3 ms·
It's not a binary thing. But the main limit of the Zumwalts in missile defense is lacking the right radars and the combat management software. There's a kinda l
by jasonwatkinspdx 9y ago
It's not a binary thing. But the main limit of the Zumwalts in missile defense is lacking the right radars and the combat management software. There's a kinda long history to all this, and it's a little muddled. My understanding of roughly what happened is originally a larger stealth cruiser design was going to handle missile defense, while the Zumwalts would handle strike. Then the cruiser project got canceled, so they started talking about adding the capabilities to the Zumwalts. That fell through when the development contract for the needed radar went to Raytheon (I don't fully understand why this killed it, seems to be something political?).
What no one in the navy wants to say clearly and openly is: the Zumwalts, as well as the 2 LCS designs, are pretty much useless as built. They won't be used for more than training, development testing, and perhaps mine sweeping duties.
Out of all 3 of those classes, the only fully capable ship anyone is talking about is a new, stretched version of the Freedom class LCS that tries to be a mini-frigate. And that's only getting talked about because foreign customers are interested.
It's an incredible waste of taxpayers money.
- Nimitz14 9y ago> It's an incredible waste of taxpayers money. I wouldn't be so negative. The money coming in allowed newbie engineers to get into the field and existing ones to get smarter and increase their skills. Not having such a project would lead to a vacuum in the knowledge required to do those sorts of projects (I don't believe the US has any other project of this sort underway). I'm sure they'll be able to learn from what went wrong to make the next project turn out better.
- bllguo 9y agocome on. There's a silver lining, sure. But it's still a massive failure. It's not a comparison between no project and a disastrous project, it's one between disastrous and successful.
- matt_the_bass 9y agoI don’t think such large metal hulled ships are used for mine clearing. Usually smaller, wood or composite hills are used.