8 ms·
In many situations, people who are identified as being at risk have somebody else placed in control of the finance, by court action. Brain injury patients for i
by ggm 9y ago
In many situations, people who are identified as being at risk have somebody else placed in control of the finance, by court action. Brain injury patients for instance. Hmmm.. hang on.. whats the major risk factor in the football circuit again?
Seriously: the recruitment of minors for major league with giant cash benefits should require them to sign a consent form for arms-length management of their capital for some time period, and give them the income stream not the capital.
after all, its often how the money is being controlled that wound up being their notional capital in the first place
- jstanley 9y ago> Seriously: the recruitment of minors for major league with giant cash benefits should require them to sign a consent form for arms-length management of their capital for some time period, and give them the income stream not the capital. No, thanks. It's their money, let them have it. If they want it to be invested on their behalf, that's fine. But it should be their choice. How would you like it if your employer told you that instead of paying you your wages, he was instead going to contribute to an investment fund, and you'd receive the income from that fund rather than receiving the money directly?
- soared 9y agoReplace your employer with government and its real life social security. In theory I support it... if it lasted till I retired.
- crankylinuxuser 9y agoUnfortunately, what Cato says is very worrying (1). Primarily, they highlight court cases in which Social Security is pulled away from people, and reaffirmed by SCOTUS. This is the troubling quote: The Court’s decision was not surprising. In an earlier case, Helvering v. Davis (1937), the Court had ruled that Social Security was not a contributory insurance program, saying, “The proceeds of both the employee and employer taxes are to be paid into the Treasury like any other internal revenue generally, and are not earmarked in any way.” We would likely have a national riot if Social Security was just yanked at once. But if my own life is any guess, the age to qualify for "benefits" keeps going higher and higher. It's theft by attrition, and backed as not theft by courts. I do not agree with CATO's eventual policy of "privatization" at all. The other choice, which was not posited, was to earmark the funds, keep them segregated from the general fund. Then do the right thing and set Social Security as a guarantee at the same age for everyone. And, remove that cap. (1) https://www.cato.org/publications/commentary/is-there-right-social-security https://www.cato.org/publications/commentary/is-there-right-...
- Brockenstein 9y ago>Then do the right thing and set Social Security as a guarantee at the same age for everyone. You have to take in consideration a few factors governing the original social security age limits. IE Life expectancy was significantly less. People live on average quite a bit longer now, addressing that reality isn't a bad idea. The other thing to consider is the money we're paying in now isn't being saved for our benefit later. It's being used to pay the benefits of current retirees. Not to mention the money that current retirees paid into the system 20, 30, 40 years ago is a pittance to what they're drawing now. I mean I like the idea of social security. A lot of people do, it's become ingrained in our national expectation. But in the same token, a lot of people don't have realistic thoughts about it. And we're going to need it to evolve with the realities of our culture. Longer lifespans, real cost of living, etc are all real issues that can't be ignored and expect Social Security to chug on perpetually.
- Spooky23 9y agoSocial Security is perfectly sustainable. The problem with is the demographic bump of the baby boom and use of it as a political football during the 60s and 70s when benefits were spun up, followed by the congress reducing funding by capping payments.
- mobilefriendly 9y agoPayments have always been capped (maximum taxable earnings), your history is factually wrong. Congress spends the surplus but the only actions ever taken by Congress on the revenue side of Social Security have been to increase taxes paid into the system.
- Spooky23 9y agoThe cap didn’t increase with inflation, which impacted collections. In effect the payroll tax was spun up in the 80s and used as government revenue via special bonds. But as the surplus as waned due to increased payments, the cap didn’t move and the government’s spending power to bridge the gap was reduced by our post-2001 perpetual war.
- colanderman 9y agoThat is quite literally how retirement works.
- skybrian 9y agoThat's what a pension plan is.
- ACow_Adonis 9y agoIn my country, that's called superannuation. You get some choice where its invested, but in short, you can't spend it on anything that benefits you materially here and now. 9.5% minimum is taken out of practically every non-casual working position. In general, it's defined contribution, not defined payment (barring some of the older pension plans which are going to have some tough decisions ahead). Flaws of the system aside, I'm generally in favor of the idea myself.
- ggm 9y agoFor 9% of my pay that's what happens. Australia has mandatory age savings. I have discretion over the investment fund. I don't get to spend the cash on hookers. Choice is a hot button item. You value this specific choice above others. I value their long term welfare above choice in this matter.
- djrogers 9y ago> Seriously: the recruitment of minors for major league with giant cash benefits should require them to sign a consent form for arms-length management of their capital for some time period, and give them the income stream not the capital. First of all, these are not minors - they are over 18. Secondly who the heck are you to decide that you should be in charge of what they can and can't do with their money?
- jdmichal 9y agoIt's also very uncommon for NFL recruits to go straight from high school without passing through college. Which would put them at closer to 21 than 18.
