3 ms·
I don't think you've read so closely. What he claims here is that Britain developed its economy using a protectionist scheme and then, in a predatory fashion,
by emodendroket 9y ago
I don't think you've read so closely. What he claims here is that Britain developed its economy using a protectionist scheme and then, in a predatory fashion, imposed "free trade" (specifically the "right" of the British to sell opium) on the Chinese. This had disastrous effects on them (opium addiction is the most obvious, I suppose). Chinese people are not thankful to the British for liberating them from restraints on the free market in the opium wars.
- emodendroket 9y agoWhile I am quibbling, the idea that "Japan was not an economic powerhouse" before the Pacific War because they struggled to keep up with production of materiel is not a good one. In the Meiji Restoration Japan went from, in less than 50 years, a backwater to an imperial power in its own right that was able to win the Sino-Japanese War and the Russo-Japanese War (the latter stunned Europeans at the time). They were the strongest and richest of the various East Asian powers and were able to colonize large parts of Asia and, as the article mentions, the Europeans never did get all their Asian colonies back after Japan lost the war. Japan's real problem in the war was its lack of natural resources. It was highly dependent on imports -- in particular it was highly dependent on American oil, an obvious problem if you're planning to go to war with America. That's why the Dutch East Indies were important and they moved to capture them early (to some extent the paucity of natural resources in Japan is what motivated the project of becoming a colonist in the first place). It's really hard to see how more trade liberalization would have helped. Besides that, the productive capacity of the United States, and its insulation from attack, was exceptional among all of the powers in World War II, even the UK. I think we can still acknowledge Japan had significant industry, even if it couldn't keep up with the world's best.
- WalterBright 9y agoYes, we can acknowledge that Japan had significant industry. It did well compared with the other East Asian economies which were very un-free at the time. It did poorly compared with the US free trade economy. Even at the outset of WW2, their military equipment was inferior to the US, except in a few places (the Zero, the Yamato). Japan was economically defeated long before the bombing of Japan got in gear. Early battles inflicted disproportionate losses on the Japanese military due to inadequate equipment and supply. Japan knew their only hope was a quick, devastating surprise attack followed by a peace agreement.
- emodendroket 9y agoCan you explain to me why more trade liberalization would have made Japan more able to fight the war? I don't see how your post really answers the objections I have.
- WalterBright 9y agoThe more free market and free trade an economy is, the more it is able to produce. Recall I mentioned that the US in the 1800s, for example, was the biggest free market and free trade zone in the world. It's hard to argue with the incredible results of that.
- emodendroket 9y agoThat seems like a dubious claim. Also, there are significant other differences between America and Japan. And again, an excessive reliance on trade made the war hard for them to win when belligerents quite logically stopped giving them materials that could be used first war.
- WalterBright 9y ago> That seems like a dubious claim. Pick a measurement. > significant other differences Sure. But the common thread among more successful economies vs less successful ones is free markets and free trade.
- emodendroket 9y ago> Pick a measurement. How about tariffs? Besides geographical isolation, the United States erected pretty strong barriers to any foreign competition and didn't really go in a strong "free trade" direction until after the second World War, after it had already become a hegemonic power. > Sure. But the common thread among more successful economies vs less successful ones is free markets and free trade. This article provides what I find to be persuasive arguments that the opposite is true and that successful countries do not begin to significantly liberalize trade until they are already strongly developed.