4 ms·
8 trade secrets (down from 100s) Was this by their own will? Back in the Oracle v Google trial, which had the same judge, he asked Oracle to cut down the 132 c
by icebraining 9y ago
8 trade secrets (down from 100s)
Was this by their own will? Back in the Oracle v Google trial, which had the same judge, he asked Oracle to cut down the 132 claims to only 3 - which Oracle was not happy about.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoNo. Judge Alsup told them to knock it down into the reasonable range. ("Less than 10") I believe it got stripped down to 9, and then one got thrown out of that group.
- Fricken 9y agoAll the trade secrets claims were plan B for Waymo. The case was initially about patent infringement, and for undisclosed reasons they were all tossed out. What was supposed to be the original slam dunk for Waymo, 'trade secret 96', Which referred to PCB circuit diagrams that were accidently emailed to Waymo instead of Uber ATG by a shared supplier, was even dropped. Waymo's whole case was pretty flimsy.
- powercf 9y ago> The case was initially about patent infringement, and for undisclosed reasons they were all tossed out. Possibly because the patents were invalid due to the existence of prior art? Previous discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15875685 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15875685
- Fricken 9y agoThe prior art cited in that news item only invalidated 'patent 936'. (That's my comment there, 3rd from top). The infringement claims were thrown out earlier than that (September 2017, IIRC).
- opo 9y ago>...The infringement claims were thrown out earlier than that (September 2017, IIRC). According to the article, the infringement claims were dropped after Waymo was notified of the USPTO reexamination that was going to be done due to Swildens filing the ex parte reexamination request. >...So he took the unusual step of challenging the 936 patent himself, filing what is called an ex-parte reexamination request. He gathered the prior art he had discovered, completed reams of paperwork, and pulled together his detailed arguments into a 101-page document that he filed with the USPTO on August 1. Waymo dropped the claims relating to the 936 patent on Sep 13. >...Swildens, naturally, thinks his reexamination request played a role. He notes that USPTO had a phone interview with Waymo’s lawyers a few days before, on September 8, at which the examiners presumably told Waymo that a reexamination of the 936 would be going ahead. If the reexamination started while the patent was being actively litigated, Uber and the court would have to be informed. https://www.wired.com/story/eric-swildens-uber-waymo-lawsuit-patent/ https://www.wired.com/story/eric-swildens-uber-waymo-lawsuit...
- raywu 9y agoThat had been a good long read; thanks for linking again
- ChuckMcM 9y agoI asked about this back in the Oracle trial and was told that if you can't prevail on what you consider your top 10 allegations, you are not going to be able to prevail on the rest of them (assumption they are weaker than your top 10). As a result litigating all of them is not useful and only serves to confuse the jury.