3 ms·
Undoubtedly lead exposure has had a profound effect on society, and on crime levels. Lead exposure leads to reduced IQ and increased aggression. But the crime l
by InclinedPlane 9y ago
Undoubtedly lead exposure has had a profound effect on society, and on crime levels. Lead exposure leads to reduced IQ and increased aggression. But the crime landscape during the relevant period (the late 20th century) has too many confounding factors to extract data from it. For one, there's the "crack epidemic" crime wave of the late '80s and early '90s. During this period the rate of homicides committed by teens tripled and then went back to previous levels. Additionally, violent crime is correlated strongly with population density. And during the late 20th century in the US cities first began to empty out (due to "white flight") and then began to be repopulated as "yuppies" working office jobs and living in cities became more a more desirable "american dream" than the suburban family home and then later as urban centers became the core of the new tech economy. At the same time, police enforcement changed dramatically through the '80s, '90s, and later. The "war on (some) drugs (used by some people)", mass incarceration, etc. These are all tremendous confounding factors while the underlying "signal" from lead exposure is expected to be a gradual change over a fairly long period.
- vpribish 9y agoalso the legalization of abortion, increase in food and medical subsidies for expectant mothers and young families, and the general rise in wealth.
- curtis 9y agoSeparating out the confounding factors is definitely a big problem, but lots of effort has gone into just that. Drum has been following the Lead-Crime Hypothesis science since at least 2012. This blog post: https://www.motherjones.com/kevin-drum/2018/02/an-updated-lead-crime-roundup-for-2018/ https://www.motherjones.com/kevin-drum/2018/02/an-updated-le... provides an overview, but maybe not an ideal overview just because it's so long. Section 3 has links to some actual papers, and some of the other links may ultimately lead to papers, but there's so much of it that I didn't explore it deeply.