2 ms·
The author is unnecessarily pejorative and dismissive of https://monthlyreview.org/commentary/did-mao-really-kill-millions-in-the-great-leap-forward/ https://mo
by ggm 9y ago
The author is unnecessarily pejorative and dismissive of https://monthlyreview.org/commentary/did-mao-really-kill-millions-in-the-great-leap-forward/ https://monthlyreview.org/commentary/did-mao-really-kill-mil... which is scholarly and well researched. If they understood population models I suspect they'd be less inclined to say it's just apologist because it weighs up the evidence pretty nicely. It felt like the article was saying ' look ma, the numbers keep going up' about Mao as if that meant they had to be more credible. That's not how it works, the rumour mill feeds more than it winnows.
Impossible for Americans to get distance from the internecine warfare between editors i suspect.
- tpm 9y agoWell, it's hard not to call an article apologist when it classifies the death of tens of millions of people as "initial disruption".
- ggm 9y agoTheir underlying point remains: basic demographics strongly suggest the post 1980 inflationary death figures are highly speculative, and lack theoretically sound underpinning. If you will forgive some whataboutism the British attitude to famine in India might give some context. Does anyone in the UK polity intend accepting their policy killed sixty million people over the life of British India? Oh, only two million in 1943. That's ok then..