- manigandham 9y agoIt's called personal responsibility. They're earning sums that many will never reach and it's on them to figure out what to do with it. Nobody is stopping them from asking for help and it's not like there aren't enough examples to learn from by now. Someone who doesn't have responsibility can't be forced into it.
- jpindar 9y agoAnd the NFL tries to provide that help, by making rookies listen to lectures about managing their finances. But while you can make them listen to advice, you can't force them to follow it.
- watwut 9y agoYou can definitely raise children for more responsibility or away from it. If a lot of top sportmen can't manage finance, that would suggest that there is something about the system that raises them (they spend more time on sport then anything else) that is that way. Which would suggest that responsible parent won't put children into such system.
- specialist 9y agoSo now naivety (ignorance) is a moral failing?
- manigandham 9y agoNo, who said anything about right or wrong here? What I said is responsibility. If you're naive/ignorant/otherwise unprepared then the answer is to ask for help and learn so you can be better prepared. That would be best for your future but it's ultimately up to you and nobody else really cares what you do.
- mfringel 9y agoYou didn't say "responsibility", you said "personal responsibility". "Personal" implies that they should take sole responsibility for their circumstances, ignoring any other agents involved. So, yes, it does appear you're talking about right and wrong.
- seanalltogether 9y ago> Seriously: the recruitment of minors for major league with giant cash benefits should require them to sign a consent form for arms-length management of their capital for some time period, and give them the income stream not the capital. So this looks great at first right? It's like a lotto winner taking the lifetime payments instead of the lump sum. The problem is you can take loans against that money very easily, or you can sign the contract over to someone else very easily. Want to invest $300,000 in your friends restaurant because you think he's a great chef, just take a loan against 10 years worth of your guaranteed income stream.
- CodesInChaos 9y agoRelated story: https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/social-issues/how-companies-make-millions-off-lead-poisoned-poor-blacks/2015/08/25/7460c1de-0d8c-11e5-9726-49d6fa26a8c6_story.html?utm_term=.c3c15ddd5fa9 https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/social-issues/how-compa...
- LordKano 9y agoIf someone is determined to screw themselves, it's impossible to stop them.
- ggm 9y agoYes. I see now that "a fool and their money are easily parted" lives on. I don't know what to do about that. Maybe a ten percent retain and the moral of the story is you are a former millionaire who now has a small stipend to remind you how stupid you are.
- Kluny 9y agoReally, taking their adult autonomy away is the first step? How about education? This might be anecdotal, but I feel like we don't hear these athlete bankruptcy stories as often about hockey players. Why? Because they're all white, not black. Putting a kid through junior hockey is expensive and hockey players tend to come from privileged homes with much better financial education than young black football players. They get just as many knocks on the head, but they get better advice from their father's accountant, and they make it to retirement with some money left. Making them sign away control of their money sounds like a new version of the old story of infantilizing black people by removing their adult rights, "for their own good".
- saikit 9y agoCould be an exception to the rule, but the highest profile athlete bankruptcy recently is from a hockey player http://ftw.usatoday.com/2016/11/columbus-blue-jackets-jack-johnson-gives-up-two-years-of-his-salary-to-settle-debts http://ftw.usatoday.com/2016/11/columbus-blue-jackets-jack-j...
- meow1032 9y agoThat was a bit of a different story since his parents took out loans in his name.
- test6554 9y agoThey do exist: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_black_NHL_players https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_black_NHL_players
- talmand 9y agoI'm curious as to how hockey is any more expensive than any other sport that has player equipment and a privileged background is more beneficial to making it to the professional level than any other sport. Could it be that black kids as a group just isn't that interested in playing hockey?
- SheepSlapper 9y ago
- jhowell 9y agoIt seems that we, the people that read about athletes and celebrities losing their money while we commute to work feel the best course of action is less control. Arguably similar, people in technology who hunt equity at the expense of future financial stability. We consider their competence at managing money in the but not the latter.
- ggm 9y agoActually we do. Lots of online resources council new ict startup entrants not to be seduced by vesting, try to point out the huge downside potential risks. The small group of people who do hunt it, are quite distinct from the people who enter sport for huge short term up front money with inadequate skills to manage it. YC isn't combing high school and college touring cash now for brilliant ideas.
- brightball 9y agoThere was actually a sports agency run by an accounting firm that did something close to this. They basically said, “We will make sure you and your family are taken care of for the rest of your life but it means there are certain things you have to let us handle with your finances so that we can say ‘no’ to people for you.” They also had to agree not to spend on drugs, strippers, excessive houses, etc.
- curun1r 9y ago> require them to sign a consent form for arms-length management of their capital for some time period All 4 big professional leagues in the US have pension plans [0] that, while not making them rich, will at least provide enough money to survive in the event they blow all their earnings. It's not quite as extreme as what you propose, but there's definitely some deferred income. [0] http://www.businessinsider.com/nfl-nhl-nba-mlb-retirement-pension-plans-lockout-2011-1 http://www.businessinsider.com/nfl-nhl-nba-mlb-retirement-pe...