4 ms·
Why the Culture Wins: An Appreciation of Iain M. Banks
- aerovistae 9y agoThey're kind of odd books because mostly their characters and plots are quite poor-- dull and badly written, and yet the world of the Culture stays with you because it's SO unique and SO well-crafted. Excession is the one book in the series which I found to be EXTREMELY enjoyable, good characters and all.
- wycs 9y agoPlayer of games is the only one I loved.
- boznz 9y ago.. and would make an awesome movie if done right
- ahartmetz 9y agoI agree with aerovistae and I found the plot of Player of Games particularly weak. Watching the protagonist winning the game thing didn't feel satisfying. It's hard to get excited about a game you cannot understand because it isn't explained. And the big "surprise" regarding a certain character towards the end was lame. It surprised me, a little, only because it seemed too obvious so I expected something more clever. That said, I liked the book because of the Culture.
- dhoulb 9y agoExcession is an outstanding book. (But note to others: Consider Phlebas or Look to Windward are better starter books if you’ve not read any!)
- effie 9y ago> Feudalism with energy weapons makes no sense – a feudal society could not produce energy weapons, and energy weapons would undermine feudal social relations. I do not follow at all. It is easy to imagine a powerful figure to maintain feudal order with help of energy weapons.
- ABCLAW 9y agoFeudalism is premised upon a ruling class providing their noble/warrior class with land holdings that they divide among a peasant class that labours, feeds and pays tithe to the noble/warrior and ruling classes in exchange for their land holdings. If the peasant class can fight as effectively as the knights, then why would you distribute land to an intermediate group for redistribution?
- danieltillett 9y agoYou mean like the English at Agencourt? There is a reason the English Civil War happened in England (and not just the obvious). The world would have been a very different place if the Levellers had won [0]. 0. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Levellers https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Levellers
- n4r9 9y agoBanks' main reasoning behind the social structure of the Culture is based on the idea that oppressive hierarchies become physically unfeasible in outer space. Without some sort of biological conditioning, it's practically impossible to oppress an entire section of civilisation for long since they can just live somewhere else in space. Space is inherently, physically suited to a kind of mutualistic anarchism. I think Banks has a vague outline of how the Culture formed from various subspecies which were escaping their indigenous power structures. Of course, societies with milder hierarchies do reach similar technical prowess to the Culture. However, they are often missing that "edge" that allows them to progress faster or last longer than the Culture.
- philipkglass 9y agoOne of the sharpest "edges" is that the Minds really are trusted in the Culture. Other civilizations may have AIs that are very nearly the rival of the Minds, but they aren't allowed to make autonomous decisions. So the combat reaction time and planning of the Minds is always far better than anything with a biological decision-maker in the loop. Thinking about that reminds me how slow the use of weapons is in Star Trek. The captain gives a verbal order to an officer who then has to physically manipulate a console to raise shields, fire phasers, or whatever. Hostile entities operating at machine-speeds should be able to go from "no signs of aggression" to "hull destroyed" before the captain can finish uttering his first sentence. The Culture in general has technology roughly equal to Star Trek, with the key difference that Culture people aren't technophobic dullards. But if the people of Star Trek weren't technophobic dullards, they'd quickly become too different to be relatable for most watchers. So it's no wonder that "transporters can duplicate people, or even keep them alive forever" is just one more Trek plot-of-the-week that's soon forgotten, rather than a key element of Trek's future society.
- tremendulo 9y agoOne problem that all cultures face is that of pecking order. Respecting the pecking order as animals gave us a lesser chance of death by violence within the species. But we've inherited the desire to rise up the status hierarchy and one of the commonest means of doing so is by trying to emulate the most successful. Unfortunately a high proportion of the most successful people appear to be sociopaths who seem to feed off of finding new ways to subtly weaken the culture as a whole.
- gballan 9y agoAs the article says, Banks' thing is post-scarcity [1]. It's not too difficult to imagine PS as one of two possible steady state conditions for us. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post-scarcity_economy https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post-scarcity_economy
- mdekkers 9y agoTechnically, we are in a position of resource abundance, and ready for a PS economy. Unfortunately, greed is keeping us down.
