3 ms·
Unless you are in an area where parking is not easy, for most Americans taking their own car easily beats taking public transit, especially if the public transi
by tzs 9y ago
Unless you are in an area where parking is not easy, for most Americans taking their own car easily beats taking public transit, especially if the public transit is buses.
1. No long walk to a bus stop or train station. In good weather, such a walk can be good, pleasant exercise. In bad weather...ugh.
2. If you have several places you need to go, the wait time at the start of each segment can really add up. Consider a trip where you want to go to (1) the bank to get some cash, (2) the post office to mail something, (3) your pharmacist to pick up some medicine, (4) a grocery store for some food, and (5) back to home. That's at least 5 waits at bus stops. Maybe more if those places are not all on the same route. A car will usually be much faster (especially if the bank has a drive up ATM and the pharmacy has a drug through pick up). (The post office probably has a drive though mail drop, but I'm assuming the post office is on the itinerary because you need to buy postage--otherwise you'd be mailing the item from home).
3. Public transit too often is treated as a collection of independent routes, each assessed in isolation when the bean counters tweak things, rather than as a complete system that should be assessed globally.
If I buy a house or condo or rent an apartment based on a good car commute to my work and good car access to the other places I need to or like to go to, there is a good chance 10 or 20 years from now I'll still have good car access to those places.
If I buy a house based on good bus routes to those places with stops close to my house and to my destinations and buses running frequently enough that the waiting is not too bad, what are the chances that will still be true in 10 years? In 20 years?
Much lower than with the car, I think. It's far too easy for the transit authorities to decide that my important routes are not getting enough ridership, and that some other, more popular router, need more resources, and shift buses away from my routes or even cancel mine completely.
I think #3 is the big one. It means that even if the public transit is good enough in my area that #1 and #2 are acceptable now, I can't count on it remaining that way long term (and in some cities, probably not even short term).
- gkya 9y agoHi, thanks for this response! I think actually it's #2 that is the big one. See, I live in Istanbul province, in a European quarter rather up north by the Bosphorus, so nowhere near the city centre, but when I go to the centre of my quarter, I can easily do all of the things you list there in about half an hour, the time spent at each place included, only by walking from one place to another. And my quarter is part of a comune (tr: ilçe) with a population of slightly more than a hundred thousand people (the province itself counts upwards of 15 million people). I guess what is different between here and the usual US city/suburb is that there shops and stuff are more laid out, where here instead they're congregated in the central areas. So once you're there often you can get all the things done, and catch the bus back home. Also, because urban trains and busses are frequent enough, we seldom need to think about the wait times. Except for the villages you can get hold of a bus in at the worst case about ten minutes everywhere. I do have to walk quite a bit to the bus stop, but that's because my part is like a little instance of a suburb between the Belgrad forests and the strait, thus scarcely populated and an exception to the general situation with the bus network. But after a 10 minute walk to the main street, it'll take less than 5 minutes to get a bus or minibüs (a private/cooperative alternative to the council's busses, pricier but more frequent) to the closest metro station. But I guess the general density of the population helps keep all this network in service, and get it to be built in the first place.
- icebraining 9y agoI agree; where I've lived in Europe, places are mostly organized as villages/towns/cities, with one or more centers where you can get everything done. Even the suburbs are usually small towns surrounding bigger cities, not just a ring of houses, so you can do all the daily activities described by the parent post without ever "going into the city".