11 ms·
The rise and fall of 18F
- zbentley 9y agoThat's quite distressing. 18F delivered a lot of really important software (identity.gov, for example) and I hoped that the quality of their products would usher in a new era of open-source-first government technological advancement.
- microcolonel 9y agoUltimately, it seems, the compensation was just always lower than industry norms.
- kuschku 9y agoThe fact that the current administration put a full hiring stop, and that 18F had everyone on 2 year contracts, seems to have been much more important. If everyone’s contracts run out after 24 months, and you can’t re-hire them, of course you’ll lose 50% of employees in 12 months.
- chrisseaton 9y agoI thought it was done as a kind of 'tour of duty' equivalent in public services, where you'd leave your company for a few years, and then go back, so you only took a salary hit for a short time?
- tonystubblebine 9y agoExactly. The attrition rate part of the article is wrong. 18F hires on two year terms renewable for a second two years. At the end then, you are required to leave. So by definition the minimum attrition rate is 25%.
- s73v3r_ 9y agoBut during the Obama administration, they were backfilling. It sounds like a lot of people are electing not to do that second term, and they're not backfilling open positions.
- tonystubblebine 9y agoAre you sure you mean to use the word "but" here. What you're saying, true or not, does not contradict what I said.
- s73v3r_ 9y agoI did mean to use the word "but". Like I said, during the Obama administration, they were hiring to replace the people who were termed out, or simply did not renew for a 2nd term. That's not happening now.
- smacktoward 9y agoCompensation in government jobs is almost always lower than what the same person could make in the private sector. 18F's problem is that the appeal of government work is in benefits other than salary: solid health coverage, a pension, job security. But those are really only of interest if you're planning on staying there long term, and 18F's pitch has always been "take a year or two off from your real job and come work with us." It's the Peace Corps for techies, and nobody joins the Peace Corps for the retirement plan.
- verst 9y agoYou cannot stay at 18F for the long term. These are limited term, 'non-competitive service' positions. * Job security only for your 2 year term (unless you renew by another 2 for a max of 4 years). After that, you need to leave government service * Health care coverage was similar to major tech companies in the Bay Area. However, vision / dental benefits were worse. * Pension benefits only start after 3 years of government service, so most working for 18F will likely not receive these. But I agree that for other government positions these are good perks.
- grepthisab 9y agoGS-15 is more than many pay, maybe not bay area or top, top companies. But I had friends there who made $160k-ish and had a hard time moving back to SF to mid-size startups because he would have had to take a pay cut (but with equity filling the gap). Plus it was pretty high impact work, and the ability to work remote on demand, so was hard to find something comparable if you're very mission driven or want a more "relaxed" lifestyle.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoIt's not a bad deal if you're young and single. It wasn't tenable for me to bring my wife and daughter to share a townhouse with a bunch of other USDS [+] staff making $130k/year. [+] I'm aware that USDS and 18F are independent branches.
- grepthisab 9y agoYeah that probably depends on your personal situation of course. But I met many 18F'ers and USDS'ers through my friends, lots of people coming on between startups for a few months, some staying for years. They seem to match your current salary up to the federal civilian max, which appears to be $161,900. So that's not exactly a small amount, especially considering the additional benefits like excellent health care and blameless vacation-taking. Though you won't be getting catered lunches or free drinks/swag. Really just seems to depend on what you value. I've considered joining myself.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- vostok 9y agoIt's not bad if you're just comparing base salaries, but it's hundreds of thousands lower than quite a few private sector jobs if you compare total compensation. Of course given the compensation and maximum length of tenure I imagine that most people are not doing it for the money.
- 9y ago
- darkerside 9y agoIt's unfortunate that the Trump administration doesn't recognize the power of technology to act as a lever. You can invest in agile technology teams, thereby actually reducing headcount of the government overall in the long term.
- chrisseaton 9y ago> It's unfortunate that the Trump administration doesn't recognize the power of technology to act as a lever. Trump seems pretty adept at using the power of technology to act as a lever - look at the power of his Twitter usage for example.
- yeukhon 9y agoThat’s different from the willingness to modernize government’s IT infrastructure.
- dsr_ 9y agoThe Republican Party position for the last two decades has been that government is incompetent to do anything except defense and transfer money to the rich. Therefore, headcount can always be reduced without any particular balancing efficiency gain -- the government just stops doing that function. Doing things more efficiently is a threat to that worldview, so it must be stopped.
