3 ms·
I can recommend MIPS assembly. It has been the only assembly I've used that actually felt like it was intended for human consumption.
by kqr 9y ago
I can recommend MIPS assembly. It has been the only assembly I've used that actually felt like it was intended for human consumption.
- userbinator 9y agoMy experience with MIPS is the complete opposite --- simple things like loading a single constant into a register require two instructions, and the lack of addressing modes is also a bit annoying. Breaking dords into bytes and vice-versa involves long sequences of shifts and logical operations, the branch delay slot is confusing to say the least, and the plentiful-yet-unhelpfully-named registers don't really make things any easier. At least ARM's conditional execution and barrel shifter are more interesting and versatile. Then again, I admittedly learned 8080 and then Z80 and x86 first, so any RISC feels too simple; but those who learned any RISC first probably feel the exact opposite.
- nbsd4lyfe 9y ago> Breaking dords into bytes and vice-versa involves long sequences of shifts and logical operations modern MIPS has "ext" and "ins", which are probably an improvement in that regard. > plentiful-yet-unhelpfully-named registers what's wrong with MIPS register names? my only comparison is x86 and that has been awful. I'm constantly looking up which registers are what.
- userbinator 9y agowhat's wrong with MIPS register names? They're not really names, just "addresses" of a different form --- and of course, 0 is not really a register. x86 register names are supposed to be mnemonic, because certain instructions are only usable with, or have shorter forms when used with, the "right" register: Accumulator, Count, Base, Data/Divide, Stack Pointer, Base Pointer, Source Index, Destination Index.
- crankybear1337 9y agoThose explanations for the x86 register mnemonics were great, thanks! To me the MIPS registers seem pretty logical too, though: $zr for zero, $sp for stack pointer, $a0-3 for arguments, $t0-7 for temporaries and $s0-7 for saved registers. Much better than the plain numbered registers on some assembly flavors.