8 ms·
From an outsiders perspective this looks like a bad investment. But I'm an outsider, so I know I don't have all the information. I would love to get an inside
by jedberg 9y ago
From an outsiders perspective this looks like a bad investment. But I'm an outsider, so I know I don't have all the information. I would love to get an insiders perspective on why this is a good investment.
My two main concerns:
1) Amazon and Whole Foods: Are they not a concern?
2) Economic downturn: Will people still order groceries at a premium?
- rabidonrails 9y ago>>1) Amazon and Whole Foods: Are they not a concern? I think they are a concern, not necessarily to Instacart but to all of the grocery chains that need to compete with Amazon/WF. Since Instacart already has the tech/infra/domain knowledge to build this service out, Instacart's value goes shooting up.
- buildawesome 9y agoopinions: 1. instacart gives companies besides amzn/wf a logistics platform to ship out retail goods. It makes these other companies more competitive. This is why you see a company like Target acquire Shipt. 2. it won't be a premium if self-driving cars exist. it might be a waiting game for investors, just like how uber and lyft are floated right now.
- cryptoz 9y ago> 2) Economic downturn: Will people still order groceries at a premium? I'm not sure about the data and large trends for this, but here's my anecdote: Right now Instacart is the cheapest way for me to get groceries. Someone with a gun took my driver's license from me a few months ago, my bike was dismantled by thiefs, and I don't live within walking distance of a grocery store. Lyft/Uber there and back is $20. Bus there and back is $6 (but with added time and stress). Instacart is $5-6. Yes, eventually, it will be easier for me to bike there or to drive there, but not right now. Right now the cheapest way for me to get a large grocery trip done is Instacart. So maybe they could survive. Not everyone is in my position, but someone who works two jobs, doesn't have a car and lives far from the store...that could describe a lot of people in the near future.
- jotm 9y agoMight be time you move elsewhere, I think...
- cryptoz 9y agoIf you mean the crime, that was Oakland, and I have recently left. But I still don't currently live near a grocery store. Maybe next move.
- jotm 9y agoYeah, no way I'm sticking around an area after having my stuff stolen and being mugged at gunpoint. Unless you own property (and even then), I'd find somewhere else... I'm currently 25 minutes walking distance from a grocery store (not counting the small convenience stores), I got used to just walking to it and buying a limited amount, enough for about a week. Driving is faster, but then I buy more, eat more and the rest goes bad...
- lazerpants 9y ago>Someone with a gun took my driver's license from me a few months ago Unless this person was a police officer, and you're glossing over a lot of the story, you can obtain a new one at your local DMV and resume operation of motor vehicles...
- cryptoz 9y ago> you can obtain a new one at your local DMV and resume operation of motor vehicles... No, my driver's license was from another country. It would have required either thousands of dollars to replace or re-taking the test in the US. Neither options has been something I can do just yet. I'll take the US test soon. If you're going to victim-shame and tell me, <<oh you just nearly got shot, what's the big deal, just hop on down to the DMV! It's your fault you can't drive a car right now>> that's not exactly such as simple thing to do and would be seriously rude.
- 9y ago
- roymurdock 9y agoI assume instacart has a liquidity event (IPO) lined up for the near future (next 12 months), and a few late stage and previous investors are laying down a cash runway to get the company there. Notably this round ($200m) was less than their last round 1 year ago ($400m) so it seems growth has slowed and its time for an exit. So its not a bet, its a holdover cash infusion until the IPO, and is not exactly risky given how mature and well-capitalized the company is at this point. The only real bet is that they'll be able to IPO before a market downturn, which seems pretty safe, I have yet to see anyone put forth and truly plausible triggers for another large global recession - there are no debt and enforcement chains I can see that would drag the system under again. But I'm not a financial expert, just an armchair economist, and if I knew what would trigger the next recession I wouldn't be posting here ;)
- jjxw 9y agoFrom one armchair economist to another I suspect the Federal Reserve will have something to do with what I wouldn't call a "recession" per se, but a slowing of growth through interest rate hikes.
- roymurdock 9y agoFed doesn't have much room to play with interest rates currently, and won't until we see a meaningful pickup in productivity, or else they risk further depressing investment into productive assets and rerouting it into speculative assets (high interest rate = high cost of borrowing/lending = high friction = slows economy down). We would observe a productivity increase through wage growth, as would be expected in a high employment environment (high demand for labor, low supply sets price of labor [wages] high) but I don't see anything from my viewpoint within the embedded and IoT industry that will meaningfully increase productivity in the near future. So more of the same we are experiencing now Unless you see some new tech that will improve productivity, in which case please do share!
- jjxw 9y agoAh - that's an interesting perspective I had not considered. I was basing my prediction on the stronger than expected job gains, GDP growth forecasts, and how the Fed is cutting back on quantitative easing. Keeping an eye on the US inflation report coming out this Wednesday should provide more guidance on what the Fed may do - if it's higher than expected I think the Fed will probably raise rates by another .25%.
- Xyik 9y agocompetition is a good thing, it encourages all competing parties to strive for a better product. from an investment point of view, its a bit similar to Lyft vs Uber ... pretty much the exact same business, but there is always room to eat market share.
- jedberg 9y agoCompetition is good for consumers but not investors. Investors want monopolies.
- bearcobra 9y ago>2) Economic downturn: Will people still order groceries at a premium? My wife and I have found that online ordering saves us money. Delivery from one of the local stores (Save-on-foods) costs $8-15. Instead of grabbing random items off the shelves because we're hungry or the store put up an enticing display of sugary cereal, we plan out our meals for the week and only buy what we need. That easily offsets the cost of delivery, while also giving us extra leisure time and saving on gas/vehicle wear & tear.
- jpalmer 9y ago3) The grocery stores in my area (midwest) already provide this service at no additional markup and free delivery if you spend over $100.
- pj_mukh 9y ago"1) Amazon and Whole Foods: Are they not a concern?" I'm guessing this raised happened because of Amazon/Whole Foods [1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/bizcarson/2017/11/08/instacart-adds-grocery-giant-kroger-in-retail-push-after-amazon-whole-foods-deal/#512b3b5d728f https://www.forbes.com/sites/bizcarson/2017/11/08/instacart-...