4 ms·
This appears to be a case of "I have my preconceived interpretation of the data, and I'm not going to see how well other hypotheses match the data." The main t
by jcranmer 9y ago
This appears to be a case of "I have my preconceived interpretation of the data, and I'm not going to see how well other hypotheses match the data."
The main thrust is that the cohort test supports the Lead-Crime Hypothesis because, on average, 70s kids were more violent than 80s kids were more violent than 90s. But later in the post, he mentions that there's an important confounding factor: the crack epidemic, which starts in 1987 and winds down in the mid-1990s. This would suggest that the increase in crimes over age for 1970s from 17 to 21 or so is fueled in large part (if we look at the later graph) by the crack epidemic. If you guesstimate that the trend should be flat-to-declining, then the trend line for the 1970s absent the crack epidemic is actually rather closer to the 1980s. Similarly the numbers for 1997 and 1998 (for 1980s) seem anomalously high, and should be lowered a bit.
Put it all together, and you'd estimate that removing the suggested effect of the crack epidemic would be that there is no substantial difference between the criminality of people born in 1970, 1980, and 1990.
- cimmanom 9y agoThis hypothesis is often put forth to in the US. The strongest studies of the lead hypothesis, however, compare data across multiple countries, which regulated lead-containing paint and gasoline at different times. These studies demonstrate that crime drops in each country at a similar period after the decrease in lead exposure, and at a rate that corresponds to the rate of decrease in lead exposure.