4 ms·
That's not what Quincy Jones says. http://www.vulture.com/2018/02/quincy-jones-in-conversation.html http://www.vulture.com/2018/02/quincy-jones-in-conversation
by DonHopkins 9y ago
That's not what Quincy Jones says.
http://www.vulture.com/2018/02/quincy-jones-in-conversation.html http://www.vulture.com/2018/02/quincy-jones-in-conversation....
David Marchese: You’re talking about business not music, but, and I mean this respectfully, don’t some of your thoughts about music fall under the category of “back in my day”?
Quincy Jones: Musical principles exist, man. Musicians today can’t go all the way with the music because they haven’t done their homework with the left brain. Music is emotion and science. You don’t have to practice emotion because that comes naturally. Technique is different. If you can’t get your finger between three and four and seven and eight on a piano, you can’t play. You can only get so far without technique. People limit themselves musically, man. Do these musicians know tango? Macumba? Yoruba music? Samba? Bossa nova? Salsa? Cha-cha?
- wickawic 9y agoI remember reading an interview with Mark Knopfler of Dire Straits. He mentions how glad he was that he never joined the singer/songwriter scene because leaning picking and rhyhhm guitar gave him the facility to play whatever he wanted. Edit: here he expresses some of the same sentiment https://youtu.be/OG__SwkV3wg https://youtu.be/OG__SwkV3wg
- watertom 9y agoYou’re wrong Quincy agrees with the article. The emotion part is what the article addresses. You gotta have that “swing” and that can’t be learned or taught, it can be enhanced, but you can’t practice into having it. As Quincy says it comes naturally, but not everyone has it. If you have the emotion part you can develop the techniques, but no the other way around. My wife is a very good piano player, but she doesn’t have “it”, she sounds like a robot playing, it’s painful to hear, but she plays in time, all the right notes, but it’s just not there. In drawing it’s most evident, some people can draw and others can’t, no amount of practice will help me. The emotion side of things kicks in more so with drawing.
- doktrin 9y ago> My wife is a very good piano player, but she doesn’t have “it” Absurdly subjective. If you can neither qualify nor quantify "it" you shouldn't start levying it as some standard of quality.
- robotresearcher 9y agoNonsense. The reason we have the concept of ‘it’ and ‘je ne sais qois’ is because we (many of us) find that a useful concept. Subjective assessment of art is absolutely allowed without rigorous metrics. The differences in timing, attack, etc from a good player and a merely competent player are objectively measurable, but a non expert can hear the difference and form an option without understanding what they are using to discriminate. Edit: fixed French spelling.
- torstenvl 9y agoL'orthographe français contient du... je ne sais quoi.
- robotresearcher 9y agoPardon. Veuillez excuser mon erreur.
- torstenvl 9y agoIl n'y a rien à excuser, Monsieur. :)
- robotresearcher 9y agoExcept I failed in my attempt to fix it and now I’m embarrassed :( !
- doktrin 9y ago> ‘je ne sais cois’ if you're going to pompously bandy a term about, you should at least spell it correctly
- GuiA 9y agoNot everyone can become Michelangelo, but anyone can become fairly proficient with a piece of charcoal with just a few months of instruction (given motor abilities that fall within the norm, but I don’t think this is what you were alluding to)
- jdietrich 9y ago>In drawing it’s most evident, some people can draw and others can’t, no amount of practice will help me. That isn't remotely true, we just don't teach children to draw. Most teachers believe that it's an innate ability and have no idea how to teach it even if they wanted to. Drawing is a straightforward skill that can be quickly learned, but it's highly counter-intuitive to most people. If you think you can't draw, pick up a copy of Drawing on the Right Side of the Brain by Betty Edwards or Keys to Drawing by Bert Dodson.
- m_mueller 9y agoYes. I see this with Japanese people. For some reason they are all able to draw better, judt like they all fold Origamis. I think it‘s just deliberate school practice.
- dkersten 9y agoI agree. I currently can’t draw for shit, but at one point I went from not being able to draw to being pretty good at it, because I practiced. Then I stopped practicing and now I can’d draw anymore. Some months ago I also watched and worked through a little bit of an online drawing course and was doing quite well, although I stopped due to lack of time and now can’t draw anymore once again. I also have no talent for sleight of hand, I’ve never been good at it, until recently, when I deliberately started practivcing for a few hours every single day (learning sleights for card illusions and caradistry). I’m not particularly good yet, but the difference from even a couple of weeks ago is huge. It takes deliberate practice, motivation and time. Sometimes, you also need a good teacher.
- DonHopkins 9y agoI only know the words he said, I don't know if he has read the article or whether or not he agrees with it. Going by his words: "You don’t have to practice emotion because that comes naturally. Technique is different." By that he means that you do have to practice technique. The title of the article is "No Causal Effect of Music Practice on Ability". That sounds like the words Quincy Jones said directly contradict the words in the title of the article, to me.
- KhanMahGretsch 9y ago>she plays in time, all the right notes, but it’s just not there. In my limited experience, I find the "it" factor which cannot be learned is the ability to keep time; that "swing" you mention. Given that your wife possesses great technical ability, perhaps self-consciousness is a factor in the perceived lack-of-emotion in her playing?
- sideshowb 9y agoI was thinking the opposite - it's possible to over focus on the technique and lack self consciousness for what the whole sounds like. Maybe it could be developed by recording and playing back, even having a go at music production.