- aalleavitch 9y agoIf we ever want to develop into a Culture-style society, now is exactly the time when we need to start planning the path to get there.
- ufmace 9y agoThis is a really interesting article with a lot of insight into the way that human societies function and spread, and how the Culture works with those ideas. The thing I find doubtful though - the novels are essentially an exploration of a type of society that may happen if technology progresses in a certain way. It's interesting and fun to read about, but we don't have any particular reason to believe that technology will work in such a way to make such a society possible, or whether it's actually practical if it is. The nature of technology tends to direct a lot of the ways that societies work. The Culture essentially depends on the development of "perfect" AI. That we eventually figure out how to build General AIs that are smart and effective enough to accomplish useful things, yet never develop a desire to do things other than what their proscribed role is. Why do slap-drones become slap-drones? Do they have to volunteer for the duty, or do they just get manufactured with a desire to be a slap-drone that never changes? Can they actually be effective if they aren't capable of thinking about what they're doing and why? If they do change their minds, can they retire or switch to another job and be replaced? Who gives them their assignments and operating parameters? And the same question applies to all of the other drones and Minds and other machine intelligences that operate all of their factories and orbitals and GVSs and such. The Culture also seems to be built around everybody in it cooperating with the general goals. In our actual society, there are lots and lots of people who disagree with the general goals, or work towards pursuing different goals that not everyone agrees with. We try to form parameters for how far you can go in various directions and how to deal with people who go past the bounds. We're also generally open to the idea of that - some of those ideas and goals might be better than what we have, so it's good to let them be tried at a small scale so they can be observed and adopted more widely if they work well. We don't see much about how the Culture would deal with such things, mostly just some people and sub-societies that leave or declare themselves separate for various reasons.
- rini17 9y agoIs there any story about the Culture from within? I mean, how do the billions, that are not involved in Contact, actually live? I suspect we would find that grossly disgusting, and it would destroy carefully constructed appeal of the whole civilization.
- louithethrid 9y agoActually there are. Its mostly hobbys, games, thrill seeking sports, entertainment and useless projects (like the desert spanning gondolas at masab orbital). So its basically californication with BackUps. I find the - the ""Amish take over"" reply intersting. Maybee we can fathom for a moment the idea of cultural symbiosis here. Religious fundamentalism is self-destructive at its core- it always leads to civil war in infinite circles. But encased as a sort of mitochondria, either internal in enclaves or a filtered external refugee stream, it might be what propells a liberal society onwards, while - we -the components kept within wither away in the long run.
- thinkingemote 9y agoActually your comment seems to me to be exactly describing the conflict between the Iridians and the Culture. Iridians would see the masses of people in the Culture as being grossly idle, wasted, no meaning, and themselves as having meaning, value, and good worth. The article does pretty much say that the Culture can be grossly disgusting from the point of view outside. To answer the question straight: people in the Culture live a life of leisure, they can do whatever, they can change their bodies at will and emotions, everything is a hobby.
- animal531 9y agoThis was one of the reasons I enjoyed Consider Phlebas. It's basically an outsider looking in (and in a very unfavourable and biased way).
- aalleavitch 9y agoThere are plenty of descriptions of life inside The Culture; they essentially spend their time partying and finding increasingly complex ways to entertain themselves in an environment free of danger or responsibilities. Banks does depict plenty of members of the Culture as really shallow individuals, but their lives are not totally without conflict (largely emotional and intellectual), and there are plenty of people who decide they want to actually take on some sort of responsibility (like those who join contact), and people in the Culture are given that opportunity if they ask for it. One of the great things about the way Banks depicts the Culture is that within the bounds of the Culture’s morality people are free to live any way they choose, and even outside of those bounds they are free to form splinter groups that live differently (like the Zetetic Elench).
- thinkingemote 9y agoI heard Banks talk once and one thing he said was that the key idea with AI is that it will be good. Most of our stories about AI is that it will look at humanity and want to destroy it. He said that AI in the Culture will look at humanity and actually like it!