4 ms·
Their claim, from the article: “If others could freely use ‘generic plus BOOK’ marks for online networking services targeted to that particular generic categor
by scott_s 16y ago
Their claim, from the article:
“If others could freely use ‘generic plus BOOK’ marks for online networking services targeted to that particular generic category of individuals, the suffix BOOK could become a generic term for ‘online community/networking services’ or ’social networking services,’” Facebook argued in the lawsuit. “That would dilute the distinctiveness of the Facebook Marks.”
Honestly, that sounds reasonable to me. They're not claiming they own trademarks to all uses of "book," but to uses in the context of online social networks.
They use the word because it was a play on the name and idea of a "yearbook." While TeachBook could claim the "book" part of their name has to do with learning from books, I wouldn't believe such a claim. It looks to me like they put "book" in their name to tell other people "we're similar to FaceBook." That's exactly the sort of thing trademarks protect against.
- nkassis 16y agoI dunno, book is a very common word, if microsoft tried it with Windows if I remember correctly and lost. Windows or Window was too common to trademark. What about a social network for book fans called bookclub or socialbook.com would that be considered infringement?
- JoeAltmaier 16y agoIt comes down to trademark law. Can you trademark a class of names? Or just one at a time.
- tptacek 16y agoIt's not as simple as that. Trademark isn't as clear-cut as copyright. In some cases, you have to have a famous mark (like Facebook, Starbucks, eBay, and Victoria's Secret). Sometimes, you have to be able to present evidence of confusion; in other cases, you have to be able to demonstrate that the infringing use is directly tarnishing your own brand. It is simply not the case that any Internet squatter can decide "I'm going to own the word Bedsheet, because nobody's thought to trademark it yet!" and then go troll anyone who uses a bedding image in their name. You have to actually build a valuable brand first.
- fleitz 16y agoA trademark grants you exclusive use of your mark as well as protection from competitors marks that are confusingly similar. Also trademarks can be lost if not defended, unlike patents and copyright. The dispute between teachbook and facebook likely revolves around being confusingly similar, and could also be in part because they need to actively defend the trademark in order for it to be valid.
- A1kmm 16y agohttp://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/html/uscode15/usc_sec_15_00001125----000-.html http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/html/uscode15/usc_sec_15_0... In the US, one at a time - but there could be a class of names which are confusingly similar to that name. They either need to argue that the similarity "is likely to cause confusion, or to cause mistake, or to deceive as to the affiliation, connection, or association of such person with another person, or as to the origin, sponsorship, or approval of his or her goods, services, or commercial activities by another person" or dilution by blurring an "association arising from the similarity between a mark or trade name and a famous mark that impairs the distinctiveness of the famous mark". The second (trademark dilution) only applies to famous marks (like Facebook), but can be used when the mark is only diluted, and there is no likelihood of confusion. However, "the degree of inherent or acquired distinctiveness of the famous mark" is important - and the distinctiveness isn't just in one particular market. English words are unlikely to be considered to be particularly distinctive, and 'face books' existed on paper before Facebook used the term.
- dstein 16y agoThe fact is they trademarked "Facebook", not "book". Very clearly this is a frivolous lawsuit and scare tactic borrowed from McDonald's who started suing every company and brand name that started with "Mc".
- tptacek 16y agoYou use these words "very clearly" and "frivolous" like they mean something. In fact, no. PerfumeBay, for instance, was smacked down by the Ninth Circuit for diluting eBay. "Victor's Little Secret" was smacked down for tarnishing Victoria's Secret. "Charbucks" is likely to lose to "Starbucks". In this specific case, it's even less frivolous. The Illinois company set up a social networking site for teachers and called it Teachbook. Even they aren't arguing that there's no overlap; they're simply surprised Facebook would care. But of course they do; they are required to defend their trademark or risk someone else claiming that they've abandoned it.
- dstein 16y agoJust because a lawsuit is successful doesn't make it less frivolous. This is not like a company called "AppleSoft" being sued by "Apple". It's more like a company called "AppleSoft" being sued by "Microsoft". It's unfortunate the laws are so ambiguously written to allow abuse of this nature.
- tptacek 16y agoI think you're looking at this situation as if most people had your level of engagement with the software industry; clearly, anyone can tell the difference between Facebook and Teachbook! Once again, no. PerfumeBay was forced to admit under oath that it had fielded support calls from people thinking they were part of eBay. It is not even remotely unlikely that, after spending more than $200 on web design, teachers might become confused about whether Teachbook was a subsidiary effort of Facebook. All this aside, can anyone say with a straight face that "Teachbook", the networking site for teachers, didn't know that they were coattailing off Facebook with that name? Give me a break. If Facebook loses, that'll be interesting, and maybe even a good thing, but don't ask us to feel sorry for these people.
- bad_user 16y agoThe Oxford English vocabulary lists 500000 words. The number of companies and of registered trademarks is probably far more than that, but the number industries/markets a company can activate in is pretty low. Pretty soon you won't be able to use any English word, if as you said ... trademarking a common word such as "book" is reasonable. Also ... if they would have to go for someone, why not go for ... Fuckbook.
- klochner 16y agoActually, "face book" is the term used for a book containing photos/blurbs of all incoming freshmen, handed out to the Freshman class each year at many universities (including Harvard, naturally).
- bobbyi 16y ago> They use the word because it was a play on the name and idea of a "yearbook." What are you basing this on? I'm pretty certain they called it "the facebook" because it was literally meant to be an online replacement for the print facebook. That was how it was explained and used when it started. It wouldn't have functioned as a "yearbook" (a way to find old classmates) because at the time they picked the name it was only open to current college students.
- scott_s 16y agoI'm basing that on the explanations I've read in various news articles about FaceBook through the years.