4 ms·
While I appreciate you doing this, is this not "reprinting without permission?" EDIT: Downvotes could mean many things. The next person planning on hitting the
by komali2 9y ago
While I appreciate you doing this, is this not "reprinting without permission?"
EDIT: Downvotes could mean many things. The next person planning on hitting the downvote button, could you spare for me a brief reply letting me know why?
EDIT2: Ugh, now I'm the "downvote edit guy." Obviously irrelevant now, but I don't want to remove the first edit and screw over people saying "I downvoted you because x," so, apologies for violating guidelines and making this mess.
- Quarrelsome 9y agoprobably pay-wall protest. At the very least its a "try-me" position to see how companies who implement pay-walls respond to this obvious outcome.
- komali2 9y agoI have no problem with protesting pay walls, I hate them too. However, correct me if I'm wrong, reprinting wholesale a journal's article is a copyright crime in the USA, is it not? Or I guess it constitutes fair use somehow?
- etjossem 9y agoYou are right. Also, the wall of text can be a little annoying. So I recommend accessing this article via https://t.co/GVSZAdt6EV https://t.co/GVSZAdt6EV (the link from Ohanian's Twitter post), which doesn't paywall it. As a submitter doing a workaround, I'd much rather find a legit link to a non-paywalled version of the article, instead of copying content.
- Quarrelsome 9y agoso is speeding on the highway... and yet.
- komali2 9y agoTrue, I speed all the time!
- Sir_Cmpwn 9y agoWorking around paywalls is a sanctioned HN passtime, and paywalls without workarounds are banned (though I have never seen this enforced, much to my displeasure).
- komali2 9y agoIt surprises me to read that paywalls without workarounds are banned - I've just glanced through the guidelines but haven't seen it mentioned, perhaps there's a submission-specific guideline set I'm not aware of? I rarely submit content https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- etjossem 9y agoThat guideline is in https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> Working around paywalls is a sanctioned HN passtime As is complaining about both paywalls and ads. That said, posting the full text isn't a workaround.
- wand3r 9y agoI honestly regularly flag articles where the OP or somneone else does not put the full text in the comments. This is a community and there has been a huge uptick in news articles posted. While HN doesn't require "tech" articles I have noticed a big uptick in paywalled news articles hitting the FP and on mobile it is really a hassle when >10-20% of the front page is either not-accessible or requires a large amount of clicking. While I understand your argument and why you make it I disagree vehemently and therefore I downvoted you. I believe that either HNers should circumvent the paywall and the content owners will likely benefit from the upvote in exposure for this who can afford/want to pay for it, or otherwise WSJ, NYT and others should be banned from HN.
- kaffee 9y agoWhy are you taking it upon yourself to say such a thing? You're doing free work for the legal industry. Fighting copyright monopolies is hard enough without adding Stockholm syndrome to the mix.
- komali2 9y agoPerhaps I am looking for an opportunity to express even more gratitude, considering the OP could be committing an actual crime to bring us content :) Or, I am curious why the OP is willing to take this risk for us. Really, though, I am just curious if I would get in trouble for doing the same down the line ;)
- squeaky-clean 9y agoWhat risk though? The worst I could ever see coming from this is HN deleting your comment and banning your account. Has anyone ever actually been fined for resharing an article text in a webforum comment?
- komali2 9y agoThat sounds to me like a risk! I like commenting here.
- gowld 9y agoMaintaining civil order is everyone's responsibility, not merely professionals. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peelian_principles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peelian_principles Denying a citizens obligation to be active member of the social order reduces us to passive objects in society. Why are you fighting copyright monopolies? You are doing free work for the any-copyright industry.
- kaffee 9y agoReally, copyright is about "civil order"? Interesting. This is the first time I have heard that particular justification for IPR. edit: ok, that's not true. the MPAA/RIAA advertisements do equate piracy with violent crime.