6 ms·
Save the CR100
- icebraining 9y agoContext: the new firmware upgrade for Sonos speakers will drop support for the CR100 controller. http://www.techradar.com/news/sonos-finally-kills-off-cr100-controller-and-long-time-fans-arent-happy http://www.techradar.com/news/sonos-finally-kills-off-cr100-... -- I have to wonder why. Planned obsolescence is an obvious answer, but if the new "standard" methods for controlling the speakers are smartphones or Alexa, it doesn't seem like they gain much from the switch. Is the protocol used by the CR100 that much of a pain to keep supporting? It makes me wonder about their software development practices.
- joelhaasnoot 9y agoThey're also claiming in the forum thread it's because of battery issues (battery getting older, more at risk for device to malfunction, etc). Seems like a bad reason to brick a device (and was likely made up once it was decided not to support)
- wilun 9y agoNote: planned obsolescence is illegal in France. I think French customers would have a quite strong case to make under that law. Sonos gives the possibility not to upgrade, so they might get away with it, but it's hard to know in advance.
- eecc 9y agoThe first effects of a world of end-to-end encrypted media streaming. You don’t own the content, you don’t own the hardware, you can’t play whatever you want, you just pay and go with whatever happens to be there. You can change channels like a Radio, that’s about it
- abraae 9y agoIsn't that life anyway? We're only on earth for a short time. You can't take your music to the grave with you, so why not accept its never really yours anyway?
- pedrocr 9y agoThis isn't about accepting it's "not really yours". This is about accepting it's actually someone else's that then has control about what you can and can't do. That entity will often be on earth for even a smaller time than you before it goes bankrupt or loses interest in that product. So you get to spend your short time on earth dealing with product obsolescence instead of owning your stuff while you're alive and even being able to pass it on to your children. It's a terrible bargain.
- Yetanfou 9y agoNo, it isn't. You don't need to take your music to the grave, those who come after you can inherit it. It can be 'yours' if you want it, as long as you managed to avoid the traps set by those who'd like you to believe there is no other way so you might as well accept it and just pay, and pay, and pay again.
- eecc 9y agowell, if you were careful enough when you bought that "The Dark Side of the Moon" LP vinyl you'd have a collectors item but - most importantly - a media record you can play anytime you want without having had to pay thousands over the course of a lifetime. Just a little cash 44 years ago.
- kjs3 9y agoReally? I have my grandfathers and fathers vinyl records. They still play just fine. I'll give them to my daughter. Probably still going to play just fine. That's not going to change because Chess Records is out of business or Universal decided to change the EULA when it bought Motown.
- mnm1 9y agoI expect any and all features of my Sonos speakers to possibly stop working except the local music library. If they ever stop that, I and others will file class action lawsuits at the very least. When the dust finally settles, that will probably be the only service still working anyway in the not so distant future. It's sad that the commercial market cannot and will not create worthwhile music services that are worth paying for in the long term. If my favorite songs disappear from the online library every few months, why should I pay a monthly fee? This happens on every service and is a categorical failure of the system's only purpose, to keep my favorite songs available. I'll take my NAS over those systems any day.
- pedrocr 9y ago>If they ever stop that, I and others will file class action lawsuits at the very least. The complete failure case for Sonos is the company stops existing or discontinues the product line and your devices are all stuck at whatever software version was the last, possibly useless after security issues or other software rot. There's no reason (and possibly no entity) to sue when that happens.
- mnm1 9y agoAs long as it still plays shit off my NAS, I don't care. And I don't see why it wouldn't, whether the company exists or not. That's what I was trying to convey above.
- pedrocr 9y ago>And I don't see why it wouldn't Because your new NAS no longer supports the old protocol. Because there was a security issue that's too serious to allow you to keep it on without a fix. Because...
- Doctor_Fegg 9y agoIf I own the hardware, I decide whether the security issue is “too serious”. Not them.
- KyeRussell 9y agoIgnoring that that's an outplayed argument, it's irrelevant. This is about hardware, not about streaming services.
