3 ms·
> The obvious reality is that HR has never been “your friend.” Rather, it is an important component of a company’s legal strategy to document and mitigate any p
by koolba 9y ago
> The obvious reality is that HR has never been “your friend.” Rather, it is an important component of a company’s legal strategy to document and mitigate any potential lawsuits that might arise from its employees, contractors, or anyone else who may interact with the firm.
Using the legal analogy should make this abundantly clear. Only a fool would think the other side's lawyer has their best interests in mind.
Simplest advice for dealing with HR is: Don't talk to HR
- gnicholas 9y ago> Simplest advice for dealing with HR is: Don't talk to HR IANAL (anymore), but I'm not sure this is true. That is, there could be certain remedies/benefits/claims that you might give up if you never put the company on notice of the misbehavior. For example, if someone offers you a promotion in exchange for romantic involvement, this would be illegal. You could make claims against the individual. But if no one ever told the company (HR or someone with mandatory reporting obligations), then the company might not be liable. And if this were a one-off situation, this makes sense — the company had no way of knowing that the bad actor was doing anything wrong. But if you tell HR or someone who must report it to HR, then the company is on notice and if they don't deal with the situation appropriately then you can pursue legal remedies against them as well. This is just my recollection from many workplace harassment trainings that we had at the law firm I worked at — I would welcome a more nuanced analysis by a specialist.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoThe trouble is, you don't know that the person you report to (HR or another person mandated to report to HR) is the harasser's best buddy. Now you're fucked.
- walshemj 9y agoSo appeal the grievance to the next level which best practice says should be over seen by some one out of the chain of command (so to speak).
- quasse 9y agoHaving recently talked to a workplace attorney about this, you are correct and the parent poster is pushing a naive and simplistic idea of how workplace litigation works. It is important that you give the company notice of bad behavior so that they can be held responsible later if they fail to stop it. That notice could come from your attorney if you want to feel more protected, but saying blanket "don't talk to HR ever" is not correct.
- koolba 9y agoThe “don’t talk to HR” is the general case. The more specific one is don’t talk to them till you’re ready to leave. That doesn’t mean you don’t keep a log of transgressions and talking points prior. It’s critical that you do. But if you approach HR with anything involving wrongdoing on the part of someone associated with your company then you better be ready to leave as well. It’s not how it should be, it’s how it is.