7 ms·
Researchers giving psilocybin to religious leaders (2017)
- WalterSear 9y agoThe original article's title is misleading.
- Buttons840 9y agoYeah. It seemed to say that researchers are doing a study about magic mushrooms and finding positive effects. Then the next paragraph says "Anil Seth", who I don't know is even connected with the study, said some philisophical things in a TED talk. Then seems to wander through some more philisophical ideas before ending.
- ghostbrainalpha 9y agoSuggested Title: Study with small sample size suggests that brief drug-induced mystical experiences change people over time, leading them to report better moods, heightened altruism and forgiveness, more closeness with others, and a sense of connection six months later
- TrainedMonkey 9y agoToo long, how about "Scientist report psychoactive drugs leading to long term positive effects".
- drvdevd 9y agoIn this case it should say “psilocybin” (as it now does) as there are very particular (IMO significant) differences in its’ effects as compared to other 5ht2* agonists, such as LSD. For example it typically has about 1/4 to 1/2 the duration of LSD which is therapeutically significant.
- achileas 9y agoSample size isn't small if the power is high. Biological studies are generally (and correctly) done with 8-20 subjects. All the ones I and my lab published in grad school were around here, and there's no arbitrary line over which a sample size is no longer small.
- charlieflowers 9y agoMaybe even, "Here's a reasonable sounding, but unproven, possible explanation for why some people report that certain drugs give them life-changing experiences." And the TLDR: The part of your brain that some claim "invents your identity" is temporarily shut off, leading you to see alternate possibilities.
- dang 9y agoYou're right. Generally the best way to complain about a title is to suggest a better one. When people do that we frequently take the suggestion. "Better" here means accurate, neutral, and using representative language from the text itself. In this case, though, it's a bit hard because the article is cobbled from multiple sources that aren't all about the same thing. Edit: we changed the URL from https://qz.com/1196408/scientists-studying-psilocybin-accidentally-proved-the-self-is-an-illusion/ https://qz.com/1196408/scientists-studying-psilocybin-accide.... Turned out that its two most substantive mainstream sources were about the same study. They threw in a Ted talk and some Alan Watts and made a vague mash. My self either found this annoying or imagined that it did, so it changed the URL to one of the articles about the ongoing study.
- Viff 9y agoTLDR: Your brain has certain regions active during normal consciousness. Magic mushrooms shut down some of those parts and activates others, so your brain makes new connections to different regions and develops an altered consciousness.
- neilwilson 9y agoRTLDR: get off your face on mushies. It's like wow man.
- dang 9y agoPlease don't do this here.
- everdev 9y agoIt's great to see alternative personal development like this proposed. Hopefully governments and doctors will find a safe way to do further research.
- mindcrime 9y agoHopefully governments and doctors will find a safe way to do further research. This is how the government does research. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_MKUltra https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_MKUltra Thanks, but no thanks. Keep the government out of it, please.
- anarazel 9y agoYes, pre Church committee secret CIA research is really applicable to the topic at hand.
- mindcrime 9y agoOh, you mean you trust the US government because of the Church Committee? Good point; after all, they haven't done anything shady, nefarious, underhanded, or illegal since then. And the other world governments, I'm sure their hands are clean as well...
- montyf 9y agoHow isn't it? Anyway, I agree with his comment but for a different reason: government "research" isn't historically trustworthy. Any psychedelics research sponsored by the government, directly or indirectly, is going to end up like marijuana research[0] and like research into alternative therapies[1]. Of course, they will continue coming up with opposite findings for drugs that lobbyists can profit from, like SSRI's. The FDA is able to literally pick and choose studies that work for them[2]. [0]: http://www.dispatch.com/news/20170319/governments-marijuana-is-terrible-for-scientific-studies-researchers-say http://www.dispatch.com/news/20170319/governments-marijuana-... [1]: http://www.nbcnews.com/id/31190909/ns/health-alternative_medicine/t/billion-spent-no-alternative-cures-found/ http://www.nbcnews.com/id/31190909/ns/health-alternative_med... (It took 2.5 billion dollars to find out that yoga and meditation "may" help with anxiety etc.) [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Selective_serotonin_reuptake_inhibitor#Controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Selective_serotonin_reuptake_i...
- jotm 9y agoI can show you the self is not an illusion - ask those people to give you all of their possessions to someone else, the poor or some charity. Suddenly, they'll care about their well being above others and their eternal connection to everyone else is shattered.
- dang 9y agoThat doesn't show the self is not an illusion. It could be an illusion that is widely believed.
- whatshisface 9y agoIf the self is an illusion who is being fooled? (Obviously I experience things - scientific research showing that the self is complicated and many-faceted don't really serve to get rid of the idea...)
- dang 9y agoThe claim is that some sort of universal self gets fooled into thinking that it is a bunch of disjoint individual selves. Whether the word 'self' is best for both concepts, I couldn't say.
- psyc 9y agoIs hypocrisy in proponents of a belief actually a good argument against the belief? This reminds me of those arguments that presume if solipsism is true, its proponents have to act like psychopaths, or that if determinism is true, its proponents have to act apathetic. In every case, if the proponents dutifully performed their beliefs, that would merely indicate they hold the belief, not that it is true.
