5 ms·
> every site should just have numbers as unique identifiers Do you realize how impractical it is for users to remember these numbers for every site? Until we g
by mehrdadn 9y ago
> every site should just have numbers as unique identifiers
Do you realize how impractical it is for users to remember these numbers for every site? Until we get to the stage where every non-English-speaking user and their grandma finds a password manager convenient, this proposal won't even pass the laugh test.
- mozumder 9y agoPassword managers really do need to be forced on people, not only because of unsafe password issues but because of username issues listed in the OP as well.
- mehrdadn 9y agoAt the risk of going a bit on a tangent, what password manager would you recommend for my grandma?
- greglindahl 9y agoIs your grandma Grace Hopper? Or someone more stereotypical?
- mehrdadn 9y agoNot quite Grace Hopper, just Hedy Lamarr. :-P (Wouldn't the question only make much sense in just one of those cases...? Not sure if I'm missing anything.)
- lwf 9y agoThere's a case made that statements like "so my grandma can use it" is (unintentionally) implicitly agist and sexist -- Grace Hopper worked in computing until her death at age 85.
- mozumder 9y agoGet her an iPhone or iPad, and have her use the built-in password manager.
- mehrdadn 9y agoAnything using cheaper/more common hardware? so the user doesn't have to buy new hardware and switch ecosystems just for the sake of being able to manage passwords? (i.e. anything PC/Android?)
- mozumder 9y agoIs your grandma REALLY tied to some ecosystem? Is she a Visual Studio Code developer? Does she need to manage Docker containers? Security does require new hardware because iOS is leaps-and-bounds better than any other system. There is no other option. Nothing else comes close.
- mehrdadn 9y agoI mean, if you agree that the only option for mass adoption of password managers is to get people to shell out $$$+ for new hardware and switch ecosystems, I rest my case.
- mozumder 9y agoNot sure what your case is? Were you expecting security in broken systems like Android? Instead of forcing security onto a broken system, just avoid that system? The fist step of security: stop using Android. And you haven't explained why your grandma is tied to an ecosystem. I'm honestly asking if she's a developer or not? What is her use case? Why does she need to be on a specific platform?
- Macha 9y agoAs developers we might be used to paying 100s of euros (or signing up to a contract to effectively do the same over time) on a phone, but the point is $grandma may not be willing to spend even 20% of iPhone budget (and definitely not replacing it by the time OS updates end)
- Nullabillity 9y agoKeePassXC on desktop, KeepShare on mobile.
- mehrdadn 9y agoKeePassXC doesn't support synchronization though?
- distances 9y agoWhat kind of synchronization? Keeping the database in Nextcloud/Dropbox should work fine.
- mehrdadn 9y agoInteresting... that actually works fine? What happens if you make an edit to your password database on your phone, and then make another independent edit on your PC, and then they both get a chance to synchronize? Do they both persist, or do you lose one?
- Nullabillity 9y agoI use Dropbox. I haven't actually tried that case since I rarely change my database from my phone. That said, I have had conflicts between two computers, but KeePassXC's built-in merge tool have fixed those nicely.
- distances 9y agoI can't honestly remember, it either lets you choose which file to keep or creates a copy. Might be that Dropbox and Nextcloud even behave differently. If I edit the file on mobile, I make a point of triggering the synchronization right after to avoid the problem. If you're on Android, Keepass2Android [1] is an excellent app that implements the input with a special keyboard. This avoids risking your password via the clipboard. It even comes with a no-network-permission version! [1] https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=keepass2android.keepass2android_nonet https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=keepass2androi...
- blowski 9y agoUse a paper notepad. Generate passwords by opening a dictionary at random for 3 words, with a random number at the end. It’s not as good as, say, 1Password but it’s more likely to get used. Combine it with the browser or OS level password manager. It’s good enough for grandma, definitely better than “kitten4” that she’s currently using everywhere. On a tangent, stereotyping this as “grandma” is a bit unfair. Most of my colleagues are college educated males in their 20s, some of them developers. And their passwords are rubbish, with no password manager, and no 2fa.
- mehrdadn 9y agoAside from how painful that sounds, paper notepads can easily get lost. And if she's out and wants to check stuff on her phone (or trying to check her bank account at my aunt's home, or whatever), is she supposed to carry it all around and risk getting it stolen? If that's the implication, I'd rather she just have kitten4 at that point. (And re: the grandma thing: it's nothing specific to grandmas, it's because the moment you suggest your audience is "college educated developers in their twenties" as in your case, people throw the notion of UI/UX out the window and recommend you suggest they compile their own kernel first. It seems you just can't win.)
- blowski 9y agoWe are obviously talking about a different stereotype. My “grandma” already keeps various notepads - recipes, appointments, address books. And she never has an urgent need to check her bank account while at Auntie Rita’s. As such, this fits her needs and workflow.
- aninhumer 9y agoYeah. In fact most likely, she's already written down "kitten4" in a notepad somewhere, because she doesn't trust herself to remember. So asking her to use a slightly longer password is not a massive change.
- jwl 9y agoIf we make a crude risk assessment, it is way more likely that her account will be randomly hacked by a botnet if she has "kitten4" as a password than someone actively stealing her purse to get her passwords. And if the notebook with passwords was stolen/lost, she would at least know it and be able to take preventive measures. For most people, writing (good and unique) passwords down in a notepad is a way more secure system than having the same bad password for every account.
- hx87 9y agoDashlane. Synchronization included, easy to use, works both offline and online.
- Too 9y agoCounter point: My grandma could easily memorize her own phone number - and all her friends phone numbers. ICQ also survived for years with numeric identifiers. Though yes, i agree that once the nr of accounts start going above 1 or 2 a password manager will be required.
- mehrdadn 9y agoExactly why I said "for every site".
