimbabwe and all that. We can be sure that the cronies are already in charge when a little inflation is sold as worse than unemployment for instance.
- mywittyname 9y agoDiscriminatory tax policies are very effective at enriching the wealthy. If you think about it, being rich or wealthy is really just having a disproportionate share of the economic output of a region. You increase this share by taking in more money from other people than you spend. Most of the time, this happens through returns on investments, but getting the government to tax someone else more than they do yourself achieves the same result (more relative assets). This is part of the reason lobbying has such a great ROI for companies.
- wz1000 9y agoSo that its currency has value? The government does not benefit from hyper inflation.
- dnautics 9y agoThe whole point of hyperinflation is to devalue sovereign debt. The ONLY entity that benefits from hyperinflation is the government.
- wz1000 9y agoThe government doesn't benefit from hyperinflation, it benefits from wiping out its debt. Taxing away the excess money after it has finished doing that prevents hyperinflation while still reducing debts. The government has the most to lose from hyperinflation, because without currency anyone will accepts, the government is severely reduced in power. With a healthy currency, the government has nearly unlimited ability to finance itself.
- jganetsk 9y agoCausality is backward here, really. Government debt and money are effectively the same thing. Growing government debt is growth in the money supply, which can lead to inflation. Governments don't try to devalue sovereign debt, they try to pay off their foreign debts. For that, they buy up all foreign currency in the market, sending the value of their currency plummeting.
- jganetsk 9y agoThe supply of money = government debt + private bank credit. So if the government runs a budget surplus or private bank credit shrinks (more old debts are paid off than new debts are issued) then the supply of money shrinks. This happens in actual economies.
- RobertoG 9y agoMaybe you can point me to an historical case of hyperinflation that was not due to a supply problem?, because I can't think of one. Zimbabwe and similar are used continuously, by some people, as an example of the problem of running government deficits. That it's dishonest or ignorant.
- whatshisface 9y agoHyperinflation can't happen without a government problem, because if they were to just do nothing the prices would reach equilibrium with the supply scarcity and then stop rising. The real question is, what happens to governments that causes them to respond to supply problems with inflationary policy? Edit: Nonexistent government is also a government problem - I didn't mean it in that way, I meant it in the sense of "problem related to government!" As for "how can you keep things running when the supply-side collapses," you could replace inflation with taxes. You could achieve the same re-assignment of value explicitly instead of implicitly: people would end up just as robbed, but the currency wouldn't have to end up devalued. (This might end up helping the economy and making people less poor in the end, since it would mean that you still get to think about your inflationary/deflationary policy decisions. Essentially nobody would choose the regressiveness/progressiveness profile of hyperinflation if given the option, and would instead probably prefer to arrange the necessary pain in some other way.)
- RobertoG 9y ago>"Hyperinflation can't happen without a government problem" I suppose that what you mean is that hyperinflation will stop at some point, not that it "can't happen". If you destroy the 80% of the economy what follows is hyperinflation. Never mind if you are in the gold standard, a fiat system or whatever. >"The real question is, what happens to governments that causes them to respond to supply problems with inflationary policy?" What happens is, it seems to me, obvious. You have to keep the services running, so, you have to pay people, but the money is not valuable anymore, so, you have to give more. What it seems that you are insinuating is that a country would be better off if the government would not try to keep the country running. I don't think this is the case. But I suppose that it is the real question.