3 ms·
Sounds great. Let's all drop the charade and serve the betterment of mankind! That's a wonderful ideal, but history has proven it to be folly. There may be an
by CivBase 9y ago
Sounds great. Let's all drop the charade and serve the betterment of mankind!
That's a wonderful ideal, but history has proven it to be folly. There may be an abundance of resources, but it's still a finite amount and humans are greedy. When a system like that scales, bad actors always take advantage.
We all want resources, but we all want things to get better too. Mechanisms like capitalism and meritocricy are the best solutions we've found for serving those two desires at scale.
They're not perfect solutions and their effectiveness is decreasing as humans are able to provide less individual value by the day. Still, we don't cling to them because we've fooled ourselves - we cling to them because nothing else has ever worked at scale for very long.
Maybe a better solution exists, but we need more than an idealistic notion of "working for the greater good" to keep it stable.
- EliRivers 9y agoAs an interesting aside, when the term "meritocracy" was created, it was a pejorative; something we should seek to avoid.
- CivBase 9y agoInteresting. It obviously has its failings - hence this discussion - but I still haven't heard of anything better yet that hasn't been proven to fall apart at scale.