4 ms·
Democracy Index 2016
- mjfl 9y agothis is almost as bad as a strongly worded letter from the UN.
- retox 9y agoWho gives a shit. 6 down votes in as many seconds lol
- sevenfive 9y agoTypical Economist analysis. Quite accurate and perceptive -- at predicting and evaluating things which have already happened. Also, seems to be paywalled.
- fnordsensei 9y agoWhy does this list have to be predictive to be useful? Isn't it quite reasonable that it's based on past performance rather than being a guess at what might happen in the future?
- sevenfive 9y agoIt's like Moody's. More political than educational. Downgrading the US may be fair, but the main purpose it serves is driving clicks. More to the point, the fact they downgraded the US shouldn't tell the average HN reader anything they don't already know. Contrast to say, S&P. Edit: By the way, look at the way the top of the "Flawed Democracies" cluster under 8.00! I can totally believe some tweaking went on here.
- mikimiki 9y ago"Also, seems to be paywalled." No, it is not. I just downloaded it - even with a Mailinator account. Why is this post so controversial? The US democracy IS crumbling. And I would have never guessed that I will find this much resentment to this fact in the comments on HN...
- MagnumOpus 9y agoNot paywalled, just registration-walled. The data is available (CC-BY) on Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_Index#Democracy_Index_by_country_(2016) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_Index#Democracy_Inde...
- lostlogin 9y agoNote that this predates the current presidency.
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoAm I the only one surprised they ever made it to full democracy? First-past-the-post voting and the dysfunctional 2 party states it engenders would be enough for me to mark it down, never mind the new Jim crow, gerrymandering, funding model, popular vote not counting etc.
- lawn 9y agoNo you're not the only one.
- refurb 9y agoAre you kidding? Your preferred candidate doesn't win and suddenly the system is rigged?
- lostlogin 9y agoThat’s missing the point. With proportional representation you often get representatives in government even if the party you wanted to ‘win’ didn’t. You get a government that has to work with alternative views and represents a greater portion of the country’s voters.
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoIt's the "suddenly" part that I'm taking issue with. The problems with American democracy are well documented and yes "rigged" is term that objectively applies to it over many decades in many different ways. Electoral reform is underrated, I think people can't quite imagine how different things would be under voting regimes where every voter can help you, even if you're their 2nd, 3rd or 4th choice. This means that people work on projects with broad appeal, and have less incentive to demonise the people that will never vote for them. Just the fact that you can assume I'm on "the other team" from my comment is part of the problem.
- 9y ago
- rukittenme 9y agoWhat is the definition of a "Flawed Democracy" versus "Full Democracy" (as defined by The Economist)? I can't view the paper because I don't have an account.
- loorinm 9y ago>> I can’t view the paper because I don’t have an account Therein lies the flaw in the democracy.
- fnordsensei 9y ago"Flawed democracies are nations where elections are fair and free and basic civil liberties are honored but may have issues (e.g. media freedom infringement). Nonetheless, these nations have significant faults in other democratic aspects, including underdeveloped political culture, low levels of participation in politics, and issues in the functioning of governance." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_Index https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_Index
- Apocryphon 9y agoFor their 2018 report, Freedom House gave the U.S. three points less: https://freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-world/2018/united-states https://freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-world/2018/united-st... Even that bastion of conservatism admits there was fishiness in the previous elections.
- leereeves 9y ago> ... because of a further erosion of trust in government and elected officials there. Is that a sign that the US is becoming less Democratic or a sign that Americans are becoming wiser? Are politicians in higher ranked countries more trustworthy, or are their misdeeds less well known?
- aaronbrethorst 9y agoBeing too cynical and pleasantly surprised is not more sophisticated than being too idealistic and disappointed. https://twitter.com/jonlovett/status/889931964144246784?lang=en https://twitter.com/jonlovett/status/889931964144246784?lang...
- leereeves 9y agoAs a cynic I'm rarely pleasantly surprised, unfortunately.
- NicoJuicy 9y agoThere will always be some kind of corruption. The question is, if they are paying the toll/price for it. In Europe ( mostly ) yes ( you see a lot of politicians fall because they handed themselves too much money for some case). I think in America, that's not the case now.
- mamon 9y agoTL;DR: democracy is „full” when elections are won by politicians The Economist supports, and „flawed” otherwise.
- loorinm 9y agoProve it
- leroy_masochist 9y agoI'm not especially looking forward to sitting through recaps of this article with the Economist readers I know. Random observation, one nice thing about the Economist is that its readers are super handy about identifying themselves.
- narrator 9y agoI used to read every issue of the economist. I stopped when I realized I already knew what they were going to say for the rest of the article after reading the first paragraph.
- profalseidol 9y agoAin't "full democracy" means "direct democracy"? No 4 year group dictatorship.
- jstewartmobile 9y agoGotta love that polite British understatement of things... http://digg.com/2018/west-virginia-woman-ejected-donors http://digg.com/2018/west-virginia-woman-ejected-donors
- refurb 9y agoJesus, that woman is one of the reasons why I've become so cynical about politics. It's just about scoring points now. What that article should say is"woman chooses to be disruptive at public hearing, gets kicked out." If I decide to a public hearing and play rap music really loud as a protest and I get kicked out, it doesn't mean the system is broken. It actually means it works.
- jstewartmobile 9y agoSo publicly enumerating all of the little venalities surrounding a bill is the same as playing "rap music really loud as a protest"? edit: original post title was The US has been downgraded from a “full democracy” to a “flawed democracy”
- refurb 9y agoGoing into a meeting to be disruptive is not "participating in democracy". She went there to get arrested. She succeeded.
- dalbasal 9y agoI think we are (in 2018) rubbing up against the link limitations of our current democratic systems, or maybe republic systems. Our current democracies generally meet the 19th century definitions of liberalism, in that the people select the government. But I think that in the modern mind, democratic systems (eg the elected people) are supposed to conduct the pure will of the people. We don't really like the idea of representative democracy, where representatives have minds (and interests) of their own. It doesn't help that democratic political systems are very mature, with well established and understood political dynamics (parties, etc.) driving most things. Imo, what people have in mind as a genuinely democratic system is more like direct democracy. Frighteningly, we still have strong modernist mentalities when it comes to politics. Most people argue from abstract justice, and assume efficacy (if they consider it at all) to be a byproduct of justice. IE if the system directly conducted the will of the people, stuff would also work better. Realistically, we have the technology now for direct democracy but almost no experience with it. I suspect we'll see attempts made in the next couple of decades. Anyway... I wonder if the Economist is influenced by the same sentiments, and have altered their view of what democracy is (or should be, idealistically).
- hrasyid 9y agoIf you don't like "Register or log in to download this free report", it's available in Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_Index#Democracy_Index_by_country_(2016) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_Index#Democracy_Inde...