4 ms·
>> Google Translate is often almost as accurate as a human translator. This is the kind of overhyped reporting of results highlighted by Douglas Hofstadter in
by YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago
>> Google Translate is often almost as accurate as a human translator.
This is the kind of overhyped reporting of results highlighted by Douglas Hofstadter in his recent article about Google Translate:
I’ve recently seen bar graphs made by technophiles that claim to represent the “quality” of translations done by humans and by computers, and these graphs depict the latest translation engines as being within striking distance of human-level translation. To me, however, such quantification of the unquantifiable reeks of pseudoscience, or, if you prefer, of nerds trying to mathematize things whose intangible, subtle, artistic nature eludes them. To my mind, Google Translate’s output today ranges all the way from excellent to grotesque, but I can’t quantify my feelings about it.
https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2018/01/the-shallowness-of-google-translate/551570/ https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2018/01/the-s...
It's funny how the article above is claiming to speak of "the downsides" to deep learning, yet it spends a few paragraphs repeating the marketing pitch of Google, Amazon and Facebook, that their AI is now as good as humans in some tasks (limited as they may be) and all thanks to deep learning. To me that goes exactly counter to the article's main point and makes me wonder, what the hell is the author trying to say- and do they even know what they're talking about?
- cgmg 9y agoWhere is the contradiction?
- StillBored 9y agoThat article pretty much sums up what my sister in law (runs a professional translation business) says. To me, someone who doesn't have a second language strong enough to verify the accuracy of translation, I simply run things through google translate, to the target language and then run the output back to English. Its the translation equivalent of the game of telephone. Take "the fat cat sat on the mat"): "the big cat was sitting on the carpet" or "The cats of oil sat on the bed" and lots of other things which are just odd..
- Balgair 9y agoWhat does this prove? Languages are different, you should expect any automatic translation program to do something like this, as it is trying to translate without prior knowledge of the 'conversation' you are having. Many languages put a lot of meaning into a single word. Look at English. "Tank" is good example. It's either a thing that holds a lot of fluid, a thing that blows up buildings on treads, or a verb that means you are taking a lot of damage in lieu of others taking damage. One word has a lot of meaning. Then you can get into conjugations and tenses, yeesh. Google translate is not meant to be a natural language processor, it's just a dumb translator. It can't figure out context as it is just a simple text box and doesn't look at the million and one things natural language processing would use. Trying to play telephone with it just proves that a dumb text box is dumb.
- 8bitsrule 9y agoHofstadter makes it obvious that 'Google Translator' is a misnomer (and not even a naive one). Even "dumb translator" seems overblown. 'Magic decoder ring' might be closer. It's troubling is that there are, undoubtedly, people out there who actually believe that the 'translation' they're seeing is a halfways accurate represention of the original. If that accidentally happens, it's sleight-of-hand. If not, it could be dangerously misleading.
- Balgair 9y agoIt's kinda like everything Google does these days. They wow'd you 5-10 years ago, and now they've regressed. Look at Maps, it was better in 2010. Now? I have to second guess it at just about every freeway on-ramp.
- 8bitsrule 9y agoThis business of 'constant improvement' very often leads to inferior, harder-to-use product. When the person who 'got it' and 'really cared' moves on, you can see it in the result.
- 9y ago
- skybrian 9y agoThere's only a contradiction if you insist on simplistic binary thinking. (Either translation works or it doesn't. Machine learning will either solve everything or is useless garbage.) Instead, we can acknowledge that Google Translate has reached a useful level of skill (enough to usually get the gist of an article), but not enough to be fully reliable, accurate translation. The Hofstadter article usefully demonstrates how far we have to go.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago>> There's only a contradiction if you insist on simplistic binary thinking. (Either translation works or it doesn't. Machine learning will either solve everything or is useless garbage.) I'm sorry, but I don't see where in my comment it looks like I'm saying anything like that. >> Instead, we can acknowledge that Google Translate has reached a useful level of skill (enough to usually get the gist of an article), but not enough to be fully reliable, accurate translation. Hofstadter's article actually argues that Google Translate is not enough to get the gist of many passages, probably all non-trivial ones.
- skybrian 9y agoOkay, in that case I'm not sure what you're trying to say. Maybe something got lost in translation :-)
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoYou can ask me what you don't understand.