4 ms·
It does strike me as something that is very difficult to retrofit. I'm not sure Apple should give up on it though, I don't want any old application I download
by tonyedgecombe 9y ago
It does strike me as something that is very difficult to retrofit.
I'm not sure Apple should give up on it though, I don't want any old application I download to be able to read through the spreadsheets in my Accounting folder.
Perhaps the emergence of Electron is a wake up call for Apple and Microsoft, there is clearly a demand for creating applications with web technologies, OS developers need to respond to that rather than letting a third party eat their lunch.
- javajosh 9y agoOne way to isolate applications, common for server daemons, is to run them under their own user. The real "human" user can sudo into any application account, and does so on application execution. Marketing would have to rename things and slap a GUI over the feature, but I don't see why it wouldn't work for arbitrary Cocoa apps. (And the screen-capture API should be limited to capturing parts of the screen the application is currently drawing to, with overlaps clipped out, etc.)
- deecewan 9y agoThat's clearly not viable, as displayed in the linked article. One of the examples of a good use for this was 1Password reading QR codes from a browser. Additionally, how would screen capture software work?
- javajosh 9y agoSo if I argue that Clojure is a great language, you'd reject that claim because you can't write drivers in it. Got it.
- ridiculous_fish 9y agoIt's a hard UI problem. The Mac sandbox overcorrects to requiring capability resources for all file accesses, while on the other extreme we have e.g. Windows UAC which trains users to roll their eyes and click through. But Apple doesn't enjoy the luxury of solving this problem in a nuanced way, because Mac apps are not acting from a position of strength. I suspect you aren't downloading lots of Mac apps today, and the reason is not insufficient sandboxing, but instead the limited selection, annoying install experience, etc. These are the problems that Apple must fix first. > Perhaps the emergence of Electron is a wake up call for Apple and Microsoft, there is clearly a demand for creating applications with web technologies 34 years ago, the Mac was new and generated developer excitement. But Apple was afraid the Mac would be dragged down via shitty DOS ports of apps like e.g. WordPerfect. Apple's response was to set a high bar via first-party "killer apps" like MacWrite, which would embarrass any such DOS ports. It worked: the Mac set the desktop publishing standard for years, decades even, and arguably still dominates. Yes, there's a demand for developing apps with web technologies, but embracing that is a losing strategy for Apple. Why should I buy a Mac to run web apps that run equally well on a Chinese Chromebook? That's ceding any software advantage. Instead Apple should leverage the Mac's unique software strengths. Aggressively evolve the Mac's unique "UI vocabulary" and application frameworks. Empower, not punish, the dedicated and passionate developer community. Ship love to the userbase (perhaps the only one in existence) that's willing to open their wallets for high-quality desktop software. And yes, tolerate web-tech apps too - but embarrass them!
- Operyl 9y agoCan you elaborate on the "annoying install experience?" I find that is completely opposite, most apps are drag and drop install (and finish their set ups on first launch, if any). Others are a very simple to click through installer. I find the installation experience to be much more .. annoying in windows sometimes. In OS X most apps are installed by dragging and dropping (well, not even required) to /Applications (usually by a folder aliased right to the right of it) and getting a "Installation Progress" in the form of how long it takes to copy data to the disk out of a compressed dmg. In Windows, most installers I run into still do the near straight run to 99%, then sit there for however long the actual installation took, or circles back 15 times.
- hamandcheese 9y agoI believe they are saying installing from the Mac App Store is an annoying experience, which I agree. It’s an inexplicably slow and clunky piece of garbage. It’s almost impressive how bad it is for a “first party” application.
- etatoby 9y agoThat's because the Mac App Store was spawned from iTunes, which has to be the shittiest piece of garbage to ever stain the hard disks of Macs.
- ridiculous_fish 9y agoBest case, installing a non-MAS app involves downloading and extracting a zip file, mounting and then copying from a disk image, and then clicking through the "application downloaded from the Internet!" dialog. Yes it's still much better than the typical Windows installer experience, but zero-install web apps are now setting the bar.
- Operyl 9y agoWe're not talking about simple, zero install web apps here. We're mostly talking about Electron apps, which are "web apps" but still downloaded in the traditional sense though.