- eecc 9y agoWell why is it irrelevant. It used to be you ditched your receiver or player when it was irreparably broken, not when Sony or Technics decided they’d had enough supporting your hardware. Here you have hardware that is useless without a software service that gets discontinued or it’s utility modified after-sale. For now users can stay on current firmware but that depends on whenever Sonos will pull a Sony PlayStation move and force an update to continue access to DRM’d music
- sjclemmy 9y agoPrecisely the reason I never invested in the Sonos. I looked into it a few years ago and I just thought they were overpriced and inflexible. I have Bluetooth speakers in my rooms and Spotify and Radio apps on my phone / tablet. Cheap and easy.
- ohazi 9y ago> due the age of the battery in the controller, it has the potential to overheat when left charging for extended periods of time ...uh, what? I assume I'm missing something here, because this doesn't make any sense. Can someone explain?
- jacobush 9y agoIt's pretty common. It never "finishes" charging, instead however many watts of the charger gets dumped as heat, indefinitely.
- ohazi 9y agoBut this is why lithium ion batteries need special lithium ion charging circuitry in the first place... If you don't have this, the cells will happily take as much energy as you give them and then promptly catch fire. It doesn't make sense to me that this would only now be a problem. Either the circuit was designed correctly, and this excuse is bullshit, or they should have issued a recall ten years ago.
- upofadown 9y agoYou are probably thinking of NiCad and to some extent NiMH simple constant current chargers. If you do that with a lithium battery you will have problems pretty much right away, possibly involving fire.
- duncan_bayne 9y ago... and once again, Stallman (and the FSF) are proved right. https://xkcd.com/743/ https://xkcd.com/743/ If you buy into a proprietary ecosystem, especially a DRM-encumbered one, and doubly-especially a streaming one, don't be surprised when the inevitable happens and your non-ownership of any part of the system bites you. I speak from personal experience. I lost some of my small Kobo library when they dropped support for their Web reader, and I closed my account (no support for my everyday / work laptop).
- icebraining 9y agoI'm an FSF supporter (technically FSFE), but I think we should be careful about these claims. It's not like open source projects never drop features. You could say "yeah, but they wouldn't be forced to upgrade" - but neither are the users in this case, as the reply says. What the users here want is to continue getting the new features and fixes of the new versions of firmware, while keeping support for the CR100. Even with the source, that would require someone to integrate those two parts, which might be prohibitively expensive. Don't get me wrong, I think they should have the right to do that if they wished, but it's not like it would just fix the problem; it would only allow them to fix it if they could afford it.
- alerighi 9y agoWith free software no one can shut down a service like they are doing. A product will continue to function and it will continue to receive updates as long as there is enough interest by the open source community in that product. Let's take for example Android smartphone, there are some old smartphone that thanks to the community are still updated to the latest version of the OS, on the other side when Apple say it's done you take your outdated iPhone and toss it in the bin, no one can continue to support it.
- icebraining 9y agoThey aren't shutting down a service, they are updating a product. Specifically, they are releasing a new version of the speakers firmware that removes support for the protocol used by CR100. All you wrote regarding Android is true, and that's why as I said I support the FSF and Free Software in general, all I'm saying is that you can't take that community for granted. Maybe someone would appear to re-add support for the CR100 to the new firmware - or maybe nobody would.
- filmgirlcw 9y agoI’m against bricking devices arbitrarily, but this product was more than 12 years old and hadn’t been sold since 2009 (I had one in 2006 when I was still in college and Sonos’s killer feature for me was that it worked with the original streaming music service, Rhapsody). Frankly, giving customers $100 credit seems kind to me. Plus the CR200 still works and they don’t have plans to brick it, so there is that. I feel for some of the users, but reading some of these complaints makes me roll my eyes. I’ve owned lots and lots of electronic devices over my life — and many audio systems — I can’t recall any other connected system having 13 years of support.
- jasonvorhe 9y agoThanks for posting this. I fully agree.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoI think what we're trying to rail against here is that why should 13, or whatever, years be an acceptable figure. My car is older than that. My toaster over is old, I've had CRT TVs that were much older before they died. I'm gonna go with a big fat juicy 'No!' here. We ought to be building for longevity and serviceability. Don't end support, just open it up. Publish the relevant source code, documentation etc. We shouldn't accept that it's ok or normal to dispose of a thing just because it is X years old.
