5 ms·
I never understood why social security counts as “spending”. We all are forced to put money into a fund that mathematically cannot lose money unless life expec
by hedora 9y ago
I never understood why social security counts as “spending”. We all are forced to put money into a fund that mathematically cannot lose money unless life expectancy shoots way up. When we withdraw the money according to plan, the government is not “spending” it.
The fact that congress borrows from the fund and doesn’t pay it back is a problem with the rest of the budget, not social security.
- perl4ever 9y agoMedicare also seem to me to be simply shifting dollars over time. Some people may gain or lose, but on average, it's just financing my (the average person's) health care when I'm old with money from my salary when I'm young.
- lotsofpulp 9y agoDue to demographics and inflation, you will certainly pay more into it than get out of it. Which means both social and Medicare are just welfare programs restricted to the old. Watch both become more and more means tested as the divide between haves and have nots grow wider. And the old vote in huge proportions so no one is taking away their benefits.
- perl4ever 9y agoGiven current life expectancy statistics, I expect to live to the age where I can benefit from Social Security and Medicare. In fact, I already benefited from Social Security as a child after my father died. I cannot regard the people who pay for these programs and the people who benefit from them as separate classes. It seems like there is something similar going on with the debate over healthcare. People on the right seem to conceive of the healthy and the sick as separate classes of people. But I don't, so arguments based on an inherent struggle between the two are not sensical to me. It almost seems as if the much older view of the rich and poor as separate classes has metastasized and mutated across ideological boundaries.
- wombatpm 9y agoThe excess revenues from social security are 'invested' in special government bonds that earn a fixed rate of return. We hit peak social security excess in 2008. To the powers that be a decrease in excess amounts to a loss in revenue. Wait until the social security administration cashes in those bonds, those redemptions go straight to the national debt.