14 ms·
Yes, it is. And the example used in the article of chemical engineering reinforces the point. It ties into computer science quite nicely. To become a chemical
by jandrewrogers 9y ago
Yes, it is. And the example used in the article of chemical engineering reinforces the point. It ties into computer science quite nicely.
To become a chemical engineer, you first have to complete the course work for a degree in chemistry. Chemistry as chemistry is an extremely modular subject matter; you can solve most problems in discrete steps in isolation. In a computer science sense, chemistry is about pure functions. Very easy to analyze, as material side effects (like spontaneous detonation) are rare.
Chemical engineering, on the other hand, is about analyzing systems that leak their state everywhere and have effects that feedback into other parts of the system. But it needs to be extremely efficient nonetheless. There is no isolation because it doesn't exist in real-world complex systems. I have seen excellent chemists absolutely fail to grok chemical engineering even though it is literally the same subject matter. The only difference is that chemical engineers are required to reason about complex distributed systems; as with computer science, only a minority of practitioners ever seem to grok it despite their best efforts. Same problem, different domain. And chemical engineers are paid on a different scale than chemists as a result.
In engineering, bimodal distributions are the sorting of people that naturally have the ability to easily reason about complex distributed systems with many concurrent moving parts and people that cannot. Increasingly, the market is discriminating on this characteristic and it is reflected in wages.
Anecdotally, it is somewhat well-known that people competent at chemical engineering find advanced software engineering to be intuitive; it is a very easy second "language" to pick up. An inordinate number of chemical engineers end up in high paying software engineering careers -- it comes very naturally and lends itself to the abstract analytical toolset you develop as a chemical engineer.
- bjourne 9y agoTbt, I haven't seen that much evidence that correlates developer ability with salary. For example, developers living in the Silicon Valley are paid the most. Not because they are the best, but because they are living in the Silicon Valley. Geographical factors play a much bigger role in compensation than developer ability.
- vemv 9y agoBut that 'greater' SV salary for a junior developer can give you less purchasing power than a 'lower' salary for a senior somewhere in Europe, due to cost of living. Granted, money is 'absolute' if you use it to e.g travel around the world, but most people don't do that. In general money is 'relative' to one's environment.
- arximboldi 9y agoNot really. I did the math in the past because I seriously considered moving to the US cuz I got an offer there. In my estimates, you would end up spending the same % of your salary in surviving, but of course the remaining let's say 30%, is simply a lot. Also a lot of things are not really that expensive (most things that are not housing, or maybe eating out.) And when you get out of the Junior level, I think the difference between SV and Europe becomes abysmal. Also, "Europe" means many things. I am talking about Berlin here. I also know other places, like Madrid, where you just simply earn pennies in comparison so the difference becomes even higher (Madrid is more expensive than Berlin, earn less) I still decided to stay here though (because of quality of living, work culture, music and partying, politics).
- ddorian43 9y agoGet a remote US job ? Harder since you compete with many people but doable.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tasuki 9y agoMost US-based companies are vary of hiring remotely from Europe. As a worker, I'm not sure I'd want to work from 4pm till midnight. The timezone difference makes collaboration difficult. South America seems to be in a much better position here. Obviously, there are also US-based companies with globally distributed remote workforce, but those are a minority.
- chx 9y ago> as material side effects (like spontaneous detonation) are rare. My father has been responsible for every chemical (including, explicitly, explosives) factory in the entire country (Hungary, 80s) and later for just one pharmaceutical company for those "side effects" to stay rare. They do not stay rare without some very stern rules.
- danmaz74 9y agoThe OP was explicitly referring to the difference between chemistry in the lab (when you can conduct perfectly isolated, small scale experiments -> very low risks) and chemistry in industry (which is what you're referring to), where risks are much higher.
- tomwphillips 9y ago>To become a chemical engineer, you first have to complete the course work for a degree in chemistry. That is incorrect. Look at the programme of study for a chemical engineering undergraduate degree [1]. It doesn't cover anywhere near the same content as an undergraduate chemistry degree [2]. [1]: http://www.imperial.ac.uk/study/ug/courses/chemical-engineering-department/chemical-engineering/ http://www.imperial.ac.uk/study/ug/courses/chemical-engineer... [2]: https://www.imperial.ac.uk/study/ug/courses/chemistry-department/chemistry-bsc/#structure https://www.imperial.ac.uk/study/ug/courses/chemistry-depart...
- zelos 9y agoI was typing a similar response. I did a 4-year MEng in ChemEng and there were only a few non-elective courses in organic and physical chemistry. The bulk of the content is fluid mechanics, thermodynamics, vessel design, safety, control systems, mathematics etc.
- LanceH 9y agoTo quote a Chem eng friend, "I don't know chemistry, all I know are flow rates."
- jandrewrogers 9y agoI probably over-generalized from my own experience. The only chemistry degree coursework we could avoid was a class about lab operations, basically safety/hazard management. This turned it into a de facto 5-year degree even though they stripped most of the non-related coursework to a bare minimum; you still had two years of coursework for the engineering program after the chemistry. People that lost their appetite for chemical engineering after compressing all their chemistry into three years could switch to chemistry, which meant they spent their last year taking the filler non-technical courses that the engineers were allowed to avoid.
