3 ms·
We are still talking about a website, right? A totally optional website, in a browser with a close button? This isn’t a chemical addiction or gambling.
by ryandrake 9y ago
We are still talking about a website, right? A totally optional website, in a browser with a close button? This isn’t a chemical addiction or gambling.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoWhat makes it different from gambling?
- ryandrake 9y agoFacebook addiction is not recognized by the pros as a mental disorder and gambling addiction is?
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoSure, but there was contestation about adding it to the DSM. Actually in DSM-V it's recommended to pursue further study into internet addiction. What I'm really asking though is what lines you draw between something like 'social media addiction' and 'gambling addiction'? Or is the only difference in your mind the inclusion in the DSM?
- ryandrake 9y agoI’m a frequent visitor to a few local card rooms and make regular trips to Vegas. I’ve seen and know addicted degenerate gamblers. It’s a totally different league from people wasting time on Facebook. I simply can’t imagine someone so self-destructively debilitated by their Facebook usage. To me, Facebook use is a dirty bad habit like nail biting. It’s not a family-destroying addiction. Totally open to the medical establishment proving otherwise though.
- Retra 9y agoIf someone keeps losing their job because they can't sit still and concentrate for 25 minutes, you aren't going to hear about it. If you can't imagine that, then I'm afraid you're imagination needs a tune up.
- bcoates 9y agoIf people were tearing their hair out about internet gambling destroying democracy they would rightly be made fun of. Internet gambling is discouraged/banned to the extent it threatens the local tax base, nobody cares about gambling addicts.
- leggomylibro 9y agoIsn't it a chemical addiction? I mean, what does Heroin do to your brain? Releases a ton of extra dopamine and serotonin and crap, right? And what happens when you see that 14 people liked your post? Okay, so maybe Facebook doesn't change the way that your brain's receptors work with long-term use, but don't deny that people keep going back for that hit of inclusion.
- majormajor 9y agoWhat happens to someone's ability to function regularly if they're constantly going back for heroin hits? Compare that to what happens if you keep opening the Facebook app on your phone. Effect size matters. A lot. I haven't seen any convincing arguments that Facebook is even as bad as the classic "couch potato" TV junkie scenario. It's impossible to prevent someone from making bad decisions, so the size of the downside risk has to be strongly considered before claiming a problem is worth heavy-handed fixes.
- ck425 9y agoThere's a growing body of research suggesting fb is worse due to frequency. It might have a smaller effect than tv or heroin but it happens way more often than either of those.
- majormajor 9y agoPoint me to the people dying from Facebook addiction a la heroin abuse and I'll believe you that it's "worse." People behave differently due to new technology, sure, that's a given. Is it catastrophically worse than easy access to extremely potent drugs? The outcomes suggest no.
- freehunter 9y agoIs having a conversation a chemical addiction? If I say something that receives a negative response, will I not try to follow it up with something that receives a positive response? After I've received that positive response, will I not try to please my conversation partner more to keep feeling good about myself? Should we then ban conversations? Some people use "it releases dopamine" like that's a bad thing, like our bodies weren't wired with dopamine receptors to teach us how to function in a society. Are you proposing we get rid of everything that releases dopamine? We should all live a bleak and meaningless life? Humans are social creatures. We're wired to seek positive feedback from our peers. Getting a laugh in a face-to-face conversation is no different than getting a smiley face in an SMS is no different than getting likes on Facebook.
- ck425 9y agoOther comments have addressed the addictive nature of fb and the evidence of how it affects our brains. I want to point out the social pressures. These days since everyone has fb almost every social event is advertised via fb. When my friends have parties they make a fb event. They presume I'm on there because almost everyone one is. If I stop using fb I'd become socially isolated extremely quickly.