6 ms·
I don't understand what is the profit for movie companies in narrowing down their own market. The movie company sold the rights to show that movie in the UK to
by icebraining 9y ago
I don't understand what is the profit for movie companies in narrowing down their own market.
The movie company sold the rights to show that movie in the UK to some other company instead of Netflix, probably for more money than Netflix offered them.
Also, you're paying a fixed monthly fee, and unless you're part of the small minority that travels a lot, you're not likely to drop Netflix over not being able to watch certain movies in foreign countries, hence they didn't lose anything.
- caf 9y agoWhile only a small minority might travel (across country borders) a lot in the US, I imagine in Europe it's a much higher proportion of the population that regularly travels to other countries.
- Symbiote 9y agoThere are regions where people commute daily over the border, and even more where people commute weekly. e.g. I have a colleague who lives in Malmö (Sweden) and commutes daily to Copenhagen (Denmark). Lots of people travel into Luxembourg every day. When I lived in the UK, the director's family lived on a pretty island in Spain, and he went every Friday for the weekend. Not exactly good for his CO₂ emissions, but people do this kind of thing.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoYay, cheap airlines. When I was interning at Rutherford Appleton Laboratories in the UK, I met a cleaner who was flying back to Poland for the weekend every other week, to attend university ("extramural" is the proper term, I think?). I was pretty shocked that one can afford this on a salary of a cleaner in a government facility.
- 8draco8 9y agoEurope is small in comparison to US and in EU borders virtually do not exists exactly like between states in US. You can go and work in any country in EU if you are EU citizen without any permissions or special paper. Plus there is a lot of countries like Czech, Slovakia, Slovenia, Austria, Belgium, Denmark, Luxembourg and couple more which are so small/have so good highway system that from any place in that country you can cross the border in under 2 hours which is basically like driving from SF to Sacramento or from NYC to Philadelphia. The point is that a lot of people travels cross country in Europe, very often it's they daily commute.
- fnord123 9y ago>The movie company sold the rights to show that movie in the UK to some other company instead of Netflix, probably for more money than Netflix offered them. This is being actively addressed by the EU: https://ec.europa.eu/digital-single-market/en/copyright https://ec.europa.eu/digital-single-market/en/copyright
- guelo 9y agoUnlucky for this guy that wont help him after brexit.
- cocoggu 9y agoIn my case, my life is spent between France and China where Netflix is inexistant. I won't cancel the subscription since my family in France is using it, but it would be almost pointless to keep paying only for myself. I don't understand this practice as well, when you are paying for a DVD or a VOD service which allow you to download the file, you can still watch it anywhere. Is it illegal to bring a DVD abroad? Why don't they give you the catalog you paid for in first place, everywhere, depending on your country's bank card? Then, no more need to setup a VPN blockade. I feel these copyright companies often pick the most inconvenient option, even if it's costing them more in the end.
- cozzyd 9y agoWell.. region codes (do those still exist?) certainly make (made?) it difficult to watch DVD's from abroad on many players.
- sitepodmatt 9y agoUnless for some odd reason your going to buy a Sony or Panasonic DVD player then most DVD players work for all regions, infact if I went to the local supermarket in Thailand I think I would struggle to find a DVD player that still embraced region restrictions. Don't forget the gold plated HDMI cables
- ryandrake 9y agoLicensing a movie in such a way that it can be played in France but not Poland seems as ridiculous as licensing it such that it can be played in Pennsylvania but not Minnesota. When will this Stone Age practice go away?
- mason55 9y agoAre you saying it shouldn’t be legal? Or that the business practice doesn’t make sense? Let’s say you’re a French movie distributor. You know the French market, you know which movies will sell, you know how to market to French audiences. Because of this you can bid more on the rights to distribute movies in France than a global company that doesn’t have any specific knowledge about the French market (your return is likely to be higher and you’re liekely to have fewer failures). Same in the Czech, Romanian, etc markets. But let’s say this movie conflicts with the release of some other movie you’re distributing so you want to hold it back for three weeks. What’s your proposed solution? Tell the studio they can only sign deals with global distributors? Tell them to accept less money?
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> What’s your proposed solution? Tell the studio they can only sign deals with global distributors? Tell them to accept less money? Stop signing exclusive deals with regional distributors. If you're going to put something on Netflix, put it on Netflix world-wide. That doesn't mean you can't also put it on a streaming service based in France that concentrates on French language movies -- do both. Let them each pay you for non-exclusive global rights. You get paid more per service for an exclusive deal, but you also get paid by fewer services. Which is increasingly looking like a bad deal as the many different services proliferate. Having a hundred buyers is more profitable than having only one buyer that pays ten times as much. It's the same game they're playing with regional exclusivity to begin with -- get more buyers by dividing up the rights. Rights in one country aren't worth as much as rights world-wide but you can sell them to more people. The difference is that regional exclusivity makes customers angry and non-exclusive licensing makes customers happy.
- 9y ago