5 ms·
I imagine federalizing municipal pension obligations would be a better idea. It would have to follow some sort of extremely firm commitment to overfund future
by maxerickson 9y ago
I imagine federalizing municipal pension obligations would be a better idea.
It would have to follow some sort of extremely firm commitment to overfund future pensions though (future residents getting a rebate from previous taxpayers is way less hazardous than future residents getting taxed for current services).
- toomuchtodo 9y agoBoth are financially feasible with reduced military spending.
- tptacek 9y agoCan you make that argument with numbers?
- toomuchtodo 9y agoOn my phone at the moment, so I’ll have to come back with an in depth Excel spreadsheet later (and I need to do additional research on Illinois pension debt; numbers available show it somewhere between $130-250 billion). Cliff notes are military spending is ~$550 billion a year. Halving that gives us ~$275 billion a year ($2.75T over ten years) to direct towards unfunded municipal pensions that need bailing out and student loan debt forgiveness (along with other policies such as reducing the interest on student loans to zero in the interim to give borrowers relief). I also assume that social security tax thresholds are removed, preventing the need for general fund transfers to top up Social Security. My apologies if I made it sound like we could write a single check and this is all fixed. It’s more the thought that we have ample resources to resolve both issues in a controlled, orderly fashion if orchestrated by competent government representation (a guy can dream). Edit: we spent $2.4 trillion on Middle East wars
- tptacek 9y agoGotcha. How many people would a 50% military cut put out of work?
- toomuchtodo 9y agoThat’s a great question, but out of scope for modeling a financial solution to student loan and pension obligations. We’ll need a way to retask redundant military employees and defense contractors, otherwise we’re trading one inefficiency for the other. If halving military spending is a hill too far, less reduction can occur and still accomplish a student loan and pension obligation debt “wipe” (~$1.5T in total is needed). Somewhat unrelated: rolling VA spending into Medicare and implementing universal healthcare would extract enormous cost savings, further reducing DoD spending. Appreciate you asking me to show my work. I think I’m going to run for office now.
- Turing_Machine 9y agoWhat repercussions do you think a 50% reduction in military spending would have on national security?
- toomuchtodo 9y agoA reduction in readiness and force projection, but not sufficient enough of a reduction to put American soil in danger. Other countries spend orders of magnitude less than the US on their military, and remain conflict free. Our current path is unsustainable structurally, and we must switch course.
- Turing_Machine 9y ago> A reduction in readiness and force projection, but not sufficient enough of a reduction to put American soil in danger. And your qualifications for making that assessment would be? > Other countries spend orders of magnitude less than the US on their military, and remain conflict free. Those "other countries" are, in almost every case, under the defense umbrella of a country that does have an adequate military.
- tptacek 9y agoUnless you have countervailing qualifications —- in which case you should talk more about them so we can ask good questions of you —- it’s unhelpful to bring qualifications into the argument.
- Turing_Machine 9y agoNope, it doesn't work that way. The military budget is set by those who actually do have expertise in the area, not me. I don't need to show expertise to accept the judgment of experts. The OP is disputing those experts, and thus does need to show expertise.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoI admit I am not qualified to make my statement with authority, it’s simply my opinion. I’d be most appreciative if someone with significant military management experience weighs in.