- filmgirlcw 9y agoIt’s an accessory. If we were talking about the speakers themselves, I wouldn be more sympathetic, but in this case I’m just not. The reality is that the nature of connected devices makes things different. This isn’t the same as a CRT TV (but also, look at how much it costs and how difficult it is get parts for a CRT in 2018). And like it or not, your next car won’t be as repairable as your current 15 year old car, because it will require custom software and bench access and updates that most mechanics will not pay for or maintain. At least these Sonos users have the option of not installing an update. This isn’t like Revolv where it just stopped working. The CR100 uses Flash IIRC...it is absolutely ancient. I’m not sure we should be realistically asking development teams to maintain separate code bases for old, obsolete software. Google and Amazon changed backends that made the CR100 stop working. Are you saying that that’s a travesty too? Legit question: how long should any company/service be required to add backward compatibility to old, obsolete products? I fundamentally agree that we should be building for longevity and serviceability, but that isn’t always possible. The platform and stack the CR100 was built on is not modern and cannot be easily maintained. And even if the software was open source (which would be great), that doesn’t change the fact that if the endpoints on the services it relies on change, nothing can be done. The only reasonable compromise I can see would be an update that would allow the CR100 to continue to work only with local files. Otherwise, at least users can opt not to update if they rely so heavily on a 13 year old controller.
- egeozcan 9y agoAs far as I understand, it all works in the local network. It shouldn't be too hard to create a server to translate its calls to the new api (that the smartphone app uses), no? edit: I don't understand why you'd down-vote this. I'd love to correct it if I said something blatantly wrong, just tell me. Also, I wasn't dismissing this as a non-problem, but rather questioning if there'd be an easy solution. My parents are also affected BTW.
- meschi 9y agoYes, but i don't think this is an option for the people complaining.
- egeozcan 9y agoI was asking to see if there's anything I'm missing. I was thinking about doing this myself. Sorry for not being clear - please see my edit.
- icebraining 9y agoMaybe. Apparently they use a non-standard wireless networking protocol called Sonosnet. They do have "bridges" to connect to a regular Wifi or ethernet network, but it's not clear to me if the CR100 can use those to connect to the speakers (and hence to the hypothetical "fake speaker" server). I'm sure all of this is reverse engineerable, but it might be less work to build everything from scratch :)
- stryk 9y agoTheir main concern sounds like a liability issue (they cite the aging Li-ion battery heavily). They're not selling it anymore, so why not bundle together some internal docs and release some sort of technical manual or detailed repair guide to give users the option of replacing the battery? Of course this would be a "you people are on your own if you screw it up" but that's to be expected.
- usrusr 9y ago> Their main concern sounds like a liability issue (they cite the aging Li-ion battery heavily) Gratuitous power autonomy is quite high on my "things I won't buy" list. I was once scouring Amazon et al for some cheap bluetooth speakers for stationary use as a "poor man's Sonos", but they all came with their own integrated power bank. Ended up buying a radio that had BT input just as a secondary feature. About three times as expensive as originally planned, only to avoid seeing one more 18650 (or pair thereof) idling into decay under my watch. I'm not always that eco-aware, but when I get stuck on an issue I tend to get irrationally zeaolous (probably a quite common form of mild bigotry)
- amiga-workbench 9y agoI'm getting really sick of appliances depending on smartphone apps, they're brittle as hell and have no longevity as OS updates kill them off (and eventually as mobile OS's die completely). I had a right faff on finding a IP security cam that didn't use the bloody awful onVIF protocol and would connect to a network without a mobile app to configure it. I take care of remote access myself, so I don't need the "feature" of having my video streams routed through a server in china so I can view it on the go. I had the same issue with RGB lighting controllers for my shelving and bookcase, in the end I had to settle on a ESP8266 based controller and figure out the protocol with wireshark, I now have some of my lighting operable from a webpage on my home server. I really wish there were a decent, privacy respecting hub that could be used for controlling all of this kind of gear.
- IntelMiner 9y agoWould you be able to point us in the direction of the gear you ended up using for your DIY-ish RGB lighting? I'd love to do something similar in my own home
- amiga-workbench 9y agohttps://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/222734901758 https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/222734901758 Its one of these, unfortunately you still need the app to get it to connect to your network, but from then on you can fire packets at it to change the colours. There is a python library up on github for interfacing with it, and I think there might be alternate firmware for its microcontroller available. I really wish more of this home automation gear would use powerline networking, no need to faff around with WiFi settings.
