5 ms·
How is this controversial? I think it can be summed up in one old but very relevant-in-our-times quote: "Those who give up freedom for security deserve neither
by userbinator 9y ago
How is this controversial?
I think it can be summed up in one old but very relevant-in-our-times quote: "Those who give up freedom for security deserve neither."
At first, the idea that something is being done "for your safety and security" sounds good, but like all utopian goals, it has deeper connotations that are truly dystopian.
As mentioned in another of the comments here, this is yet another instance of companies using the "more secure" argument to gain control over the masses and ostracise anything they don't like. They're harnessing fear and exploiting it to their advantage.
To give an analogy in the real world, we don't lock ourselves in bulletproof cages and expend great efforts in hiding from others (for the most part), and I'm sure if your car's GPS indicated locations with high crime rates as "not safe" and prevented you from going there, there would be much outrage. We shouldn't let companies and (and try very hard, unfortunately not always succeeding for) governments dictate every detail of how we should live our lives offline, and the same should apply online.
There's a very long tail of sites, many sadly disappearing from Google[1], of old yet extremely useful information, which are probably going to stay HTTP for the forseeable future. I made a comment about this in a previous "HTTP/S debate" article:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14751540 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14751540
Fortunately the only good thing that may come of this is that people will just start completely ignoring "not secure".
And I have JS off by default and whitelisted on a very small number of sites, if you were wondering...
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16153840 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16153840
- yzmtf2008 9y agoYou have javascript disabled. I do not. I happen to use plenty of sites that require javascript, with HN being one of them. Most of the users out there do not have javascript disabled either. How do you account for their security? > and I'm sure if your car's GPS indicated locations with high crime rates as "not safe" and prevented you from going there, there would be much outrage. This is just a warning though, no one is preventing you from "going there", it's merely a warning that it might not be safe. Your analogy is more similar to "there's a slow down on that road, let me navigate you somewhere else, but feel free to go there if you want". You have exactly the same amount of freedom. How exactly is using HTTPS "gain control over the masses"? Google does not control the HTTPS infrastructure. It's not like those sites are gone either. There's always archive.org.
- zerostar07 9y agothe gps could also be just a warning. same effect also we know how these things go. first a warning, then a ban, then extinction from history
- yzmtf2008 9y agoLet's not start the whole slippery slope logic, please.
- zerostar07 9y agodidn't that happen with whatever technology google deemed unfit for the batteries of their phones, like Flash for example?`
- gowld 9y agoFlash was a proprietary non-mobile-friendly technology from the start until its demise at the hands of its creators. No heavy-handed dictatorship, just bad products dying, and products that unfortunately depended on them died along with them. http://blogs.adobe.com/flashplayer/2012/06/flash-player-and-android-update.html#sthash.X0uGKiDQ.tb6utxIW.dpbs http://blogs.adobe.com/flashplayer/2012/06/flash-player-and-...
- ori_b 9y ago> I happen to use plenty of sites that require javascript, with HN being one of them. HN works just fine without Javascript. The only thing that doesn't work is collapsing comment threads.
- chocolatebunny 9y agoI think your last statement highlights the real issue here. Everyone is afraid of malicious javascript. I don't know why they're conflating that with http injection. The most straightforward thing to do would be to disable javascript on non https sites by default or warn if a nonhttps site has javascript. Most of the old sites we want to keep around don't have javascript in them (or much javascript in them). Ideally people should only be enabling javascript on sites they trust (and are running https for "real" "trust") but having a trusted whitelist for enabling javascript brings back your big brother arguments.
- yzmtf2008 9y agoIt's not just javascript though, we've seen ISP (or other malicious actors in the network) inject ads, of even place the entire HTML content of the site into an iframe.
- r00fus 9y agoBingo. This is why it matters to Google. Ad injection could impact their bottom line.
- innagadadavida 9y agoThis is a malware injection problem and it should be possible for google to create signatures of JavaScript from different websites and have chrome verify it and block it. Penalizing all http users is heavy handed and google should not go down that path.
- jhanschoo 9y agoNobody is giving up freedom for security; you can still visit HTTP sites if you want to, its just going to be treated as unsafe by default. As other commenter noted, Comcast has been observed to inject content to its customers; would you rather that on HTTP or that you run HTTPS?
- Santosh83 9y agoWhen a highway is plagued by bandits, the govt must go after the bandits and put them away, not close the highway or turn into a cramped tunnel made of armoured steel with only one narrow lane.
- andybak 9y agoThat's a very narrow view of the options available for law enforcement. Sometimes "going after all the bad guys" is a terrible strategy.
- hagbarth 9y agoSo which central govt should we trust to "put the bandits away" on the internet?
- Santosh83 9y agoI'm saying that instead of doing away with plain-text protocols, maybe national govts can each regulate their ISPs to stop injecting content into the bits they transmit? That would go a long way towards increase of privacy. As for bad state (sponsored) actors, I doubt https can really stop them doing what they want, especially not the big ones.
- deadbunny 9y ago> maybe national govts can each regulate their ISPs to stop injecting content into the bits they transmit? Good one. Next you'll be telling me that those very same companies don't spend billions on getting the laws written the way they want. Sure you could try the top down approach where everyone has the best intentions but that's not going to happen, in the meantime I'm installing bulletproof windows in my car.
- chris_wot 9y agoThe quote is: “Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety” And it was about taxes.
- hannob 9y ago> I think it can be summed up in one old but very relevant-in-our-times quote: "Those who give up freedom for security deserve neither." Now if you could explain to me how using secure connections and showing a correct warning for insecure connections is restricting your freedom that'd be interesting.
- circuitboredcom 9y agoMy ISP offers security certificates for $145 more than I currently pay per year. The result is that I'll have to pay up, or face a drop off in traffic for my sites from people who will be too scared to view them because of this new browser-based warning... My sites are all public information, no secure data is displayed on them, and there are no user accounts beyond those of my team's editing accounts. It would be sort of overkill to require HTTPS on them. Cloud hosting is much more expensive than my current hosting plan. It seems like this is also highly convenient for ISPs that http will be phased out because either way, ISPs make a lot more money out of web site business by the newly required standard. This is the future we knew was coming, where it becomes so expensive for individuals to do the same as companies do. It's how Radio, TV, and many other things were taken away over the years, it simply became too much of a legal hurdle and way too expensive to run until large companies became the only channel owners. It's just history repeating itself, but now to shut out individual web site and application makers who don't have resources to compete with big business. :\
- wishinghand 9y agoMy hosting service makes no money from me installing Let's Encrypt on my sites. Is that available on your hosting provider?