3 ms·
I don't think there is any difference between believing something about "model-entities" and believing something that a theory predicts will be the case. You ha
by barrkel 16y ago
I don't think there is any difference between believing something about "model-entities" and believing something that a theory predicts will be the case. You haven't justified your implied assertion that predictions according to theories are not only different, but more trustworthy, than predictions according to models (theories in computational form).
- JoeAltmaier 16y agoUnless we believe that the universe is actually made of math, then Maxwell's Equations are also just a model.
- shasta 16y agoI think the argument being made isn't that "theories in computational form" are inferior, but rather something more pedantic - that there's no such thing as a "theory in computational form". Theories are about nature. A computer program that performs some simulation isn't itself a theory. The theory is "such and such natural phenomenon behaves like this here computer program."
- barrkel 16y agoWell, theories must be stored in some representation, whether it's a configuration of neuron state, ink markings in a book, verbal descriptions in sound, etc. My position is that programs are just another representation.
- shasta 16y agoProgramming languages generally don't have semantics that include claims about the physical world.
- barrkel 16y agoInk scratches on wood pulp don't have semantics either; it's the interpreter - i.e. the reader - that imbues them with semantics. Similarly, programs manipulate symbols. It's up to the person who runs the program to imbue those symbols with meaning. F=ma; that's some coloured pixels on your screen. It's also an expression of one of the laws of Newtonian mechanics. It can be used to calculate the approximate acceleration of a mass after a particular force has been applied to it. But the coloured pixels on your screen isn't doing that; you need to apply your mind. Similarly, here's a function: function calc_a(m, F) { return F / m; } That might be part of a program which calculates the acceleration due to a force. It's also just a series of bytes, which, when interpreted by a translator, will ultimately shuffle bits of electrical state around a very complex circuit. You still need to apply your mind to give it meaning.
- shasta 16y agoIt sounds like we agree - programs aren't theories. Something else is required that relates the program to the real world. Note: you could have a programming language whose semantics specify a proposed relationship to reality, just as we posit such relationships in natural language. But most programming languages don't allow such things.
- shasta 16y agoProgramming languages generally don't have semantics that include claims about the physical world.
- shasta 16y agoProgramming languages generally don't have semantics that include claims about the physical world.