5 ms·
This is interesting. What interventions can be made to reduce this pay gap? With the reasons in the paper, should this gap be corrected (eg, force maximum speed
by prepend 9y ago
This is interesting. What interventions can be made to reduce this pay gap? With the reasons in the paper, should this gap be corrected (eg, force maximum speed, pay higher for slow drivers but only gender specific, etc etc).
- fatjokes 9y ago> pay higher for slow drivers but only gender specific ... that's wage discrimination and is illegal.
- mc32 9y agoIllegal or not it would certainly be gamed.
- T2_t2 9y ago"I identify as a non-binary person - what do I get paid?"
- mc32 9y agoprobably trend toward the one you most closely resemble behaviorally.
- erikpukinskis 9y agoWhat does your drivers license say?
- dragonwriter 9y ago> What interventions can be made to reduce this pay gap? Does the pay gap exist after adjusting for insurance costs and expected long-term driver-born per mile cost not covered by insurance, which Uber drivers bear? Since the cause of the higher pay seems directly linked to the reason for the gender-based difference in insurance rates, this might be something to consider.
- pixel_fcker 9y agoShould interventions be made to reduce the gap?
- mlevental 9y agowhat exactly are you implying? is it that it'll correct itself naturally (free market forces) or that it doesn't need to be corrected?
- pixel_fcker 9y agoI'm implying that it doesn't need to be corrected.
- mlevental 9y agowhy do you think it doesn't need to be corrected? you don't see how an equitable distribution of resources between the sexes is much more productive for the whole? nm the morality of it.
- pixel_fcker 9y agoI believe strongly in an equal distribution of opportunity between the sexes. How would you propose fixing the gap that the paper describes? Simply paying women drivers 7% more? Would that be fair?
- mlevental 9y agoresources should be allocated to correct for this >The second factor is work experience. Even in the relatively simple production of a passenger’s ride, past experience is valuable for drivers. i.e. women should be given training to compensate for the a priori difference in experience. women should also be educated about this >hourly earnings on Uber vary predictably by location and time of week, and men tend to drive in more lucrative locations. the obvious question becomes why aren't women driving during more lucrative times. is it because those times are late nights during which it's potentially more dangerous for a woman driver. this is of course a systemic issue of a larger system. my point is that usually when someone claims "accidental/benign inequality" all one needs to do is expand the scope to discover the malignant root.
- Zanni 9y agoSince the pay gap is fair (in the sense that it's driven by personal preferences and experience), there are only two reasons to reduce it: 1) if you think it's going to cost you women drivers and 2) if you think that men are driving dangerously fast. Point 2 is something that Uber actually has enough data to assess and address, but the better motivation would be safety. Reducing the pay gap would be an ancillary benefit. As for point 1, I think the only option is education. Point out that pay increases with experience, and by how much. Maybe draw drivers' attention to more lucrative areas? Though I think that's contingent on experience as well. Beyond that, any attempt to address the pay gap seems unfair and, as fatjokes points out, possibly illegal.
- neveroffensive 9y ago> What interventions can be made to reduce this pay gap? This is a scary question to me. Is making arbitrary changes to align the world more with your definition of fairness really a good idea? Isn't this the precursor to authoritarian/totalitarian thinking? People chose to drive faster, people chose to prefer faster rides, neither of these things are "wrong" in any way. The market is simply rewarding those who provide service which is most desirable. I'm not saying it's fair, but it's not unfair in a way we should try and control IMHO. Any human attempts to correct the arbitrary injustice/unfairness in nature are only bound to shift/perpetuate it. Edit: My point really is, nature is evil, but by making choices ourselves which harm others to decrease natures evil, we become evil ourselves. It's the classic trolley/surgeon problem. I argue it's better not to flip the switch on the track and let nature take it's course because otherwise you become the arbiter, and a murderer. It seems more heartless with the trolley problem, but it's conforms to intuition with the surgeon scenario.
- tenpies 9y ago> What interventions can be made to reduce this pay gap? I don't see how you could do this without rewarding inefficiency and inexperience. More efficient workers with more experience should absolutely get paid more than new workers that don't do as good a job. Our entire society is structured on this concept.
- danjoc 9y ago>I don't see how you could do this without rewarding inefficiency and inexperience. It's easy though. Just pay women more. Uber can take a smaller cut of your pay if you have two x chromosomes. Another approach would be to allow passengers to chose their driver's gender. More passengers will chose female over male drivers.
- aisofteng 9y agoThat's wage discrimination and is illegal.
- danjoc 9y agoAnd paying women less is legal? https://www.eeoc.gov/laws/types/equalcompensation.cfm https://www.eeoc.gov/laws/types/equalcompensation.cfm "The Equal Pay Act requires that men and women in the same workplace be given equal pay for equal work." "If there is an inequality in wages between men and women, employers may not reduce the wages of either sex to equalize their pay." Seems pretty straightforward. Pay has to be equal. Can't lower wages. Therefore, pay women more. Easy as pie.
- omarforgotpwd 9y agoBetter protections for female drivers that make them less likely stop driving for Uber. For example having an option to favor Women or only pickup women, or only pickup women and men with a high rating, etc so that they can feel more safe driving for Uber. If a female Uber driver has controls that allow her to stay out driving longer than she would normally be comfortable with, she can generate higher earnings and close some of that gap.
- throwaway1748 9y agoYes, but men are statistically more likely than women to be the victim of violence. Male drivers are taking on just as much, if not more of a safety risk driving for Uber, why should special accommodation be made for women?
- omarforgotpwd 9y agoBecause the men are not as bothered by the risk as women and continue driving for Uber whereas women drivers do not.
- tengbretson 9y ago>What interventions can be made to reduce this pay gap? It would actually be pretty simple to eliminate this pay gap. All we would need to do is make it illegal to base the amount you pay someone on things like how much you actually valued their service.