3 ms·
"Fake News" is a political PR term; can't they just talk about returning to baseline values after being given false information? Also, this is another bad toy
by pessimizer 9y ago
"Fake News" is a political PR term; can't they just talk about returning to baseline values after being given false information?
Also, this is another bad toy problem like the trolley problem; when you hear false information about something from people that you consider trustworthy, after hearing that information corrected it's not altogether rational to return to a baseline judgment of that thing.
When you hear information from trustworthy sources, you know that something attracted the trustworthy people to examine the subjects of that information, something about what the trustworthy people know about those subjects made them think that the information had a reasonable probability of being true, and the trustworthy people thought that information was important enough for you to consider that they communicated it to you. We want things in courts to be considered in isolation, because the courts are meant to be a final arbiter, and therefore the feedback effect of suspicion feeding suspicion would tend to make the first statement of an authority figure on a person the final judgment of the state on that person. Life is different; if you disregard rumors, and the context of statements (even when ultimately disregarding the content of statements) you're missing a lot.
The problem here is who you trust, not what you trust, and the ability to update trust, not as much the ability to update judgments on things unobserved and unexperienced.
I'd submit that people with lower "cognitive skills" would tend to trust the researchers more, and think that even if the researcher has withdrawn statements about events, they must have had a good reason for thinking them in the first place, and would have made a reasonable effort to avoid lying intentionally. On the other hand, people with higher "cognitive skills" would be more familiar with the format of experiments, and assume that the researcher was lying about everything, and that "Nathalie" didn't exist.
tl;dr, basically, the researchers weren't wearing the right outfit to convince one of the groups.