5 ms·
Altered Carbon – All the DNA of great science-fiction with some missing links
- geobourazanas 9y agohttps://joannavass.typeform.com/to/Vy18OL https://joannavass.typeform.com/to/Vy18OL Hey all, we are a team working toward democratising genetic testing. We are trying to gauge how much people know about genetic testing and what people feel about it. I have a super short form (4 questions only). Would really really appreciate some input from the good folks on this channel!
- aeleos 9y agoI am currently about 5 episodes in and I am enjoying it so far. The 5th episode has kinda lost some of the excitement that the first 4 had, but I'm hoping it it picks up again. I know that this series is based on a book, and I have been looking for more sci-fi books to read. Does anyone have any insight on how the TV series compares to the book and whether it is worth reading?
- grondilu 9y agoOn reddit there is some kind of consensus that the series is great up until around episode 7, when it gets from bad to worse. I personally did read about half the book until I lost interest. So I guess the series and the book have that in common. Anyway, from what I've read the series is more or less true to the book, except from episode 7 when even I could notice some major differences (mainly the nature and motivations of the envoys).
- nightfreeze 9y agoI completely agree with the first sentence. I actually had to make an effort to watch it past the middle, where the writing gets really bad. (I stuck with it because i'm a cyberpunk fan, your mileage may vary) The book is no masterpiece, not by a longshot, but it's a fun read and I think it's miles better than the show.
- rtkwe 9y agoYeah they kind of added CTAC that kind of acts like the Envoys did in the book. I see why they did it though it gave them a way to work in more backstory and info on the Quellists that the book didn't really get into iirc.
- jcomis 9y agoIt's worth reading if you like the cyberpunk genre for sure.
- DanBC 9y agoThe books are worth reading. If you're interested in "people upload their conciousness" you might want to read some of Greg Egan's stuff. He's done a wider range, covering more situations. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mind_uploading_in_fiction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mind_uploading_in_fiction > The fiction of Greg Egan has explored many of the philosophical, ethical, legal, and identity aspects of mind transfer, as well as the financial and computing aspects (i.e. hardware, software, processing power) of maintaining "copies." In Egan's Permutation City (1994), Diaspora (1997) and Zendegi (2010), "copies" are made by computer simulation of scanned brain physiology. See also Egan's "jewelhead" stories, where the mind is transferred from the organic brain to a small, immortal backup computer at the base of the skull, the organic brain then being surgically removed.
- TylerE 9y agoI thought the book was 3rd rate "genre" (in the worst way) fiction.
- Scene_Cast2 9y agoI've only read the book, haven't seen the series. I wonder if I'm alone in my opinion - the book has a great storyline, great setting, ideas and concepts, but all the interactions seem to be heavy-handed sarcasm, and that gets old. It's almost like someone put a sarcasm Instagram filter, or applied style transfer to pretty much every interaction. I mean I get it, it's supposed to be gritty and noire - however, "edgy" (just like spicy) can't be the only flavor in a dish.
- maxerickson 9y agoI don't think it is that far out that an ex soldier that literally had their personality deconstructed is a bit jaded.
- Eric_WVGG 9y agoI’m a huge Morgan fan, but yeah, my biggest criticism is that he’s really hung up on writing about tough guys. Sequel is a banger, though, I recommend it.
- trollopTheJope 9y agoI didn't finish the book. Even for a young adults sci-fi novel, it's very badly written.
- gipp 9y agoThe show is mostly _fun_, but I definitely wouldn't call it a _great_ or well-made show, apart from the visuals. Too much clunky dialogue and half-baked subplots. In particular, there's a certain traumatized daughter whose plot never makes sense at any turn. The show seems to expect us to already know and have a major emotional investment in a character who we've never seen speak and who seems to have almost no tangible relationship to anything else happening in the show. Plus the way other characters react to what's going on with her is completely nonsensical. The show has plenty of issues but that one in particular really bothered me for some reason.
- rbaud 9y agoIn the book, which I'd recommend if you enjoyed the concepts surrounding digitized consciousness, the subplot with the traumatized daughter serves to introduce a pretty pivotal character/plot point.
- gooseus 9y agoYes, I agree... character development was very weak for pretty much everyone but Tak and Ortega, and even they were pretty shaky. I put this show in the camp good concepts, good visuals, decent fights, but the characters are just along for whatever ride the writers want to take them on. Also, the plot had my eyes rolling a little too often for my taste. Much of the future tech ended up being a hammer that could force the story through any hole they wanted while other elements didn't make sense to exist in the way they were portrayed. The Raven AI was cool, but their weak excuse for how those constructs were neglected and not used everywhere didn't make any sense given his role as the story played out.
- Joeri 9y agoPersonally, I really liked altered carbon. The acting was good, the sets great, and the story intriguing. The show doesn’t go out of its way to surprise you like GoT, but it had enough mysteries and twists to keep things interesting. The only lesser part for me wasn’t the story but the technology. I’m ok with unexplained advanced tech, but it has to make sense. Why are the only things run by advanced better-than-human AI’s hotels and brothels? Why is it so trivial to transfer minds between bodies but so difficult to make a simple backup? Why are prosthetic replacement arms so powerful they can crush metal, and why if that tech is available don’t the special ops use bodies which are all-prosthetic? Too many things didn’t make sense.
- cheschire 9y agoA very faithful adaptation that reflects most of the strengths (and weaknesses) of the source material. For example the ending felt a bit like a false summit. Solving the Bancroft murder should have been the climax of this detective novel, but the story keeps going and feels awkward afterwards. I had forgotten how badly the story lost me in the books until I was watching this show and I couldn't remember what I should be caring about. You can't build climactic tension if the viewer isn't even sure what they should be tense about! Setting aside content, I just want to say Poe's actor was fantastic, but Rei's actress just didn't deliver on the same level as the rest of the primary cast. And the sets were amazing. Some of the best I've seen on a streaming-only show.