- HeyLaughingBoy 9y agoWay to miss the forest for the trees...
- 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- phkahler 9y agoSo you're pointing to the ability to manage complexity? I had not heard it put that way before but it feels right to me. From TFA the author said "How is it possible that programmers are paid so well without these other barriers to entry that similarly remunerative fields have? " My initial thought was that there are people who get it those that don't. But you can teach many people the tools of programming. It's using those tools to do something interesting that seems to be the challenge. By interesting I suppose I mean something exceeding some level of complexity. This makes sense, I don't see our schools teaching anything too complex - it tends to be compartmentalized.
- logfromblammo 9y agoAlso, because software developers are like soldiers or litigation lawyers. The more other people have, the more you will need. If company X is your competitor, and they employ 10 software developers, sooner or later, whatever it is they're working on will release, and that might provide X with a massive competitive advantage over you. So you have to hire your own people to keep up with your side of the arms race. And sometimes, a brand new person comes along with a bunch of software folks to create company Y, and they devastate both you and X within their first 5 years.
- nvarsj 9y ago> In engineering, bimodal distributions are the sorting of people that naturally have the ability to easily reason about complex distributed systems with many concurrent moving parts and people that cannot. Increasingly, the market is discriminating on this characteristic and it is reflected in wages. What faith in the system :). The truth I think is "it's who you know" more than "what you know". The best paid engineers are ones who spend a lot of time positioning themselves to get well paid. Why that is bi-modal I can't be sure - but my guess is that once you hit a certain network effect you start to make a lot more.
- Clubber 9y agoIt's both. You have to know people of whom you impress with your ability.
- nvarsj 9y agoSure, but I don't think the differentiator in the bimodal distribution is technical ability.
- Clubber 9y agoI would guess being good hits the first mark, being good and knowing someone who can pay a lot that knows you're good hits the second mark. Perhaps the second mark not only includes being good and knowing someone, but being good and providing a larger value, like being able to analyze and communicate with a company and quantitatively save them money through business process automation.
- taurath 9y agoAnd yet the primary indicator of a programmer's ability through job interviews are tiny-scale optimizations and brain teasers.
- tboyd47 9y agoI thought it was just because the GAFA tech giants are currently in a bidding war for programmers in a very expensive part of the country. I've met and worked with many very talented engineers, fully capable of grokking complex systems, not working in Silicon Valley.
- eli_gottlieb 9y agoI'd definitely call that the best explanation. You spend a few years working at a GAFAM, and now you've got a hugely prestigious resume from an expensive, high-cost-of-living area that other companies will shell out for, big time. You spend any time outside that cluster, even doing excellent and difficult work, and you just don't have the prestige. It's also a matter of scale: the GAFAMs just ship more units in terms of revenue per employee. Sure, that's largely because of monopoly and network effects, but hey.
- crdoconnor 9y ago>Chemical engineering, on the other hand, is about analyzing systems that leak their state everywhere and have effects that feedback into other parts of the system. But it needs to be extremely efficient nonetheless. There is no isolation because it doesn't exist in real-world complex systems. Is it not possible to engineer in isolation on real world complex chemical engineering system? I try to do that with software, and most software can certainly benefit from stricter isolation (e.g. looser coupling), but most software teams - even well paid ones - often have an in-built bias against investing in less tangible work which means that you ultimately end up with these complex systems are that hard to reason about. Not that I feel like I should be complaining about this if it is indeed the reason I'm paid well.
- walshemj 9y agoAnd also chemical engineering also requires skills in mech /fluids engineering doing a reaction in a lab vs at scale is a completely different thing.
- veritas3241 9y ago> Anecdotally, it is somewhat well-known that people competent at chemical engineering find advanced software engineering to be intuitive; it is a very easy second "language" to pick up. An inordinate number of chemical engineers end up in high paying software engineering careers -- it comes very naturally and lends itself to the abstract analytical toolset you develop as a chemical engineer. As someone trained as a chemical engineer who now is a Data Engineer (SQL & Python pipe fitter), feel free to add me to your anec-data :-)
- yomly 9y agoI like your analogy. To offer my own anecdote: In pure/theoretical Chemistry you conveniently ignore in-situ solvation effects to think about mechanisms of the organic reaction. Then in the real world, you can't replicate someone else's paper because of humidity differences between your lab and the author's.
- peterjlee 9y agoJust anecdotal but all of my friends who majored in chemical engineering are somehow software engineers now..
- noir_lord 9y agoBoss studied chemical engineering, he's not remotely a techie but is ridiculously smart and he assimilates stuff at a speed I've rarely met.
- bdcs 9y agoFascinating argument, which fits me well (PhD ChemE who learned software and is now SWE at large tech firm). Allow me to take an alternative argument: Highly-driven students, especially those driven by money, became ChemEs to earn a lot of money and prestige. They looked up highest paying majors and chose ChemE for these reasons. I think it is now obvious SWE is very high paying and prestigious -- perhaps more so than ChemE -- so these highly-driven people switched. It had nothing to do with the topics intrinsically, but rather ChemE was largely perceived as the hardest/most-prestigious field and now SWE is.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]