3 ms·
Windows 95 was no paragon of stability when you started loading it up with tray apps and running big nasty applications or trying to use the damn printer with i
by jandrese 9y ago
Windows 95 was no paragon of stability when you started loading it up with tray apps and running big nasty applications or trying to use the damn printer with its piece of shit driver. We are spoiled these days by how stable our computers are.
I agree with you that keeping the file metadata in a separate fork is far superior to keeping the file metadata in a three character extension, but sadly the world zagged on this one when Apple zigged. I especially like that you could have two files of the same type associated with different applications, so if you created a text file in your IDE it would open back up in that IDE instead of launching the word processor. And you could change it (somewhat clunkily) at will.
Win95 did have some advantages though. The Start Menu was a better organization system than Apple's Application folder for example. Macs of that era were also slow and badly overpriced.
- Momquist 9y ago> I agree with you that keeping the file metadata in a separate fork is far superior to keeping the file metadata in a three character extension Since we're talking about Win95, then the 3 characters limit doesn't apply (long filenames was a major new feature of this OS after all). .jpeg and .html were relatively common for example at the time, and worked fine. I find the extension system still kludgy, but arguing than it was worse in part because of the limited pool, is incorrect starting from Win95.
- jandrese 9y agoYet for the same compatibility reasons most people stuck with .jpg and .htm, at least in the Windows world. Even now it's very unusual to see a .jpeg extension on a filename. The metadata that Macs kept in the resource fork go way beyond file type and creator too. It included things like the file's Icon, creation/modification information (so it would survive a trip over the Internet!), loads of stuff for applications (menus, graphics, sounds, etc...), formatting for plain text documents (so they fall back to plain text on unsupported systems), and so much more. Fun fact: NTFS supports the concept of a resource fork on files, but almost nothing in Windows uses it. I think I've seen more malware hiding stuff in there than legitimate uses in the wild. Worse, even the obvious case of loading a Mac file on a Windows machine it usually fails and falls back to creating the clunky separate directory instead.
- hypervis0r 9y agoYou don't see .jpeg because people are used to .jpg. There's nothing incompatible with long names that we care about. Also, that Windows feature you mention is called ADS - alternate data stream.
- jandrese 9y agoYes, but you also never see extensions like: .jpeg.photoshop.ro.creat127339292.... The filename extension is the bare minimum of metadata for a file and not easy to extend. Even then Unix systems will skip even that minimal metadata and force you to messily search for magic numbers at the start of the file and make a guess.
- dfox 9y agoNTFS does not have resource fork in the MacOS sense nor extended attributes in the unix sense. Instead it allows for file to have multiple named contents that are accessible by same file IO API (in essence the file can behave like a simplified directory). There is no distinction between data and metadata stored this way. In the late 90s MS even intended to not use OLE compound storage fileformat (ie. what office 97/2000 formats are built on) on NTFS drives and instead write the objects into separate streams (reportedly it was not implemented because then windows would have to somehow transparently reconstruct the compound storage when you copy such file to non-NTFS drive or upload it to the internet). Today apart from malvare hidding only major usage multiple streams have are the "this file was downloaded from internet, are you sure you want to open it?" prompts which store the internet-ness of file in secondary stream.
- jandrese 9y agoConceptually the MacOS Resource Fork is basically a directory where all of your filenames have to be exactly 4 characters long. The only difference is that each "file" might be a stack of "files". So you might have a CODE resource that has multiple CODE segments in it. One thing I loved about old MacOS apps is opening them up in ResEdit and so much of how the thing was built.
- msla 9y agoThe resource fork idea is great if everyone agrees on it and everyone preserves them, even across OSes. Or if you're going to Very Deliberately Ignore the Other OSes and go do things your own way. VDIing like that seems to be a very Apple trait. My point is, I'm not sure how well the resource fork model could have ever survived prolonged and sustained contact with the Internet and modern pervasive networking.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y ago> The Start Menu was a better organization system than Apple's Application folder for example. These were not actually that different. The original Start Menu was just a menuized view of a folder hierarchy (which mostly contained shortcuts but could contain any document).