3 ms·
Prohibiting the third zone (partially taken care of by work and partially by the state) is deadweight loss, leading to both less tax revenue and greater need fo
by closeparen 9y ago
Prohibiting the third zone (partially taken care of by work and partially by the state) is deadweight loss, leading to both less tax revenue and greater need for subsidy. Full welfare dependence is not economically or morally superior to halfway in, halfway out. Designing the welfare and labor protection systems based on this belief leads to all kinds of binary cliffs and thresholds that discourage or punish incrementally improving one’s station.
Heaping obligations onto full time work relationships, for example, just encourages employers to keep anyone from getting too many hours. Needing to assemble multiple part time jobs with unpredictable schedules leaves low-income workers worse off than before.
You can’t legislate benefits into existence without also funding them. There’s this seductive idea that you can extract more from capitalists by setting high minimum standards for allowable transactions (see: “affordable housing”) and they continue to disprove it by just walking away from the transactions instead.
- ppeetteerr 9y agoI would argue that full welfare, depending on how its used or what it provides, is either a blessing or a curse. I Canada, a person can return to a vocational school full time while being on welfare to improve their standing in life. If that same person is unable to better their standing through government services, they have two choices: the black market and the gig economy. Here, the gig economy is a benefit but, the way it's being done now, it's a stand in for regular business. So we're sacrificing regulated, decent paying jobs with unregulated, poorly paying jobs.
- closeparen 9y agoIs it a stand in? My understanding is that there are vastly more workers in the gig economy than the “disrupted” industries previously employed. Seems like a classic case of concentrated downside, diffuse upside, similar to free trade. The existence of the gig economy shouldn’t prevent someone from choosing to be fully welfare dependent for i.e. retraining, if welfare is good enough.