4 ms·
I suggest people lookup "The Market For Lemons"[1] as it is a good warning for what can happen to markets with extreme information asymmetry. VPN providers lik
by slg 9y ago
I suggest people lookup "The Market For Lemons"[1] as it is a good warning for what can happen to markets with extreme information asymmetry. VPN providers like many tech companies have a huge information asymmetry over their customers. There is no way to really verify many of the claims that a provider is making, especially when it comes to something like logging. The result is that the consumer can't actually distinguish a low quality product from a high quality product. This creates a disincentive for companies to actually provide a high quality product when they can provide a product that is lower quality and cheaper to produce and still pull in the same revenue from users. If this is allowed to go on without any form of third party intervention, the end result is a market filled of products with dubious quality.
[1] - https://www.iei.liu.se/nek/730g83/artiklar/1.328833/AkerlofMarketforLemons.pdf https://www.iei.liu.se/nek/730g83/artiklar/1.328833/AkerlofM...
- lighttower 9y agoExactly what you say. Maybe the solution is to use two VPNs. That way the second doesn't know your home IP and the first has no info on the content. Like a home baked Tor.
- jsjohnst 9y agoYou don’t thing a legal authority wouldn’t subpoena both?
- yjftsjthsd-h 9y agoFirst, they can be in different jurisdictions. Second, it depends on what threat model you use; I for one am hiding from my ISP, not the government.
- cm2187 9y agoI think that’s not his point. There is a probability p that vpn providers are not providing the service they advertise (ie lemon). But the probability that both are lemons become p^2 which is much lower (subpoena-ing a provider that maintains no log is useless). Where it breaks I think is that you can chain as many VPNs as you want, only the last one sees what you are downloading, the others only see traffic to another VPN. So the authority just needs to subpoena that one.
- Thriptic 9y agoThe performance hit would be enormous
- yjftsjthsd-h 9y agoWhy? Obviously latency would spike, but bandwidth should be fine.
- jsjohnst 9y agoGenerally speaking, tunneling TCP inside TCP is a bad idea. Yes, it’ll “mostly” work with the added latency you mentioned, but it can go very poorly if the network starts having packet congestion or dropped packets. If the “outer” VPN is UDP or IPsec, then not as much an issue, but many of the VPN providers commonly used are TCP based (of the ones I spot checked from a google search anyway). And remember, since they are TCPinTCP already, you are just making the situation even more likely to occur. Further reading: http://sites.inka.de/bigred/devel/tcp-tcp.html http://sites.inka.de/bigred/devel/tcp-tcp.html
- slrz 9y agoMost VPN systems use UDP, with TCP possibly being supported as a fallback solution for when UDP connectivity is broken. The exception are things like SSH tunnels using sshuttle but they call themselves a "poor man's VPN" for a reason.
- yjftsjthsd-h 9y agoThough ironically sshuttle claims to fix this problem.
- dredmorbius 9y agoIt's not clear to me that you're referencing data asymmetries in the same sense Akerlof does. "Lemons" discusses a buyer and seller having different levels of knowledge about a product, not necessarily one another. The result, in the essay, is that buyers presume lower-quality product, and something of a self-fulfilling prophecy emerges in that sellers are aware that high-quality product won't trade on the market. This is one of several types of Gresham's Law dynamics, where Gresham's Law can be generalised to describe both asymmetries of information and constraints on complexity. The knowledge of the counterparty case verges more on one of control, in being able to know the other party's interests, motives, and/or vulnerabilities. That's ... well outside the scope of "Lemons", and has far more to do with power and control dynamics. (Though it might also result in presumptions on the part of customers of such a monopoly.) Part of the answer, in both cases, is to provide more information or trust through various mechanisms, including regulation, audits, etc. The part of the ISP market which is as described in "Lemons" is in knowing what information is or isn't collected, and how it's used. The inability to do so does lead to race-to-the-bottom tendencies, a phenomenon also frequently described as "a (sort of|kind of) Gresham's Law". Searching for variants of that phrase within Google Books is quite interesting. Examples include: legal citations, neighbourhoods, immigration/immigrants, coin, politicians, divorce law, environmental regulations, mass / popular media, television, bicycles, software, consumer electronics, and more. See also: the Tyranny of the Minimum Viable User https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/69wk8y/the_tyranny_of_the_minimum_viable_user/ https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/69wk8y/the_tyr... I've also explored Gresham's Law quite a bit: https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/search?q=%22gresham%27s+law%22&restrict_sr=on&sort=relevance&t=all https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/search?q=%22gresham%27s...
- slg 9y agoThe information asymmetry I was referencing was simply the knowledge of whether data is or is not recorded and how much is recorded. A VPN service that records more data is what I would consider a lower quality product and a lemon. Once a company starts collecting information it can use that data for a variety of other purposes such as selling it to advertisers. That extra revenue stream is what would make a lower quality VPN product cheaper than a higher quality one with no logging. Also the end result of a market full of lemons is something that develops over time. I don't think the VPN market is mature enough for buyers to have learned to presume a lower quality product. I would even argue that the information asymmetry is so extreme in the case of VPN services, that a user can purchase a product, user it for years, and still not be able to accurately assess its quality. This would slow down the development of a true market for lemons.