4 ms·
I never understood this... if there was some investment strategy that beat inflation, then if everyone used it, inflation would catch up to it. So if you inves
by EGreg 9y ago
I never understood this... if there was some investment strategy that beat inflation, then if everyone used it, inflation would catch up to it.
So if you invest 10% of your salary all you're doing is saving 10% adjusted for inflation, assuming your investment vehicle doesn't do worse than inflation. And then when you retire you just live off that.
There is no free lunch. In Capitalism, millions of people are in a rat race to survive and eat.
- WalterBright 9y ago> if there was some investment strategy that beat inflation, There is, stocks average 7% returns after inflation. > then if everyone used it, inflation would catch up to it. Inflation is caused by the government printing money faster than the economy grows, not investments.
- EGreg 9y agoIt can be caused by both. Inflation is a result of a large number of people being able to pay higher prices for the same goods.
- WalterBright 9y agoThe act of spending does not create money.
- EGreg 9y agoThat is not relevant to what we were talking about.
- WalterBright 9y agoHow do you think money is created? In any case, no matter how wealthy Fred is, if Fred spends an extra $1000 on X then he has $1000 less to spend on something else. How is that supposed to result in inflation? Spending money doesn't magically put more money in one's pocket (despite wishing it did!), it means you've got less money.
- y4mi 9y agoInflation means, afaik, only that the same amount of money has lesser purchasing power than it previously had. This is an effect that can have various causes. One of them is that the government or Central Banks printed more money. Another way this could happen is if there was an influx of income in your region. This effect is less visible in today's economy with cheap and easy shipping of products, but can still be observed in objects that are pretty much impossible to ship. The only example that comes to my mind right now is housing.
- WalterBright 9y ago> Inflation means, afaik, only that the same amount of money has lesser purchasing power than it previously had. That's a tautological definition. Money's value is determined by supply and demand, just like everything else. If there's more money representing the same amount of goods, the money gets devalued and you have inflation. To understand inflation one must understand how money is created and destroyed, i.e. what determines the supply of money. Spending money faster does not create more supply, and McDonald's raising their prices is not inflationary because they did not create more money. Money is created by printing it, or by the creation of debt. Money is destroyed by burning it or by paying down debt.
- y4mi 9y agoWell, Wikipedia seems to agree with that tautological definition. While McDonald's alone increasing their price wouldn't be inflation, it could become that if a significant part of the businesses in that location increased theirs as well. It's just really hard to find examples of this today. It's mostly limited to holiday hotzones, rent and similar.
- WalterBright 9y ago> Wikipedia seems to agree with that tautological definition. It reminds me of when I saw a technical analyst on CNBC sagely note that the reason the P/E ratio was high was because the Price rose faster than the Earnings. Sheesh! It is not inflationary if McDonald's increases their prices. Spending more at McDonald's means you have less to spend elsewhere. Your spending does not create more money to replace it. Consider if the money was a fixed number gold coins instead, and you'll see that anyone raising prices does not result in more gold coins.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]