5 ms·
Sometimes I wish someone would pass a law that forbid the modern use of brands. If you are a company, anything you control should carry your own name first and
by toyg 9y ago
Sometimes I wish someone would pass a law that forbid the modern use of brands. If you are a company, anything you control should carry your own name first and foremost. It would remove the illusion of choice that the current market of manufactured goods and food strives to provide in order to avoid organised dissent.
- 45h34jh53k4j 9y agoI dont know about that, why shouldn't a corporation, effectively a person, use lawful speech to define how the world sees it? If you care enough, it easy enough to be informed about who is producing your food. I feel this is something like identity politics, and something that really does not need regulation except to allow those to identify however they wish, with no determent to others.
- cstoner 9y agoBecause a corporation should not be considered "effectively a person". Corporations are made up of people, yes, but giving them personhood is a pretty dangerous idea. Should they get to vote? Obviously, the answer has to be "no" or else people will register companies to rig elections. If they can't vote, are they really people?
- grzm 9y agoTying the definition of personhood to voting is problematic. I agree that there should be some distinction between human beings and corporations. I don’t have an answer to what that distinction should be, but I don’t think voting is it.
- hueving 9y ago>If they can't vote, are they really people? If they aren't, then what exactly are felons and foreigners?
- prklmn 9y agoIt’s a bad analogy. The better is because they don’t breath, don’t have a pulse, and don’t have human DNA, they are not really people, and should not be treated as such.
- wutbrodo 9y ago> Corporations are made up of people, yes, but giving them personhood is a pretty dangerous idea. Should they get to vote? Obviously, the answer has to be "no" or else people will register companies to rig elections. This logic is hugely flawed. Since we work off of a one-person-gets-one-ballot system, grouping people together (as in a corporation) and giving them a vote wouldn't make any sense. By contrast, you can't "use up" your speech rights: Each person is allowed an unlimited amount of legal speech, and I don't think there's a compelling philosophical argument that a group of people speaking together isn't protected. There may be _pragmatic_ arguments, but that's another ballgame altogether, since the entire point of the Constitution is that it's _not_ subject to the pragmatism/whims of the time. I'm not saying that "corporations should be legally modeled as people" is an ironclad truth, but none of your objections make sense.
- mike741 9y agothe persons in the corporation would not lose their vote. the corporation is just one additional person, meaning someone could create multiple corporate persons and multiply their vote (at least, in OP's hypothetical scenario)
- jjeaff 9y agoI think you misunderstand the argument made by many who say "a corporation is people". "Corporate personhood" is just a word the left uses to make it sound crazy. In reality, the argument is that you can't restrict a corporation's speech because using a corporation to speak is merely a form or method people use to speak. You could speak via billboards, grass roots organizations, a radio show, lettets, or even a company you own. The government can't curtail your speech no matter the method.
- lotharbot 9y agomore generally, "corporate personhood" in US law, going back to at least the 1790s and in other countries going back even longer, serves the legal purpose of establishing that when people work together to do something under the "corporate" banner (which allows them to have a succession of members working toward a common goal and pooling resources), they retain rights like speech, property ownership, and ability to enter into or terminate contracts including hiring and firing employees. This connects to the idea (expressed by chief justice Marshall) that "The great object of an incorporation is to bestow the character and properties of individuality on a collective and changing body of men."
- philwelch 9y agoLegal personhood is a concept that applies to ships, cities, states, and countries as well as human beings and corporations. It's a legal fiction that serves specific legal purposes; abandoning the entire concept because you don't think corporations should have the same set of rights as human beings is excessive because different types of legal persons already have different sets of legal rights.
- pdx 9y ago> why shouldn't a corporation, effectively a person... Why shouldn't a corporation, effectively a person, use the vast wealth at it's disposal to influence elections and steer government policy in the direction it wants? Hmmm, perhaps we should rethink this whole corporations as persons thing.
- rlkf 9y agoWho should determine the will of this corporate-person? The shareholders? The board? The managing director? If I own a stake in an index fund, how do I propagate my will proportionately to the actions of these corporations? Corporate-persons is an area fraught with agent problems, and should therefore not be allowed.
- Retra 9y agoIf corporations were people, we'd call them people. Don't start an argument on a worthless premise.
- losteric 9y agoDo you mean branding must reflect ownership? Banning the use of brands obviously won't achieve anything desirable, but requiring transparent branding seems like it will improve the consumer market's spending decisions. Of course, pro-free-market legislation will never make it through Republican-controlled Congress...
- hueving 9y agoRestricting what brand names people can use is anything but "pro-free-market".
- rfrey 9y agoThat wasn't the proposal, the proposal was to enforce better information availability to consumers by displaying the owners of the brand prominently. IANANC but my understanding is that a true market is two-sided: it requires informed consumers. Initiatives that bolster the buyer-side of the market aren't anti-market.
- underdown 9y agoCalling a newly proposed regulation "pro free market" legislation is a little orwellian.
- swsieber 9y agoOkay. How about pro-efficient markets? Because certainly markets completely unrestrained leads to rent seeking.
- losteric 9y agoHow free is a monopolized market? If a regulation outlaws monopolies, does it improve or impede the market's freedom? Regulations that improve market efficiency are good. Regulations that impede efficiency are bad. In practice, we do need regulations because real-world actors are not optimal rational agents.
- 9y ago
- fleitz 9y agoNorth Korea is always looking for defectors if you want to live in a place that forbids the use of brands. No pesky bottled water, or other consumer goods either.
- Applejinx 9y agoI'd like that. 'Sucralose' is a brand intended to seem like a substance. It's neither a sugar nor an ose: it's C12H19Cl3O8 also known as (1→6)-Dichloro-(1→6)-dideoxy-β-D-fructofuranosyl-4-chloro-4-deoxy-α-D-galactopyranoside. If you burn it at over 662 degrees you get polychlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxin smoke, which makes sense considering that you make 'sucralose' by a chlorinating process. I have some nasty reactions to the stuff and so did my late mother, who was a total skeptic to all crunchy-granola pure-foodery. I hate that they can brand a strange chemical like this with the names of natural sweeteners and then we're expected to call it by that name. Though I admit DichlorodideoxyβDfructofuranosyl4chloro4deoxyαDgalactopyranoside is much harder to say, and contains letters that aren't even letters at all.
- philwelch 9y agoYou'd think so, but Nestle already does this of their own free will and they don't really seem to suffer for it.