- masklinn 9y agoTwo is an understatement. We're in 2018, it brings us to 1998. Reagan's "Nine Most Terrifying Words" quip (I'm from the government and I'm here to help) dates back to August 1986, so this was already a well-entrenched enough view that a sitting president could express it during a news conference[0] — and more state that he's "always felt" that way and that all attendees would know about it. And AFAIK no one batted an eye. The reality is that it's always been a strong overcurrent of american conservatism and the GOP, it went under during the New Deal period (Eisenhower was a new deal-er despite being a republican) but resurged into the 50s alongside people like Goldwater, who pined for the days of the Hoover administration (whom Goldwater considered a friend). [0] http://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/ws/?pid=37733 http://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/ws/?pid=37733
- joss82 9y agoI wonder where the name 18F comes from...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- atonse 9y agoGSA is located at 18th St and F St.
- gowld 9y agoChange it to F-18 to inspire better funding from GOP? And move 17 blocks west to F&35?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- grepthisab 9y agoTheir offices are located on 18th and F streets in DC.
- erikb 9y agoExactly, right?
- Finnucane 9y ago"This sharp decline represents a significant erosion of technical talent in the federal government and, if it continues, will likely impede the ability of the Trump administration to use technology to implement its agenda over the next few years." This is . . . bad? But in the larger scheme, this is bad, since it seemed like 18F was actually making some headway in improving the government's use of internet technology.
- phlakaton 9y agoIt seems pretty unlikely to me that 18F would routinely be called upon to implement a specifically Trumpian agenda. From the little I know of what they do, it's about making government effective in service to the American people. That should be a politically neutral goal. To the extent that even Trump's administration is focused on that, I can support it. However, the evidence I've seen so far strongly suggests to me that it's not.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> It seems pretty unlikely to me that 18F would routinely be called upon to implement a specifically Trumpian agenda. From the little I know of what they do, it's about making government effective in service to the American people. That should be a politically neutral goal. In government, “in service to the American people" in the mission of an agency means, in practice, “in service to the priorities of the current political leadership”. Notionally, democratic accountability should make the latter approximate the former, but in practice results are quite mixed.
- phlakaton 9y agoLet me put it this way: is getting veterans prompter, better access to VA health care a Democratic issue or a Republican issue? Hopefully you'll agree it's both (or neither). Now you could look at improvements we might make to the VA at this time and oppose them, saying that any improvements we make to the government during a Trump administration legitimizes his administration and priorities. As for me, I've had enough of that. It's the "party of 'no'" all over again. If you think the 18F is doing something specifically nefarious, name it. Otherwise, if something is a benefit to the American people, I support 18F, the Digital Service, or whoever taking it on--and I suspect that most of their work falls into this relatively uncontroversial category.
- JustAnotherPat 9y ago18F was a model for success, and of course the current administration can not tolerate that.
- dang 9y agoWould you please stop posting unsubstantive comments and/or flamebait to HN? We don't want partisan flamewars, or any flamewars.
- JustAnotherPat 9y agoSometimes the most logical conclusion is one that incorporates politics. I get HN likes to beat around the bush until after the fact, but in this instance I don't think pointing out a political motivation is all that uncalled for.
- erikb 9y ago40M looking for 18F for some fun? I mean, the name is already not too well designed I'd say.
- supahfly_remix 9y agoI know you're joking, but FWIW the name refers to the agency's location at 18&F Sts. in DC. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/18F https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/18F
- gaius 9y ago18F is the MOS for Army intelligence if I remember correctly. That alone will have put lots of people off.
- dtparr 9y agoI wonder how many people interested in and competent at 18F's mission would be familiar enough with enlisted job codes in the Army to make that connection.
- gaius 9y agoWell, I did. It wouldn’t be that far-fetched - look at some of the work the Army Corps Of Engineers has done.
- dtparr 9y agoYeah, I'm not saying no one would, but of the cross section I mentioned, how many would make the nominal connection and find it negative enough to dissuade them from applying knowing there's no actual functional connection. Not 0, but I wouldn't say 'lots of people'.
- yuvadam 9y agoCreepiness level: high
- mattdeboard 9y agoThis was my big fear when I was going through the extremely and unnecessarily long interview process (started interviewing in May, was told I got the job in July, was given a start date for late October in late September...I took a different job in the meantime) there a few years ago. That, yeah, cool, Obama is forward looking and stuff but 18F just seems like a prime target for the chopping block for a Republican administration.
