40 ms·
The gunboats didn’t create a free trade scenario. They created merchantilist, extraterritorial trade zones. They bought Chinese goods with opium, not because t
by Spooky23 9y ago
The gunboats didn’t create a free trade scenario. They created merchantilist, extraterritorial trade zones.
They bought Chinese goods with opium, not because they were fighting for liberty and free trade, but because they didn’t want to buy silk and other goods with silver. The hard currency was needed to hire the mercenaries (who are all about cash and carry) that kept Indian peasants growing poppies.
The result of this forced trade and loss of control was devastating inflation and collapse of governance within China and the circumstances that led to to horrors of the 20th century.
- WalterBright 9y ago> forced trade Nobody was forced to buy opium. The force was in removal of the force preventing people from buying opium.
- emodendroket 9y agoThe "force" in question was forcing China to allow the sale of opium, rather than their preferred policy of not allowing anyone, British or Chinese, to sell opium and create opium addicts. Incidentally, while flying the banner of "free trade" in the two Opium Wars, the British also took Chinese territory (most significantly Hong Kong), secured rights to extraterritoriality for themselves, and expanded the "coolie" system of indentured servitude. Frankly, it's astonishing to me that anybody could try to cast the Opium Wars as the selfless British removing barriers to liberty.
- WalterBright 9y ago> it's astonishing to me that anybody could try to cast the Opium Wars as the selfless British removing barriers to liberty. I'm not pretending it as selfless. Free trade benefits both parties. Nor am I claiming other things the British did are free market. I'm only talking about removal of the barriers to the opium trade.
- emodendroket 9y agoAt the very least, you seem to think it was to the Chinese people's benefit to have foreigners force the Chinese government, at the barrel of a gun, to allow opium into the country. But the larger point is, then as now, the concept of free trade was cynically invoked to create a subordinate relationship. A thread running through the original piece is the way insisting on free trade policies in developing economies is a way to keep them from ever becoming serious competitors (the countries advocating them did not use this template to develop themselves).
- WalterBright 9y ago> you seem to think it was to the Chinese people's benefit to have foreigners force the Chinese government, at the barrel of a gun, to allow opium into the country. The Chinese people wanted to buy opium. They obviously thought it was to their benefit. BTW, the US war on drugs has not been of benefit to this country.
- emodendroket 9y agoThe Chinese government thought that allowing that would turn their country into a basket case with a shortage of hard currency and a bunch of opiate addicts. In the event, the first Opium War inaugurated the Century of Humiliation that still forms the basis of wounded Chinese nationalism, so they may have been on to something.
- Spooky23 9y agoThat's an interesting perspective. Sounds like your economic dogma is having a tunnel vision effect on this issue. This period was characterized by imperialism, mercantilist trade policy, and gross violations of Chinese sovereignty. "Removal of force" from trade wasn't a factor at all -- the other Western powers (France, Germany, US, and later Japan) weren't allowed to trade in the British extraterritorial zones. Britain didn't want "free trade", to the contrary, they wanted exclusivity.
- WalterBright 9y agoThe British wanted to sell opium to Chinese citizens who wanted to buy it. The Chinese government tried to forcibly stop that. Removal of choice is unfree trade, restoration of choice is free trade. Once again, nobody made anybody buy opium.
- WalterBright 9y agoYou're suggesting that the Chinese citizens were forced to make a free choice about whether they wanted to buy opium or not?