4 ms·
I wonder about this: > But to grasp China’s economic achievement, and its ramifications, it is imperative to ask: Why has a market economy directed by a Commun
by mirimir 9y ago
I wonder about this:
> But to grasp China’s economic achievement, and its ramifications, it is imperative to ask: Why has a market economy directed by a Communist state become the world’s second-largest?
Was China ever really a communist state? They've said so, of course, and talked the talk. But maybe it's more accurate to say the China remains a Confucian state. With an overlay that looks a lot more like fascism / national socialism than communism.
- jonathanyc 9y agoCome on. China is no utopia—it isn’t even a country I would want to live in—but equating them to Nazis instantly discredits your arguments. The Chinese model is unique, and why shouldn’t it be? They are the first country in history of their size to industrialize and become a world power. Let’s stop making cute generalizations that only serve to make ourselves feel better and think of what we actually don’t like about their system of government so we can fix it in our own. “The Chinese are Nazis!!” doesn’t help anyone.
- HumanDrivenDev 9y ago> They are the first country in history of their size to industrialize and become a world power. Are you implying that a very large country becoming a world power is somehow an impressive achievement?
- mirimir 9y agoI never said Nazi. What I'm getting at is the emphasis on strong leadership, and the belief that businesses should serve the national interest.
- emodendroket 9y agoYou said "national socialism," which is, quite literally, the ideology that "Nazi" is shorthand for.
- mirimir 9y agoOK, so I should have limited it to fascism, given that "national socialism" has become so closely identified with German Nazism. It was opponents who labeled the "National Socialist German Workers' Party" as the "Nazi Party". And there was a lot more idealistic socialism there, before Hitler and his associates took over and created what we know as Nazism.[0] 0) http://www.independent.org/pdf/tir/tir_19_04_06_znamenski.pdf http://www.independent.org/pdf/tir/tir_19_04_06_znamenski.pd....
- HumanDrivenDev 9y agoWas China ever really a communist state? What's communist and isn't needs to be defined by what happens in reality, instead of being defined by comparing it to the kindest interpretation of a utopian ideology. One might also tiresomely argue that Nazi Germany wasn't really fascist, given how radically it departed from Mussolini fantasies of a fascist state, or even Hitlers own fantasies of a thousand year Reich. But we don't, because at this stage it's tiresome. Communism is no different.
- mirimir 9y agoFor both Confucianism and communism, farmers/workers are the core of society. However, communism is, in theory, fundamentally democratic. With collective decision making. Conversely, Confucianism emphasizes loyalty and deference to wise authorities. Which does China most resemble?
- HumanDrivenDev 9y agoAgain what communism is 'in theory' is neither interesting nor relevant to reality. Say what you will about fascists, but at least I've never heard them say "Yeah but Nazi Germany wasn't real National Socialism".
- mirimir 9y agoWell, maybe that's just because there aren't many real fascists around these days. Or rather, that they use other labels, to avoid negative associations. I believe that just about all national governments are in fact kleptocracies. The powerful veil themselves in whatever ideology that's required. There are some idealists, of course. Especially at lower levels. But systems reward those who shed their ideals, and play the game.
- HumanDrivenDev 9y ago> Well, maybe that's just because there aren't many real fascists around these days. Or rather, that they use other labels, to avoid negative associations. Is there any evidence of this? I hear it a lot, but it seems like nothing more then left-wing McCarthyism. What's the far-right version of a pinko?
- muninn_ 9y agoChina was without a doubt a Communist country.
- emodendroket 9y agoI think, without a doubt, they were a communist state at least during the Mao years if not up to Deng. At this point, though, no way.
- TheCoelacanth 9y ago> Was China ever really a communist state? There are few if any states that actually consider themselves to be communist. China considers itself a socialist state that is the middle of a long process of transitioning to communism. The ruling party is named the Communist party because of what its stated end-goal for governance is, not because of their current methods of governance.