- s73v3r_ 9y agoWhich is a shame, because the only reason that would be is "because Obama did it, so we must be against it." This kind of forward-thinking technology group is exactly what the government needs more of.
- mooreds 9y agoThat was my major question in the interview process too: "how do you stay relevant across administration changes". His answer was (paraphrase): we save the government money, how could anyone be against that? Looks like folks can be.
- geekamongus 9y agoAs someone who worked in a DOC agency for 5+ years doing security work, much of my job consisted of reviewing software for compliance and security before acquiring/installing it in our systems. Every time someone showed up with something 18F was doing, it involved far more bleeding edge cloudy stuff than we were able to accept. In short, the shiny object that was 18F had a really hard time doing its job of integrating with the resistant, crusty old pillars of Federal Agency policy and technology.
- dwater 9y agoAs someone who works for a company that works with the DoD, the push mentioned in the second to last paragraph is making it's way down the chain and we are seeing a greater acceptance of cloud tech. There isn't widespread adoption yet but they are open to projects moving in that direction.
- geekamongus 9y agoThis was true when I left two months ago, but the challenge, for us anyway, was how we extend our security boundary to encompass cloud technology without breaking the bank. Anything managed at levels higher up and offered as a "service" typically proved to be stringent to operate inside of.
- logfromblammo 9y agoUS federal government really needs its own cloud computing agency full of stick-up-the-butt security and reliability fanatics. 99.999% availability. Formally verified code everywhere. Built on a real-time OS. Guaranteed periodic permanent backups. Anything the gummint does pretty much needs to scale immediately to 400 million users, can never experience a data breach, and needs to stay available constantly, possibly for decades, or maybe even forever. The loss of the 1890 census records by fire is still significant today. If every copy of the quarterly reports for GE from 1982 were lost, the impact would be much smaller. The current cloud service offered commercially today are plenty good enough for even some of the hugest public companies, but not quite good enough for an entity with vastly different goals and needs. The different flavor of requirements might mean that private sector business will never offer a suitable class of service. Currently, some agencies run their own data centers, so the necessary expertise certainly exists, but that is not currently contributing in any way to a common infrastructure.
- buildbuildbuild 9y agoI consider rumors of 18F's demise to be greatly exaggerated. It may take a few years for a shift in power to occur which results in better funding, but the momentum they have already built has inspired myself as well as many others, and I consider that to be a great success. Code For America and 18F: Thank you for your many sacrifices, don't be discouraged. Keep it up.
- blauditore 9y agoOff-topic, but this page's `article` tag has its `title` attribute set to the article's title. Event though it sounds reasonable, that's not how it's supposed to work... :) As a result, I get a useless tooltip when placing the cursor almost anywhere on the page.
- throwawayhello 9y agoThis article seems off the mark. I currently work at 18F and in some ways I see what it's trying to say but it's missing important details. 1) 18F positions are filled in 2 year terms (Schedule A), with the possibility of a two year extension. 18F is about four years old and many people are terming out. My impression is that most people enjoy the work and would prefer to stay, they just can't. 2) Backfilling positions was severely hurt by the hiring freeze. That's been frustrating, but that's not specific to 18F or a judgement on 18F's work. 3) Recent changes in leadership disappointed many people because we appeared to be getting into a good rhythm. But the new commissioner loves the work we're doing and is planning to grow the team by 100 new people - bringing us back to peak levels. Are there challenges? Sure. But there are challenges at every organization and the challenges of 18F are complex and interesting. I love my job and I am working with incredible colleagues. The projects themselves are fascinating and we get to wrestle with complex problems. We lead with technology, but the goal is usually to transform the way an agency or department works. That's massive! The pay is actually pretty good: GS-15 is $164,200 for Bay Area, which is not the highest, but we're hardly struggling.
- Alex3917 9y ago> GS-15 is $164,200 for Bay Area, which is not the highest, but we're hardly struggling. Don't you need a Ph.D. for most GS-15 jobs though?
- throwawayhello 9y agoNo. Just experience. Most 18Fs I know are GS-14/GS-15.
