11 ms·
But the climate models say that we can do this. The models are so accurate and trustworthy that we can totally predict what global climate will be 100 years in
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
But the climate models say that we can do this. The models are so accurate and trustworthy that we can totally predict what global climate will be 100 years in the future depending on whether or not we adopt Kyoto. We can also predict what they would be now if humans didn't emit CO2.
Why are you denying the consensus and being anti-science? You must also be a creationist.
</snark>
This is an interesting topic, because it really forces us to evaluate how much we actually know about climate. To draw conclusions like "the modern warming trend is anthropogenic in origin", we need to believe that our climate models are really good. So good, in fact, that they can accurately model virtually the entire climate, which is what allows us to pinpoint CO2 emissions and rule out all other forcings as the cause of modern warming.
We do this by running the models with those other forcings, but without CO2, and observe less warming. But then, we turn around and say "we can't model $geoengineering_scheme". Why not? Are our models simply incapable of predicting the response of climate to various forcings?
- leot 16y agoGeoengineering schemes are entirely novel new forcings, while the impact of atmospheric CO2 can be studied historically. This weakens your contention, but I still think you're pointing out an interesting bit of hypocrisy in the public debate (often these hypocrisies cease to exist in debates among experts).
- yummyfajitas 16y agoWe have historical data on SO2 - basically every volcanic eruption ever. That's actually not a lot of data, but it's considerably more than we know about exogenous inputs of CO2 - we have only one data point on CO2, but a handful on SO2 (Pinatubo, Krakatoa, a few more).
- anthonyb 16y agoThe models don't enter into it. You just need to observe the relative carbon isotope levels in the CO2 of the atmosphere. If the CO2 is natural, there'll be a large proportion of C-14 (it's created by interactions with cosmic rays in the upper atmosphere). If it's man made, there'll be a lot of C-12 and 13, since that comes from oil, which has been nowhere near the upper atmosphere for millions of years. Oh, and there's now enough man-made CO2 in the air that carbon dating is inaccurate for recent things (it tests as really old).
- yummyfajitas 16y agoHow does measuring CO2 levels answer the question of "what would have happened if there were less CO2 in the atmosphere?" Can we do the same thing with sulfur dioxide after a volcano? If so, all we need to do is wait for the next big volcano to prove geoengineering is viable.
- anthonyb 16y agoSulphur dioxide will lower temperatures, sure - but at what cost? The oceans are acidic enough already.
- marknutter 16y agoThe models certainly do enter into it if you want to predict what the consequences will be of having higher CO2 concentrations. Knowing that we belch a lot of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere may tell us the cause, but not the effect. That has to be done with modeling or educated guesses.
- anthonyb 16y agoMost of yummyfajitas' post seemed to be name-calling; I was responding to this point: > To draw conclusions like "the modern warming trend is anthropogenic in origin", we need to believe that our climate models are really good. Which is entirely wrong. There are plenty of other sources of data which support that conclusion.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoI'll ask you again: without using models, how do we know what the earth's temperature would have been without anthropogenic CO2? Without knowing that, we can not draw any conclusions as to whether the modern warming trend is caused by human-emitted CO2 or not. Incidentally, I devoted precisely one line of my post to name-calling, namely reversing a common ad-hominem levied against skeptics of climate modelling.