5 ms·
Consider that the best athletes in the world have coaches. Even if it's a cooperative endeavor, it helps an athlete to have someone else to design training prog
by scott_s 16y ago
Consider that the best athletes in the world have coaches. Even if it's a cooperative endeavor, it helps an athlete to have someone else to design training programs, objectively point out weaknesses, push them when the still have more to give, and pull them back when they've gone too hard.
In theory, the athletes can do this by themselves. In practice, they rely on their coaches.
In theory, you can read books on your own and hold yourself accountable so that you grind through difficult problems and projects so that you actually learn the material you read about. In practice, having a teacher to help you through this process makes you much more likely to succeed.
- amackera 16y agoSadly, in my experience, teachers in Computer Science degrees rarely help one through this process.
- mechanical_fish 16y agoYes. I never encountered someone who actually could have (a) sold me a CS degree, then (b) coached me properly, until after the Web was invented. The other point I'd make is that I went to grad school, and frankly in the technical subjects the professors are rarely the best coaches. Most of them have not been beginners for a long time, and their primary focus is not on how to relate to beginners. (Primary focus: How to relate to funding agencies. Secondary and tertiary focuses: How to relate to the rest of the department, and how to relate to grad students. Somewhere down near the bottom of the priority queue: Relating to undergraduates. Those profs who are primarily focused on teaching are absolute godsends, but are probably also having trouble getting tenure; such is the nature of undergraduate technical education at elite universities.) The best coaches tend to be slightly-older fellow students. Ironically, the social structure of undergraduate classes is designed to segregate students at different levels of experience; the moral of that is: You must take steps to seek out older students who are willing to offer advice.
- kkshin 16y agoI had great teachers that helped me with my education at my school and they truly enriched my learning experience.
- Paulomus 16y agoYes, my Uni experience overall has been kind of disappointing, but the good classes with interesting teachers have been amazing. Also the motivation of having to study has got me further than I would myself.
- charlesdm 16y agoThis depends a lot on the person, the school and the actual teacher. While I believe that a high quality school like Stanford, MIT, etc will have excellent teachers and will teach you a fair amount, I have yet to encounter such people. I also believe some people are just better at figuring stuff out on their own than others, which is fine. The places I went to didn't really have the passionate and good people you need for teaching imo. Sure many of these people can teach the basics, but once you get to a certain point a fair part of the students is actually a lot better than these teachers. You need more hackers, more highly skilled people. I actually remember watching some of the Stanford video seminars and those courses seemed more appealing than the stuff I was being tought.
- scott_s 16y agoThis depends a lot on the person, the school and the actual teacher. Of course. But I'm making a point about what works for most people, most of the time. In this analogy, it's not necessarily a direct mapping from coach to teacher. If the coach is part of a large infrastructure, such as on a football team, then the mapping is more direct. Teachers are only one benefit of taking an actual course. An established syllabus which has gone through years of iterations is another benefit - and this is often independent of the actual teacher. Another is the motivation. Taking a course is an investment of money and ego that self-study often lacks. People tend to be more committed to something they've invested in.
- absconditus 16y agoMost people aspire to be merely adequate.
- jey 16y agoThis kind of coaching/mentorship is probably found a lot more in a grad program than undergrad, where it's pretty much nonexistent.
- scott_s 16y agoThis is true, but that wasn't my point. I used coaching as an analogy to point out that even people who are among the best at what they do don't do it alone. There is an attitude among technical people that "the material is out there, who needs school?" which I find too reductionist. Courses are more than just the raw material; they are infrastructure, incentives, and, yes, outside help.
- tokenadult 16y agoI get the impression that some undergraduates at some colleges do get good coaching and mentorship, and I would like to hear from other HN participants if they know of examples of that.
- kd0amg 16y agoI would like to hear from other HN participants if they know of examples of that. /me raises hand It helps to be in a small department. A friend of mine at another (larger) school once asked me for advice on how to seek out letters of recommendation. The problem was that none of the professors knew who he was, since he'd only been in large lectures and never had the same professor twice. On the other hand, there were a few professors (2 in math, 2 in CS) who had taught multiple smaller classes I was in. When I was looking for recommendations, I had a lot less trouble finding professors who knew my background (including both other classes I'd taken and areas where I'd gone wandering beyond the scope of the courses they'd taught) well enough to write them. Most of the complaints I hear about professors/instructors being unreachable come from people who never make any serious attempt to reach them (i.e. so few try and so many complain that those who don't try must be a majority of those who complain). Beyond that, those who do contact the professor/instructor for additional mentoring typically aren't the ones who need it most.
- baguasquirrel 16y ago
- akmiller 16y agoBut a teacher doesn't have to be a teacher in a school setting. It could be a peer or mentor in a completely different environment (be it work or just a good friend). The success found in coaches for people who are already talented at their craft often centers around motivation and challenging that person to become even better.
- scott_s 16y agoCertainly. But such people are in short supply.
- elai 16y agoYou have to realize that IRC, forums, mailing lists, etc are often just as good or better than some random-circumstance professor, and that programming and computer science are especially well equipped in this area.
- saulhoward 16y agoThe kind of teacher/pupil coach/athlete relationship you are talking about is expressly not what Universities have historically aimed to provide. A University gives a student access to resources (including mentors), and time to study, it _does not_ provide someone to continuously watch over you in the way you describe. In fact, you are only really tested to see if you have improved once in an entire bachelor degree -- at the end of it.