- westiseast 9y agoIt’s mistaken (and somewhat sad!) to take a cynical attitude like that given the implications of the research. The most exciting part of these type of studies is the ability to take depressive people and ‘kick’ them out of the cognitive ruts they are in. Those cognitive ruts are often world-views, thought structures and learned behaviours from childhood or their parents which constantly reinforce that the sufferer is worthless or stupid or unwanted etc. In those world views, other people are often seen in very negative light - they’re critical, or assholes, or dangerous, or perhaps you’re so needy for love and attention that you endlessly see other people as your savior (and constantly make bad relationships as a result). The idea that we just need love and kindness and selflessness and we’re all connected maaaan - that’s a childish interpretation. As is the idea that interconnectednesa and empathy falls apart in a realistic adult world of possessions and basic needs. In the context of mental illness, being able to experience connectedness and heightened empathy might mean seeing other people for who they really are, not who they appear to be in your distorted worldview. It might mean realizing that other people are similar to you and you’re not alone in your struggle, or realizing that you can give support to someone else instead of constantly needing support from them. Sometimes breakthroughs like that take years in therapy, but might be achieved much more quickly using mushrooms. Hope that helps dissolve the cynicism.
- nabla9 9y ago>The Tibetan Zen Buddhist monk Chogyam Trongpa It's written Chögyam Trungpa. Trungpa was Vajrayana school Buddhist. "Tibetan Zen Buddhism" does not exist. I'm sure there are individual Tibetans who are Zen Buddhists, but there is no Zen tradition in Tibet. Trungpa was also alcoholic, womanizer, sexually abused his students, cocaine user, ... and was able to get away with it because it was all 'crazy wisdom'. Zen and Buddhism in general is full of people like Alan Watts and Trungpa. Both were highly intelligent, inspiring writers, and alcoholics who presented themselves as masters.
- hosh 9y agoChris Wallis, author of Tantra Illuminated had written to clarify what makes someone a "tantric master", specifically, one is a master of self. I think that is a useful distinction when you are searching for guidance. Another way to look at it is something I've heard Adyashanti (another teacher) spoke about in an interview on batgap.com -- someone's relationship with their teacher is often a reflection of of their relationship with the whole of the spiritual search, whether that be idealization or cynicism, both responses to that searching for perfection.
- nabla9 9y agoThere is whole Tibetan sutra with instructions of how to have sex with prepubescent girls. After their first menstrual cycle they become impure and don't help monk in his spiritual journey. If you have religion and status, you can always find ways to rationalize fucking around as spiritual development. I have respect for Buddhism in general and I have practiced meditation with a teacher 20 years. I understand the need to have a teacher and the need for guidance, but it's human nature for people to abuse others when given too much authority.
- hosh 9y agoThere is also a whole Tibetan teaching that evolved from ritual cannabilism that shares its roots with practices from India. That particular teaching evolved to use visualizations, and the one being offered for sacrifice in those visualization is the practitioner and not someone else. When done that way, it's an extreme, but beautiful teaching relating to impermanence and the Bodhisattva ideal. The lotus growing from the mud -- and that mud is very muddy. I don't think people outside realize just how dark of a place the Tibetan people came from before the Buddhist Vajrayana practitioners came in to "tame" the land gods of Tibet. There was a monastic order that attempted to bring the Dharma (with the Tibetan king's blessing) and were hounded out. The last monk that left told the king, he needed to bring one of the Vajrayana people. The level of intensity of the dark and negative stuff was just that bad. There had always been and likely, always will be the Guru syndrome. Even sincere teachers getting themselves trapped by that. (And that was one of my few favorite parts of the Last Jedi). It is as much as the failings of the guru as it is people seeking for something projecting all sorts of idealizations and failings onto their teachers. It doesn't matter whether it is Tibetan or not. This happens with any religion or spiritual path. One last note, something I heard from several teachers: you can be awakened and still be an ass. You would just be very clear, realized ass.
- hosh 9y agoI've been keeping an eye out on this study and had hoped there were more results, but this article hasn't said anything about that. Not sure where the no-self part comes in, but it looks like the article title has changed. I've been listening to a lot of Adyashanti's talks and interviews lately. He's not saying anything substantially different from any other non-dual teacher is saying, though I find that he is very clear when he does speak about this. One of the things that come up is that the experience of "no-self" is different from "unity consciousness" and "identification with witness" though those are each awakenings and realizations someone might go through. I wanted to note that because "no-self" is often confused with "unity consciousness", but what's clear from Adyashanti and some of the others is that the experience of a unity consciousness will still have a very subtle landing space, whereas "no self" doesn't even have that subtle self-referencing either. Also, these people are experiencing "no-self" and "unity consciousness" as an integral part of their daily, ordinary experience, usually while simultaneously experiencing an individuated and relative sense of self. These are not altered consciousness in the sense that many psychonauts might speak of, or a one-time mystical or peak experience, and the experience itself is a lot simpler, if impossible to put into words.
- rootw0rm 9y agoThe "no-self" concept you speak of is usually referred to as ego death I believe.
- pmoriarty 9y agoThis reminds me of the "Marsh Chapel Experiment" (aka the "Good Friday Experiment") from 1962: "Prior to the Good Friday service, graduate degree divinity student volunteers from the Boston area were randomly divided into two groups. In a double-blind experiment, half of the students received psilocybin, while a control group received a large dose of niacin. Niacin produces clear physiological changes and thus was used as an active placebo... Almost all of the members of the experimental group reported experiencing profound religious experiences, providing empirical support for the notion that psychedelic drugs can facilitate religious experiences..."[1] Much more detail here: [2] [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marsh_Chapel_Experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marsh_Chapel_Experiment [2] - https://www.erowid.org/plants/mushrooms/mushrooms_journal2.shtml https://www.erowid.org/plants/mushrooms/mushrooms_journal2.s...
- dsego 9y agoHow about they give them antipsychotics instead?
- lafar6502 9y agoPriests are lucky bastards
- dang 9y agoCan you please not post unsubstantive comments to Hacker News? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html