24 ms·
Can you explain to me why more trade liberalization would have made Japan more able to fight the war? I don't see how your post really answers the objections I
by emodendroket 9y ago
Can you explain to me why more trade liberalization would have made Japan more able to fight the war? I don't see how your post really answers the objections I have.
- WalterBright 9y agoThe more free market and free trade an economy is, the more it is able to produce. Recall I mentioned that the US in the 1800s, for example, was the biggest free market and free trade zone in the world. It's hard to argue with the incredible results of that.
- emodendroket 9y agoThat seems like a dubious claim. Also, there are significant other differences between America and Japan. And again, an excessive reliance on trade made the war hard for them to win when belligerents quite logically stopped giving them materials that could be used first war.
- WalterBright 9y ago> That seems like a dubious claim. Pick a measurement. > significant other differences Sure. But the common thread among more successful economies vs less successful ones is free markets and free trade.
- emodendroket 9y ago> Pick a measurement. How about tariffs? Besides geographical isolation, the United States erected pretty strong barriers to any foreign competition and didn't really go in a strong "free trade" direction until after the second World War, after it had already become a hegemonic power. > Sure. But the common thread among more successful economies vs less successful ones is free markets and free trade. This article provides what I find to be persuasive arguments that the opposite is true and that successful countries do not begin to significantly liberalize trade until they are already strongly developed.
- WalterBright 9y ago> How about tariffs? They're not a measure of prosperity. They weren't particularly high in the US, either. > persuasive arguments that the opposite is true That's because it cherry-picked the data, and never looked at the magnitude of the tariffs. If protectionism produced prosperity, Cuba would be richer than Japan. And we wouldn't place sanctions and embargoes to punish countries, and they wouldn't beg for relief from them. Recall that the US itself is the largest free trade zone in the world. Do you think the US would be more prosperous if California protected itself from imports from the rest of the country?