- inopinatus 9y agoDon't underestimate the ability of non-technical people. Issuing membership numbers has been standard organisational practice for centuries and continues to work today for everything from airline loyalty schemes to international sports associations. Case in point, I operate a service that uses numeric identifiers. Going by the helpdesk queries, our users are more likely to get their email address wrong than their membership number.
- mehrdadn 9y agoHow often do your customers need access to these membership numbers, and how many such membership numbers do they deal with in their lives? If every service they used did the exact same thing as you do you think the error rate would still be so low? And how often do they forget their numbers (rather than getting them wrong)?
- inopinatus 9y agoThese questions might make sense to me if the notion of a membership number was some strange new construct that we should adopt warily until proven to work. It's amazing the results you get from treating your users like competent human beings rather than idiot cattle.
- mehrdadn 9y ago> These questions might make sense to me if the notion of a membership number was some strange new construct that we should adopt warily until proven to work. It's amazing the results you get from treating your users like competent human beings rather than idiot cattle. All this snark just to dodge obvious questions about your approach?
- inopinatus 9y agoYour demands for additional data have crossed into crude sealioning. I already offered the key data point that represents our concerns, viz. that users are more reliably remembering their membership number than an email address. Speculation on the potential scalability of this approach seems absurd given that membership numbers have been successfully used by organisations of every scale for centuries.
- kuschku 9y agoEspecially when you want to print this on your business card, or spell it out over the phone, or type it into a friend’s contacts app. 100595964940551841549 isn’t exactly usable for that. Even phone numbers, such as 01573 0677867 are much shorter, and they follow a pattern.
- mehrdadn 9y agoWould a number half as long as that not be sufficient?
- kuschku 9y agoThat number is the value Google currently uses to identify accounts. 100001702987293 (Facebook’s) is still too long. And in either case, someone will end up with huge, unwieldy numbers. By using ascii identifiers, they’ll be 3 times shorter, though. Facebook’s number is just "WvN1+8Yd" in base64. And at that point, why not allow people to choose identifiers? John.Doe.123 is still much more readable than 100001702987293
- rzwitserloot 9y agoI wonder what happens if you still get to choose a username, but the service appends at least 3 digits (randomly; the first doesn't get 001; in fact let's say nobody gets a number below 101), and does some mangling especially for really short usernames (appends something or prepends something). This gives every 'username' an effectively unlimited space of identifiers via the number suffix, and it trains users to realize that 'person who controls the account with username X' is not necessarily the same person as 'person who I know on other sites as username X'.
- corobo 9y agoDiscord (and I believe Blizzard/Battle.net) does this. Your site-wide username would be something like Example#5436 but on individual servers you can be tagged with @example
- 9y ago
- bloak 9y agoThe number is not confidential, so people would not have to remember it, nor would they have to use a password manager. Digits are much easier to spell over the phone than a mixture of letters and digits. People are used to identifying themselves with a sequence of digits. If you're dealing with the tax office, the water company, the electricity company, or whatever, you get asked for your customer number, your meter number, your reference number, and so on, and usually these consist mostly of digits. Sometimes these identifiers are way too long, or several different identifiers are unnecessarily used, or the same sequence of digits is confusingly referred to by several different names ("customer reference", "account number", whatever), but those are separate problems.
- mehrdadn 9y ago> People are used to identifying themselves with a sequence of digits. If you're dealing with the tax office, the water company, the electricity company, or whatever, you get asked for your customer number, your meter number, your reference number, and so on, and usually these consist mostly of digits. It's not a level comparison though. You don't need those numbers often, and when you do, you have all the resources you need with you, and it's not urgent. You generally need those when you call customer service, which you only do when you're at home and have time to spare. But if every email, messaging/social networking app, bank, credit card company, shopping site, etc. required me to go hunting for a 10+-digit number, I wouldn't have any trouble understanding it, but I would get fed up pretty fast.
- Yizahi 9y agoThat's why we need biometric hardware everywhere and use its data as a login, not as a password. Bio data is mapped onto a long UUID and user just sets whatever username he wants to be displayed. We even have means to smoothly transition from no hardware to 100% coverage - just allow manual UUID input for systems where biometric is unavailable - e.g. you have a pair of face/ID on the phone, fingerprint/ID on laptop and just ID on PC.
- ricardobeat 9y agoAnd gain the ability for anyone to link and track your identity across all services you use. The NSA will be pleased :)
- Yizahi 9y agoHow? UUID will be different per service. Anyway - it won't be worse than current single (2-3) email as a login to everywhere, of facebookID as login to everywhere.
- mehrdadn 9y agoSure, I can see this working in principle in a distant future. Not in the current world or the foreseeable future though.
- hawski 9y agoSerious question: what happens when you lose your finger? Or you have an accident and your face gets mangled? Or a ball hit your eye and you lose it? You have to remember your UUID? Probably it would be more like a file than a string.
- Yizahi 9y agoYou'll have to remember multiple UUIDs, one per service. Now that I think of it will be rather cumbersome. And bio data has to be editable if it will be usable at all i.e. add/delete new entries - fingers, eyes etc. Damn, it is harder than it seems. Anyway, bio data as a login should be implemented, we only need to think exactly how.
- lazyjones 9y ago> Do you realize how impractical it is for users to remember these numbers for every site? That's really not an issue. It isn't much easier to remember that I'm "John28161" on a busy site. Websites have been offering "I forgot my username" functionality for ages, so as long as you remember your e-mail address, you're fine. Also, just let users bookmark their personal profile page (foo.site.com/user/83755567565) easily and it's solved even if cookies are deleted. Apps won't have a problem either way.
- nulagrithom 9y agoYou might as well have them just log in with their email address in that case, which brings you back to the original "cruel username" problem.