3 ms·
The problem is solved, save for entrenched incumbents. Open Access: PLoS https://www.plos.org/ https://www.plos.org/ Closed Access: (P)PNAS https://www.google
by gowld 9y ago
The problem is solved, save for entrenched incumbents.
Open Access: PLoS https://www.plos.org/ https://www.plos.org/
Closed Access: (P)PNAS https://www.google.com/search?q=ppnas https://www.google.com/search?q=ppnas http://andrewgelman.com/2017/10/04/breaking-pnas-changes-slogan/ http://andrewgelman.com/2017/10/04/breaking-pnas-changes-slo...
Closed Access journals DO NOT serve as a quality filter. The unpaid peer-reviewers serve as a quality filter (and often a poot one anyway).
- indubitable 9y agoOf course you're right, but the review process is connected to the journal. PLoS journals are very accepting and so they end up being seen as a repository for publications that could not get published elsewhere. That's not to say nothing of value is published there, but rather that if you take a random paper from one of their journals, it's going to be of a different quality than a random paper from the Annual Review of Astronomy and Astrophysics. And like others have mentioned, a supplement is a great idea because of publication bias against things like negative results. However, I would again see this as supplementing and supplanting when I think most people here are gunning for the latter.
- Fomite 9y agoDespite publishing in PLoS journals a fair amount, I'm not a huge fan of the actual customer experience of publishing on their platform. I once seriously gave up first authorship on a paper in exchange for not having to deal with PLoS Currents' submission system. Similarly, the BMC-system appears to be having serious issues with turning around papers swiftly enough.