- germinalphrase 9y agoI had never read about power line home automation before. Interesting stuff.
- amiga-workbench 9y ago
- bambax 9y agoI bought my first Sonos elements in 2006, and used to love them. I still use Sonos, for lack of a better option (?) but have come to hate it, the devices, the company, the whole "ecosystem", with the heat of a thousand suns. It updates constantly, you can't ever refuse an update, updates stop the system just when you need to use it, change the UI for no reason, and every update breaks something. Every single iteration is a little slower; I used to keep an oldish ipod touch just to manage Sonos but now it's so slow it's almost unusable. Since 2006 my use of Sonos HAS NOT CHANGED AT ALL: mp3s are stored on a Nas and they're played in various "rooms"; and sometimes I listen to radios; and THAT'S IT. Of course Sonos as a company has to support new streaming services and whatnot, but why does it have to break everything in the process, or force all users to upgrade? Why can't it leave us alone?? Every 6 months I try to look for an open source alternative, maybe based on a Pi (+ relay to power up amps on demand) but have not been very lucky so far. Am very interested in any pointers to something simple to implement and that I would completely control.
- TheCondor 9y agoCheck out Wren speakers. They do have a smartphone app but I send them audio from bunches of sources, they sound great too.
- christoph 9y agoI have exactly the same feeling. It feels like every time I go to cook in the kitchen and open the app on my phone, it brings the update process up. Numerous times, i've lost connectivity entirely, which seems to only be fixed by deleting the app from my phone, re-installing, signing back in, going back through the basic pairing process. It just makes me want to throw the whole thing out. It's beyond maddening!! Why can't it support bluetooth without purchasing the stupid bridge? Sometimes I want to watch Netflix when cooking and have the audio come out the system. Somebody should bring out a decent competitor to fix these issues. I'd buy it in a heartbeat.
- kurlberg 9y agoI'm quite happy with a squeezebox server running on a linux computer, and music streamed to a Squeezebox Radio. Sadly these cannot be bought anymore, but there is a chromecast plugin that works with squeezebox server - I can then stream to a chromecast audioplug + powered speaker (edifier 1280T). Unfortunately the edifier does not have USB for chromecast power, but the sound is pretty decent. I've also streamed to a sony SRS-X 77 with a bit less success, there are occasional wifi dropouts.
- bambax 9y ago> due the age of the battery in the controller, it has the potential to overheat when left charging for extended periods of time This is some argument on Sonos' part! The reason why the battery in the CR100 is "old" is because Sonos chose to build a device with a non-replaceable battery!! If they're so concerned about safety why don't they offer to replace the batteries (for a reasonable fee)??
- ZenoArrow 9y agoAccording to some of the posters in that Sonos forum thread, aftermarket batteries are available for the CR100. What I'm not sure about is how easy they are to replace, but it's clearly possible for some users.
- kirb 9y agoIt’s not hard to replace; probably the hardest part is separating the adhesived back rubber cover and then sealing it again after. The battery uses a modular connector. https://en.community.sonos.com/advanced-setups-229000/guide-to-changing-the-cr100-battery-5216 https://en.community.sonos.com/advanced-setups-229000/guide-...
- starsinspace 9y agoSo, end users are now figuring out why it's bad to buy into such proprietary, closed systems. I can fully understand the outrage. Unfortunately I find that most people don't care if you warn them about such things beforehand. Any product that relies on a manufacturer-only provided online service of any kind to provide its functionality, will simply stop functioning whenever the manufacturer feels like it (or goes out of business, etc). Oh, and it will also most likely not care about your privacy, but that's a given these days. Also, any product relying on a closed-source smartphone app (using proprietary protocols to communicate with the product) will also become increasingly annoying as time passes. At some point, the app won't get updates anymore, and some time after that you'll have to keep a special old smartphone around just for the purpose of running that app. Sounds great, eh? On the other hand, many 30, 40, 50 years old electronics products still work fine today, and can be used, as they were self-contained, and wholly owned (and fixable) by the user. p.s. the fact that ageing batteries are cited as reason by Sonos also further shows what a stupid idea it is to put non-replaceable batteries into products. I really hope that regulation will finally end that practice soon.
- akras14 9y agoDeath by redesign... https://www.alexkras.com/death-by-redesign/ https://www.alexkras.com/death-by-redesign/