- compsciphd 9y agomost GS-15s I knew grewing up in the DC area didn't have PHDs (and most PHD government employees I knew weren't GS-15s as GS-15s in research fields are rare) As an aside (apologize for the semi humble-brag), I get a lot of mileage out of the fact that I'm the only person who was a GS-1 than many people have ever met, considering if one has a HS diploma, one is automatically a GS-2 :)
- 9y ago
- dragonwriter 9y ago18F always had the air of a demonstration project in all but name: in the long term, government IT needs either are so different from industry that hiring short-tour private industry vets the way 18F is structured to is nonsense, or (and I think this is more likely) are similar enough that what needs to happen is that government hiring and treatment (including, but not limited to, pay) of IT staff (including IT managers, not just technicians) needs to improve so that they are more competitive across the board in hiring the best people, not just having a place where they attract a few people to try to fix the messes that the rest are making, whether through inadequate technical skills or poor management of tech programs and staff. So it probably should have withered, one way or the other. But what seems to be happening is neither of those, but just general neglect. But that is kind of par for the course in this Administration when the office isn't one with enough connection to hot-button partisan issues to be the target of outright malice.
- gowld 9y agoOf course. The hope was that 18F's success would inspire agency leads and political leaders to to change IT government-wide
- kirillzubovsky 9y agoOne aspect the article doesn't seem to cover is how hard it is for the current team to recruit anyone to join. Think about it. They all joined during Obama, and presumably supporting him and Dem principles in place. Now that Trump is the supreme ruler, the current team is slowly leaving, as the article has pointed out. Imagine trying to hire someone to replace you, when you can't tell them with a straight face that if given a choice, you would stay for a second term because you can't wait to leave. Thus lack of hiring.
- phlakaton 9y agoIt could be that. Or it could be that, you know, their career page simply states: We don't have any open positions right now. That would make recruiting a bit difficult. (Source: https://18f.gsa.gov/join/ https://18f.gsa.gov/join/)
- linkmotif 9y agoBut the Trump administration is working on a military parade, so...
- smsm42 9y agoFrom this article, it remains unclear to me what 18f is doing and how it's doing it differently from any other IT shop of any other governmental body. I mean, I get that they do it in agile, modular and user-friendly fashion (did you ever see anybody declare otherwise - that they're going to develop in monolithic, lazy and user-hostile fashion? everybody knows the buzzwords) - but what specifically they do and why it is so important to keep doing whatever they do? Also, it looks like the leadership issues come from the fact that the leader(s), despite declaring themselves to be apolitical, were very much political (they just expected their policy to win so they can pose as apolitical while doing exactly what they wanted), got triggered by Trump being elected and rage-quit the job. Which is entirely within their rights, nobody is obligated to work for Trump or the govt, especially if they hate the guy, but it's not exactly a sign of problems within 18F as such.
- danso 9y ago18F is part of the General Services Administration and was ostensibly tasked to not just work on IT (for GSA, and others) but to develop and promulgate best practices across the federal agencies. A 2015 blog post about "The difference between 18F and USDS": https://ben.balter.com/2015/04/22/the-difference-between-18f-and-usds/ https://ben.balter.com/2015/04/22/the-difference-between-18f... > The [Presidential Innovation Fellows] program was a success, and soon after a group called 18F was created within the General Services Administration (GSA) not only to house the PIFs, both physically and bureaucratically, but also to continue and augment their efforts — to centralize forward-thinking technologists in government under one administrative umbrella, and to provide a vehicle for change that wasn’t tied so closely to the administration and the highly political world in which it operates on a daily basis
- gowld 9y agoThe difference is that 18F builds technology the way they want, on a consulting basis to (non-tech) agencies that need tech. The old way was that non-tech agencies build/buy tech, with all the incompetence that comes from that route.
- book_mentioned 9y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13432881#13433212 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13432881#13433212 >Keverw: I wonder how the USDS is different than the 18F? >>Matt_Cutts: USDS and 18F serve in pretty different roles. USDS often comes in when there's a crisis or a high presidential priority, because the organization sits in the office of the President. 18F is located in the General Services Administration and is especially strong when looking at the medium- to long-term goals of an organization [continues]
- book_mentioned 9y agoIf you want to apply for a job with the USDS specifically (or 18F semi-similarly), this sub-discussion seems helpful: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14672837 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14672837
- mychael 9y agoI would support a privatized version of 18F. One we could measure impact of better and terminate more easily.
- laser 9y agoIt seems unfair to compare 18F attrition to GSA, as people in tech generally have a lot more options than people in other government sectors. For comparison, the ~2 year average retention at 18F is among the best of the big tech companies [1]. Not to say there aren't issues, but this article seems to make things sound worse than they probably are. [1] http://www.businessinsider.com/employee-retention-rate-top-tech-companies-2017-8 http://www.businessinsider.com/employee-retention-rate-top-t...