3 ms·
> I dislike this reductive reasoning because it basically turns predatory businesses into saviors by taking mercy on the poor fools who dared to find themselves
by roenxi 9y ago
> I dislike this reductive reasoning because it basically turns predatory businesses into saviors by taking mercy on the poor fools who dared to find themselves with no means to feed or house themselves.
I'm onboard with a big chunk of what you are saying; we would have more if we wasted less, and we shouldn't organise ourselves such that we need to work more than we enjoy leisure time.
On to the part where I disagree - this lead sentence is absurdly one-eyed and anti-business. Employees have agency; it isn't a label applied at birth that they can't shake. It is as easy to quit as to be fired. Nobody is worse off if new sources of employment are made available.
While on the subject, I'm going to take a flying leap and say that the ideas behind there being "predatory businesses"
are going to be completely at odds with the ideas behind "their jobs are pointless". To hold both these ideas in my head at once requires the company management to literally be insane and evil. I'm going to opine that they are not both.
- redial 9y ago> Nobody is worse off if new sources of employment are made available. Sometimes yes and sometimes we are all worse, specially if the source of employment is the cause of a massive oil spill. > "predatory businesses" are going to be completely at odds with the ideas behind "their jobs are pointless" Again, not always. A "pointless company" (or government agency), however efficient, will always be full of people doing pointless jobs.
- roenxi 9y agoYou might have misread what I put between the quotation marks, "predatory company" not "pointless company". It goes a fair bit against the grain of stereotype to describe the government as a predatory employer.
- redial 9y agoYou misread what I said. Any company can be pointless, even predatory ones, and yes, even government agencies. And I never described the government as a predatory employer. The quotation marks I added to "pointless company" have no relation to the quotation marks on your comment, which seems to be the source of confusion.