3 ms·
No, the Equifax breach hurt tons of constituents on both sides of the aisle. The parties had every reason to come together on this. Especially the Republicans,
by sp332 9y ago
No, the Equifax breach hurt tons of constituents on both sides of the aisle. The parties had every reason to come together on this. Especially the Republicans, because the lack of trust will be bad for business. But it seems the ones elected at the moment are beholden to specific donors and not accountable to the people they're supposed to represent.
I'm not clear on how deregulation would hurt Equifax and the other reporting agencies? It seems that enforcing regulations would hurt them in this case.
- rectang 9y agoI realize this isn't immediately realistic, but please brainstorm with me: 1. Change privacy laws so that consumers own their own data. (Something like Germany's BDSG?) 2. Repeal the Fair Credit Reporting Act. The idea is that once consumers have the weapons and wherewithal to sue irresponsible credit rating authorities out of existence, perhaps fewer "regulations" will be needed.
- sp332 9y agoEquifax already has 23 class-action lawsuits pending. But it would be better for consumers if a breach of this type were a crime investigated by the government, so individuals don't have to proactively go to court themselves. By default, incumbents and big players have the advantage in the market, so without regulation I doubt anyone could unseat the Big Three agencies. They can afford to have a some inaccuracies and even a breach here and there and still be hard to beat. Remember the people whose data they lost are not their customers. Using the government to force companies to protect that data could level the playing field and increase competition. As for 1. that is of course regulation.
- mulmen 9y agoYou seem to have conflated the concepts of representation and protection. Congress represents constituents, it does not protect them. If constituents do not demand action here congress will not pursue further action. The CFPB is supposed to be protecting consumers, not congress.
- sp332 9y agoThat's a good point. But rectang was asking about protection becoming partisan, which is playing out in the Senate.