4 ms·
I don't agree with the de-emphasis of salting. Salt eradicates time-space tradeoffs. Any successful scheme is going to get used by lots of people which means a
by tialaramex 9y ago
I don't agree with the de-emphasis of salting. Salt eradicates time-space tradeoffs. Any successful scheme is going to get used by lots of people which means a time-space tradeoff would be hugely valuable even if you have GPUs or even ASICs on your side.
Even an eyeball test shows the value of salt. Here are 4 million usernames and hashed passwords. Oh, 86000 of them have the same hash. Ok, those 86000 users have some easy to guess password, we'll break that first.
- Tomte 9y agoIt doesn't really eradicate time-space tradeoffs. It only mildly alleviates them. Please look up bcrypt and why it's better than a simple salt. Noone proposed getting rid of salting without another measure. And you don't "break a password first". You brute-force and compare against all of the hashes.
- simik 9y agobcrypt and scrypt are inherently salted.