5 ms·
Protonmail Online Security Guide for Journalists
- zebraflask 9y agoIs that why it's usually used for cryptocoins?
- binaryanomaly 9y agoProtonmail is certainly one of the more secure mail solutions since it's e2e encrypted not just at rest. On the other hand it doesn't support U2F yet which doesn't bring it to the top in terms of security. Regarding privacy I would say it's one of the best available solutions since everything is encrypted they can and do not read your email content.
- drdaeman 9y agoIt's still a webapp, fully served from network, without any code signing (not even SRI to match hashes against), except for the TLS layer. AFAIK they don't even have a standalone variant except for the unofficial desktop Electron app, and a beta IMAP bridge for paying customers. Basically, they still ultimately rely on trust, just like others. While they're drastically different from e.g. Gmail, trust requirement is still there. If one's well-being really depends on security, it's best to err on side of caution. Meaning, something like MailPile on the client side, very cautious non-automated key exchange, and, optionally, self-hosted email with at-rest encryption (e.g. Postfix+Dovecot+GnuPG pipe) is probably much better option than anything Protonmail can offer in their current state. Or avoiding email (as it's not yet there and probably never will be) and using something like Wire or BitMessage or whatever (I'm not a security expert) has both client-side static and auditable source code and limits metadata leakage.
- binaryanomaly 9y agoBridge is out of beta: https://protonmail.com/bridge/ https://protonmail.com/bridge/ and yes for paying customers. Given they don't sell your data it's natural that advanced features have a price. Yes there is of course trust involved as with anything. Still, for the majority of the folks it's better to trust someone else with their mail over running their own servers with gaping security holes. Avoiding email is not really possible yet and in the very near future...
- JetSpiegel 9y ago> advanced features It's an email service. IMAP is a standard, not some feature they are charitably implementing.
- aceofduh 9y agoThere’s no competition for paid email. They can literally do whatever they want.
- xfer 9y agoNo linux client and closed source. I would love to switch my gsuite account but there is no real benefit.
- binaryanomaly 9y agoComing soon. Well the end it's only email. You decide whom to trust with. Personally, I feel better with Protonmail. It's not better nor cheaper than gsuite it just has a totally different proposition as a product.
- badrabbit 9y agoWhy does it need to support u2f? Would be nice if it did but from a security point of view,it does support two factor authentication(TOTP). If you're concerned about the authenticator app being compromised then a dedicated phone or hardware token device can be configured. As I said,u2f has better security but at least financially speaking,time based OTP has a lower barrier of entry while being superior in it's security to most non-u2f alternates (phone call,sms,etc...). I don't think lack of u2f alone disqualifies it from being considered as having top tier authentication.
- pfg 9y agoU2F is the only generally available two-factor method that is phishing-resistant. Phishing accounts for a large percentage of targeted attacks, something that is highly relevant in a threat model for journalists.
- baxtr 9y agoGood idea, regarding this incident (discussed yesterday here, too) https://mobile.twitter.com/YuanfenYang/status/962002259407089664 https://mobile.twitter.com/YuanfenYang/status/96200225940708...
- dna_polymerase 9y ago> Use encrypted services (ProtonMail for email, Signal for chat, etc.) Also have a look at Briar [0] as they offer P2P communication, and the ability to route everything via Tor. As an alternative to Mail also BitMessage comes into mind, which avoids Metadata about who you contacted. Oh also have a look at drdaeman's comment in here, ProtonMail is far from the solution for secure email. [0]: https://briarproject.org https://briarproject.org
- ryanlol 9y agoIt is fucking straight up evil to disguise your marketing blog posts as "security guides" for at risk people. It is really sad that stuff like this is making it to the HN front page. The advice given here is largely NOT good. There are only a few extremely limited scenarios where you might want to choose Protonmail over Gmail. Do not use Protonmail. And for gods sake, whatever you do don't follow the advice from this "guide" and use their "Secure VPN" service. Here's a much better guide, which wasn't written with the sole intention of selling you things https://techsolidarity.org/resources/basic_security.htm https://techsolidarity.org/resources/basic_security.htm EDIT: This is just way too good to not include in here https://protonvpn.com/secure-vpn https://protonvpn.com/secure-vpn >ProtonVPN comes with Tor support built-in. Through our selected Tor servers, you can route all your traffic through the Tor anonymity network and also access dark web sites. This provides a convenient way to access Onion sites with just a single click. These guys are trying to convince people to access .onion sites through their VPN using Tor nodes ran by them...
- bgcollins 9y agoYeah, I never got protonmail. Perhaps the are legit, perhaps they are the Crypto AG of the 21st century. No way to tell.
- ComodoHacker 9y agoDo you have anything besides unfounded claims? >The advice given here is largely NOT good It may be insufficient, I agree, but what's particularly wrong with it? >don't follow the advice from this "guide" and use their "Secure VPN" service Again, do you have anything substantial? Known vulnerabilities? Negative experience? It's OK to sell things and write marketing blog posts. I'm pretty sure your company does it as well. And thanks for the link.
- ryanlol 9y ago>Again, do you have anything substantial? Known vulnerabilities? Negative experience? Since when is "public VPN services are bad" a claim which needs substantiating? As tptacek put it: VPN services. For when you want coffee-shop wireless network security, but in the comfort of your own home or hotel room. But these guys go further than most providers. These guys try to bait you into ditching Tor and relying on their Tor-as-a-service instead, which is nothing but malicious. >It may be insufficient, I agree, but what's particularly wrong with it? They tell you to use a VPN to avoid "government surveillance agencies. They try to get you to use their Tor-as-a-service, which is insane and completely defeats the purpose of using Tor. They recommend that you use their products instead of objectively better products by competitors, they don't even bother to mention the competing products. They suggest that using Protonmail to talk to non-protonmail users over email is at least somewhat secure, it is not. All the advice that doesn't amount to "use our product" is extremely limited. Key advice such as Don't use an Android phone is nowhere to be found. >It's OK to sell things and write marketing blog posts. I'm pretty sure your company does it as well. The critical difference is that my marketing blog posts do not pretend to be security guides for people who could literally get killed for following bad advice. We should absolutely be condemning Protonmail for putting this out. They can't claim to be a great provider for at-risk users while simultaneously putting them in further danger by giving them bad security advice.
- trustnot 9y agoProtonmail can't be trusted anymore, especially not by journalists. First they hack a phishing site: https://twitter.com/thel3l/status/962142015109578752 https://twitter.com/thel3l/status/962142015109578752 And when they get critical reporting for this, they claim the journalist based his story on 'unsubstantiated rumors': https://twitter.com/xFailure/status/962026777743835139 https://twitter.com/xFailure/status/962026777743835139