- Eric_WVGG 9y agoThe story isn’t about the murder, though, it’s about power. If the novel (and the show) failed to sell you on that, it’s a legitimate complaint.
- nine_k 9y agoThe book definitely does not fail in this regard. The very way the murder is solved and presented to Bancroft is certainly not the stock "mystery solved, justice is restored" ending, though the mystery is solved, and justice is indeed sort of restored.
- Eric_WVGG 9y agoIt's quite a lot like Fletch, in a weird way
- darksim905 9y agoWe're complaining about Rei's actress? Such a beautiful woman deserves our devotion, haha. If anything, I was annoyed by the casting of Bancroft. It's like someone saw James Purefoy in "The Following" & decided "Yes, we want this crazy guy in this series". Sure he wasn't around for quite a bit & wasn't too central to anything other than "main good guy, solve my murder!" but his...essence bothered me. But I'm biased ;)
- walterbell 9y agoA central theme of Altered Carbon is the effect of immortality, wealth and power on parent-child relationships and social hierarchy. One of the executive producers is David Ellison, son of billionaire Larry Ellison. Another exec producer is James Vanderbilt, descendant of the Gilded Age Vanderbilts, once the wealthiest family in America. There's some overlap with virtual reality themes from Joss Whedon's Dollhouse. Dichen Lachman has a role in both shows.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rebuilder 9y agoHaven't read the book because the back cover made it sound pretty cookie-cutter. The show is surprisingly good, good cinematography, some nice visual ideas, good cast, overall a very solid cyberpunk-noir world is built. Ok, a lot of the visual design is pretty recycled - 45 degree angles make things scifi right?- and unfortunately the main plot underlying it all seems to be the usual "Rich sociopaths vs the rest of the world" dystopia that hasn't been thought out well enough to make it interesting. But despite having little real foundation, the edifice they've built has kept me interested so far.
- Symmetry 9y agoA lot of the adaption was good but so many of the changes to the plot and characters were in the direction of pushing it into a cookie cutter Hollywood show that I eventually lost patience and didn't finish. Like the changes to Quellism, making the main character more of a chosen one, the soap opera-ish familial ties, and the mystical matrix warping powers.
- philipkglass 9y agoI'm cribbing part of what I wrote about the adaptation on Ars Technica. Spoilers follow, and I have no spoiler tags here. Worst change from the book: Making Quellcrist Falconer into a technophobe and the personal love interest of long-ago Kovacs. In the book she's a famous dead[1] figure from history who a) admirably fought on the losing side of a rebellion and b) wrote a lot of quotable things. She's like a cross between William Wallace and Sun Tzu. Falconer thought that her followers could play the long game against unjust power, since human immortality made time irrelevant; she didn't argue that immortality itself was wrong. In the series she's just that tired stock character, the pseudo-wise reactionary who argues that there are Things Man Was Not Meant to Know. In the book Kovacs seems to love Falconer's ideas, but she lived before him and they weren't a romantic item. He's not interested in personally trying to fight a rebellion against the whole Protectorate, either. He's just looking out for his own skin and a few people he cares about. Making Rei into Kovacs's sister was unnecessary and again went directly against the tone of the original: it made Kovacs sad and conflicted instead of furious and calculating when it comes to permanently stopping her. The series is visually gorgeous, and if you haven't come into the series with the expectation that the same ideas and noirish conventions will be maintained from the book (as I did), you may well enjoy it better for that. [1] Yes, I read the later Woken Furies where Falconer seems to "come back" in a way, but an event from decades after Altered Carbon shouldn't have been shoehorned into the Altered Carbon adaptation this way. Or at least I thought it shouldn't have been.
- JustSomeNobody 9y agoI have not read the book or watched the show, though I want to. Should I watch first then read the book?
- philipkglass 9y agoYou should be fine watching the show first. Do you feel more satisfied with fiction when powerful villains are, by some miraculous stroke of luck, brought to justice? Or do you feel more satisfied with the logical consistency of stories where the powerful can mostly get away with crimes, because that's what power is? The latter is more like the book and noir-ish fiction in general. I also prefer the latter, perhaps because the first is just so much more common. Maybe if the standard Hollywood ending had powerful villains crushing attempts to bring them to justice I'd have an affinity for "plucky underdog triumphs against the odds" stories. But the plucky underdog pulls off an improbable win so often in popular entertainment that I'm tired of it. To believe that underdogs are actually underdogs I need to see them lose more often than they win.
- forgotAgain 9y agoMeh. Too often falls back on nudity to make up for failure to develop a more immersive environment. Said in another way, they used nudity to make up for a small CGI budget.
- kkotak 9y agoLost interest in the first 30 mins. What I saw was a contrived story timeline inconsistencies (people protesting 1960s style outside the building - really?), flying cars with drivers (who can drive and land badly - really?), stacks stored on spines (and only the richest can afford the cloud - really?), squaller living on the planet with rich living on the towers (not original by any stretch), one special living person better than everyone in the universe (again, original?, really?), a police department functioning like the 1990s, a woman detective have inexplicably drives Neo (sic) to the super villain and will inevitably be romantically involved with Neo? Please people - watch some Black Mirror and plethora of short Sci-fi films on Youtube for intellectual entertainment.
- nfriedly 9y agoHeh, I just started watching this. I wondered about the DNA-linked line of credit - how's that work if you can change bodies?
- baconizer 9y agoIt felt like playing a triple A game with great idea and visual, but with writing, acting, dialogue from a generic RPG maker by a teenager done after a Monday evening.