4 ms·
I also think it's inherently silly to believe you can't be friends with people you disagree with. Some of the more lasting memories in my life came from convers
by ocdtrekkie 9y ago
I also think it's inherently silly to believe you can't be friends with people you disagree with. Some of the more lasting memories in my life came from conversations I've had with people that I couldn't be further apart from in perspective and opinion, and some of them, I'd go so far as to say I was friends with.
- fred_is_fred 9y agoHow many Nazis are you friends with? Could you be friends with someone who wants to murder "jew children" like weev? I sure hope not.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoI don't think I'm friends with anyone I'd call a Nazi or white supremacist, I don't follow everyone I've ever been friends with before, so couldn't tell you for sure noone I've been friends with isn't one today. I did have an annoyingly frustrating conversation yesterday with someone I had to work really hard to convince the footage from the Tesla in orbit wasn't shot in a studio. I'd call him a friend, I think. Definitely have some big rifts of views though.
- fred_is_fred 9y agoFlat earther versus actively advocating for the murder of Jewish children is not even in the same ballpark.
- sctb 9y agoCould you please stop posting unsubstantive inflammatory comments in this thread? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- ulrikrasmussen 9y agoRight, if we force ourselves to be declared enemies of anyone who does not share our world view, then nobody will grow, and people will just get more entrenched in their bubbles. This reminds me of a podcast, incidentally "The Daily" produced by NYTimes, where a former white nationalist tells a quite fascinating story about how he completely changed his mind about the white nationalist movement after being regularly invited to dinners by his Jewish friend whom he met in college. If anyone is interested, the episode can be found here: https://dfkfj8j276wwv.cloudfront.net/episodes/d7b8650b-3ef3-42c5-a1ce-c548463b04db/b11553ee2b88f5539c6a3d5827c84b38496d0373daca83c4f71d6d47cc359956249c3a1adbe4ad0ec89ff2c2225c641db67f5d90fe2786bfde111ba5b97d30a5/TD%20Aug%2022%20FINAL%20no%20ad%20break.mp3 https://dfkfj8j276wwv.cloudfront.net/episodes/d7b8650b-3ef3-...
- ulrikrasmussen 9y agoLet me add that listening to his story helped me understand that white nationalism, or any form of bigotry really, is mostly about identity and belonging to a group, often their own family who subscribe to the same ideals. By offering your friendship to such a person, you also offer an alternative. By declaring your friendship over because of your differences, you not only lose a friend, you also validate that other person in his/her views and help him paint a picture of you and people who think like you as the enemy. It saddens me that so many people think that it is unforgivable to have a history of friendship with a person like that, and I am genuinely scared that the fear of backlash from the internet means that public figures will be forced to reinforce a stereotypical good/evil picture of society. Then we will truly all lose in the end.
- mc32 9y agoIt's very sad that in today's climate people can't be associated with Louis Farrakhan or Steve Bannon for fear the outraged masses will make the implication to befriend such people means you submit to their particular theories of politics and other belief systems. It's utterly juvenile and should be condemned by our thinkers and influencers.
- scarface74 9y agoThere is a huge difference in my mind of being friends with someone who doesn't share your political views and someone who actively belittles a group of people because of race, sex, etc. I treat anyone in my family with a "long handled spoon" whose whole topic of conversation is about "those White folks" don't want to see "us" get ahead, and "they" are all alike or "them foreigners" are taking all of our jobs. I don't need that crap in my life. Not only from a moral perspective, but they are insulting people I consider friends, hang out with, and at the end of the day, I have far more in common with than the people making the remarks. Also, from a practical standpoint, I know they are probably talking about my family who are almost poster children "liberal elite".
- sushid 9y agoIt's fair for you to say that you don't need that negativity in your life, but remember that your family members may have experienced racism in a different era even if they're only a few decades older than you. You'd be surprised how different your day to day life as a minority would be in a different socioeconomic ladder, city, or industry. I spent my first first two years in the States bullied and called various ethnic slurs by classmates. My brother who attended the same school and grade only 6 years later never felt or received any of that, partly due to his knowledge of the English language, but also because blatant racism became totally unacceptable in grade school by that time. Now, do I hold a grudge against an entire race for that? No, in fact, my first few friends even then were all caucasians. But I can certainly see someone who grew up 10 years before be harboring some resentment because I've also seen how rapidly racial remarks can fall out of favor.
- scarface74 9y agoMakes sense. But let's take that a step further. I was just talking about this in another thread on HN. How much racism is a proxy for just overall resentment? I think my parents' families serve as a perfect case study. My parents who are now in their 70s and have been married 50 years were high school sweet hearts. They both grew up and went to school together in the segregated South and both of their parents were poor but they did scrape by. All of my parents siblings went to the same segregated school. My mom and her four siblings all graduated from some type of post secondary school - teachers, nurses, and one that owns his own car repair business. Out of my dad's siblings, he was the only one to graduate from high school or college. One side, all of them beat the odds and experienced upward mobility and the other side for the most part didn't. So which side of the family do you think I'm referring to when I say I have to deal with some of them with a long handled spoon? My parents and more so my grandparents dealt with the brunt of the Jim Crow South. But my parents made sure that they balanced making me aware of our history without allowing me to use that as an excuse or be resentful. Of course they didn't tell me any of this while I was going to a predominantly White private school....
- vr46 9y agoHmm. In the writer’s situation, it was somewhat more than an old pal with a habit of telling off-colour jokes. Friendship involves acceptance of the other person and their values on some level, and we’re talking about a Daily Stormer writer who promotes Nazi rallies and celebrates Timothy McVeigh. I’m sure Weev is an absolute charmer. Engaging with people and being friends with them are different things.